Stave 4 · Key quoteThe narrator
The Phantom slowly, gravely, silently, approached.
The third spirit arrives.
- In plain words
- The phantom came closer, slowly, seriously and silently.
- What it shows
- The three adverbs slow the sentence down and build fear. “Gravely” hints at the grave: the last spirit is silent and serious, like death itself.
Themes The supernatural · Death
Techniques Listing
Stave 4 · Key quoteThe narrator
It was shrouded in a deep black garment, which concealed its head, its face, its form, and left nothing of it visible save one outstretched hand.
The third spirit arrives.
- In plain words
- It was wrapped in a black robe that hid its head, face and body, except for one pointing hand.
- What it shows
- The spirit looks like the figure of Death, wrapped as if in a shroud. Only its pointing hand shows, directing Scrooge to what will happen if he does not change.
Themes The supernatural · Death · Light and darkness
Techniques Listing · Symbolism · Repetition
Stave 4Scrooge
“Ghost of the Future!” he exclaimed, “I fear you more than any spectre I have seen.”
Facing the third and final spirit.
- In plain words
- Ghost of the Future, I fear you more than any ghost I have seen.
- What it shows
- Scrooge fears the future most, because it is unknown and it holds his death. He goes on to say he hopes to become “another man”, showing that he wants to change.
Themes The supernatural · Past, present and future · Redemption and change
Stave 4A businessman
It’s likely to be a very cheap funeral,
Businessmen in the City talk about a man who has died.
- In plain words
- It will probably be a very cheap funeral.
- What it shows
- Men joke about a dead man’s funeral. No one mourns him, and the talk is all about cost, showing the lonely end of a greedy life.
Themes Death · Greed and money · Isolation
Stave 4A businessman
I don’t mind going if a lunch is provided,
Businessmen in the City talk about a man who has died.
- In plain words
- I will go if there is a free lunch.
- What it shows
- The man would only go to the funeral for a free meal. The heartless joke shows that the dead man meant nothing to anyone.
Themes Death · Greed and money · Isolation
Stave 4 · Key quoteThe charwoman
He frightened every one away from him when he was alive, to profit us when he was dead!
A filthy rag-and-bone shop, selling a dead man’s belongings.
- In plain words
- He scared everyone away while he lived, so now we can profit from him being dead!
- What it shows
- The woman has stolen the dead man’s things and laughs about it. His greed drove everyone away, so there was no one to protect his things, or to grieve.
Themes Greed and money · Death · Isolation
Techniques Antithesis
Stave 4 · Key quoteThe narrator
He lay, in the dark empty house, with not a man, a woman, or a child, to say that he was kind to me in this or that,
A dark room, where a dead man lies alone.
- In plain words
- He lay in the dark, empty house, with not one person to say he had been kind to them.
- What it shows
- No one in the world can remember a single kindness from the dead man. The list of “a man, a woman, or a child” shows he is cut off from everyone.
Themes Death · Isolation · Light and darkness
Techniques Listing
Editions differ: Some editions print “to say he was kind” without “that”.
Stave 4Scrooge
“Spirit!” he said, “this is a fearful place. In leaving it, I shall not leave its lesson, trust me.”
Beside a dead man nobody mourns.
- In plain words
- Spirit, this is a frightening place. When I leave it, I will remember its lesson, I promise.
- What it shows
- Scrooge promises to learn from what he has seen. He is changing, but he still does not realise that the dead man is himself.
Themes Redemption and change · Death
Stave 4Scrooge
Let me see some tenderness connected with a death,
After seeing only greed and relief at one man’s death.
- In plain words
- Show me a death that someone grieves over with love.
- What it shows
- Scrooge asks to see someone mourned with love. It shows he now values tenderness, and it leads to the Cratchits grieving for Tiny Tim.
Themes Death · Redemption and change
Techniques Imperative
Stave 4 · Key quoteBob Cratchit
My little, little child!
A small, quiet house in the future, after a visit to the place where a child will be buried.
- In plain words
- My little child!
- What it shows
- Bob’s broken cry of grief for Tiny Tim. The repetition shows how deep his love is, and the scene shows Scrooge what poverty and neglect can cost.
Themes Family · Death · Poverty and social responsibility
Techniques Repetition
Stave 4 · Key quoteScrooge
Are these the shadows of the things that Will be, or are they shadows of things that May be, only?
In a churchyard, before reading the name on a neglected grave.
- In plain words
- Are these things that will definitely happen, or only things that might happen?
- What it shows
- This is Scrooge’s key question: is the future fixed, or can it change? The capital letters on “Will” and “May” stress the difference, and the whole story rests on the hope that the future can be changed.
Themes Past, present and future · Redemption and change · The supernatural
Techniques Repetition · Antithesis
Editions differ: Some editions print “shadows of the things that May be”.
Stave 4Scrooge
Men’s courses will foreshadow certain ends, to which, if persevered in, they must lead,
In a churchyard, before reading the name on a neglected grave.
- In plain words
- The way people live leads to certain endings, if they keep going the same way.
- What it shows
- Scrooge reasons that the way people live leads to certain ends, but if they change course, the ending can change too. It shows his hope of redemption.
Themes Redemption and change · Past, present and future
Techniques Metaphor
Stave 4 · Key quoteThe narrator
read upon the stone of the neglected grave his own name, EBENEZER SCROOGE.
A churchyard, following the spirit’s pointing hand.
- In plain words
- He read his own name on the forgotten grave: Ebenezer Scrooge.
- What it shows
- The final shock: the dead man nobody mourned is Scrooge. The “neglected grave” shows that nobody visits or cares, the loneliness he chose in life.
Themes Death · Isolation · Past, present and future
Stave 4 · Key quoteScrooge
I will honour Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.
Kneeling at a grave, pleading with the silent spirit.
- In plain words
- I will keep the spirit of Christmas in my heart all year round.
- What it shows
- The promise shows his change is meant to last. Keeping Christmas “all the year” means living with kindness every day, not just on one day.
Themes The spirit of Christmas · Redemption and change
Stave 4 · Key quoteScrooge
I will live in the Past, the Present, and the Future. The Spirits of all Three shall strive within me.
Kneeling at a grave, pleading with the silent spirit.
- In plain words
- I will remember the lessons of the past, present and future. All three spirits will work inside me.
- What it shows
- Scrooge promises to keep what each spirit taught: the lessons of his past, kindness in the present, and the warning of a lonely future. The list of three echoes the three spirits.
Themes Redemption and change · Past, present and future · The supernatural
Techniques Listing
Stave 4 · Key quoteScrooge
I am not the man I was.
Clutching at the spirit’s robe beside a grave.
- In plain words
- I am not the man I used to be.
- What it shows
- A short, simple statement that sums up his change in seven words.
Themes Redemption and change · Past, present and future
Stave 4Scrooge
Oh, tell me I may sponge away the writing on this stone!
Kneeling at a grave, pleading with the silent spirit.
- In plain words
- Please tell me I can wipe the name off this gravestone!
- What it shows
- Scrooge begs to change his future. “Sponge away the writing” echoes the warning in Stave 3 that the writing on the boy Ignorance’s brow can still be “erased”: the future is not yet fixed.
Themes Redemption and change · Death · Past, present and future
Techniques Metaphor · Imperative