Show Working
Open the app

GCSE Psychology · Core topicsAQA, OCR and Edexcel

Social influence: GCSE questions with answers

40 GCSE Psychology questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working Psychology bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 40 questions 6 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Social influence questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Social influenceEvery board

What is conformity?

  1. AHelping a stranger who is in trouble
  2. BLosing your sense of self in a crowd
  3. CFollowing a direct order from an authority figure
  4. DChanging behaviour to fit in with a majority
Show the answer

Answer: D Changing behaviour to fit in with a majority

Conformity is going along with a group or majority, usually without being asked. Obedience is doing what an authority figure tells you to do. The key difference is the direct order.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

02 / Social influenceEvery board

At a new school, Leo starts wearing his tie short like everyone else in his class, though nobody has asked him to.

Which kind of social influence is this?

  1. AObedience
  2. BConformity
  3. CDeindividuation
  4. DSocial loafing
Show the answer

Answer: B Conformity

Nobody gives Leo an order; he changes to match the majority in his class. That is conformity to majority influence.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

03 / Social influenceEvery board

A lifeguard blows a whistle and tells everyone to leave the pool, and the swimmers all get out.

Which kind of social influence is this?

  1. AObedience
  2. BConformity
  3. CMinority influence
  4. DDeindividuation
Show the answer

Answer: A Obedience

The swimmers follow a direct instruction from someone with authority in that setting. That is obedience, not conformity, because there is an order from an authority figure.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

04 / Social influenceEvery board

What is deindividuation?

  1. AChoosing to help a stranger in an emergency
  2. BLosing your sense of identity in a crowd
  3. CCopying the majority so that the group will like you
  4. DFollowing the orders of a figure of authority
Show the answer

Answer: B Losing your sense of identity in a crowd

Deindividuation is losing your sense of being an individual when you are part of a crowd, often when you feel anonymous. People may then act in ways they would not alone. Give the full idea, not just “not taking responsibility”.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

05 / Social influenceEvery board

At a football match, fans wearing the same masks and scarves shout insults that none of them would say on their own.

Which idea best explains this behaviour?

  1. AProsocial behaviour
  2. BDeindividuation
  3. CSocial loafing
  4. DAgency theory
Show the answer

Answer: B Deindividuation

Masks, matching clothes and a big crowd make each fan feel anonymous. They lose their sense of personal identity, which is deindividuation, and behave in ways they would not on their own.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

06 / Social influenceEvery board

Which of these is prosocial behaviour in a crowd?

  1. AFootball fans throwing bottles at a line of police
  2. BA group of people smashing shop windows in a street
  3. CPeople pushing past others to get to the front first
  4. DStrangers working together to clear up after a flood
Show the answer

Answer: D Strangers working together to clear up after a flood

Crowds can behave well or badly. Prosocial behaviour helps others, like volunteers clearing up after a disaster. Antisocial behaviour harms others or society, like looting or violence.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

07 / Social influenceEvery board

A dispositional factor is something that comes from:

  1. Athe culture a crowd belongs to
  2. Bthe situation, such as the size of a group
  3. Cthe orders of a figure in authority
  4. Dthe person, such as their personality
Show the answer

Answer: D the person, such as their personality

Social influence is explained by two kinds of factor. Situational (social) factors come from the setting, such as group size or an authority figure. Dispositional factors come from the person, such as personality, self-esteem or morals.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

08 / Social influenceAQA

In Asch’s conformity study, what task did participants do?

  1. AGuessed how many beans were in a jar
  2. BGave electric shocks to a learner
  3. CMatched a line to one of three others
  4. DHelped a man who collapsed on a train
Show the answer

Answer: C Matched a line to one of three others

Asch asked people which of three lines matched a standard line. The others in the group were confederates who, on critical trials, all gave the same wrong answer, leaving the real participant as a minority of one.

Checked against doi.org

09 / Social influenceAQA

Which is a fair criticism of Asch’s line task?

  1. AIt was carried out on a busy city street outdoors
  2. BIt did not use any confederates in the groups
  3. CJudging lines is not like real-life decisions
  4. DThe line task had no correct answer to give
Show the answer

Answer: C Judging lines is not like real-life decisions

Matching lines in a laboratory is a trivial task with little at stake, so the study may lack ecological validity. Participants were also deceived about the confederates and the aim.

Checked against doi.org

10 / Social influenceAQA

In a quiz, the questions get much harder and the answers become less obvious.

What usually happens to conformity as a task gets harder?

  1. AIt decreases
  2. BIt disappears
  3. CIt stays the same
  4. DIt increases
Show the answer

Answer: D It increases

AQA names three social factors: group size, anonymity and task difficulty. When a task is hard and the answer unclear, people are less sure of themselves and more likely to go along with the majority.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

11 / Social influenceAQA

How does giving answers anonymously, in private, usually affect conformity to a majority?

  1. AConformity stays the same
  2. BOnly experts conform
  3. CConformity goes up
  4. DConformity goes down
Show the answer

Answer: D Conformity goes down

When people can answer privately, the group cannot see them disagree, so there is less pressure to go along. Conformity to the majority usually falls. Do not confuse this with anonymity in a crowd, which links to deindividuation.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

12 / Social influenceAQA

Dev is a skilled birdwatcher. His group insists a bird is a robin, but Dev is sure it is a chaffinch and says so.

Which dispositional factor makes Dev less likely to conform?

  1. AHis expertise
  2. BHis anonymity
  3. CThe task difficulty
  4. DThe group size
Show the answer

Answer: A His expertise

Expertise is a dispositional factor: someone who knows a lot about the task trusts their own judgement and is less likely to conform. Group size, task difficulty and anonymity are social factors.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

13 / Social influenceAQA

In Milgram’s agency theory, what is the agentic state?

  1. ALosing your sense of identity in a large crowd
  2. BActing on your own conscience and your own values
  3. CCopying a group so that you fit in with them
  4. DActing for an authority, not feeling responsible
Show the answer

Answer: D Acting for an authority, not feeling responsible

Agency theory says that when we obey a legitimate authority we shift into the agentic state: we act as their agent and feel they are responsible. In the autonomous state we act on our own conscience and feel responsible ourselves.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

14 / Social influenceAQA

Which of these does agency theory name as a social factor affecting obedience?

  1. ASelf-esteem
  2. BMorality
  3. CProximity
  4. DExpertise
Show the answer

Answer: C Proximity

AQA’s agency theory names four social factors: agency, authority, culture and proximity. When the person being harmed is close by, it is harder to deny responsibility, so obedience tends to fall.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

15 / Social influenceAQA

In a shop, a man in a security uniform asks Ali to step aside. Ali does so at once without asking why.

Using agency theory, why does Ali obey?

  1. AHe sees the guard as a legitimate authority
  2. BHe has high self-esteem
  3. CHe is anonymous in a crowd
  4. DHe is in the autonomous state
Show the answer

Answer: A He sees the guard as a legitimate authority

Agency theory says we obey people we see as legitimate authorities, and a uniform is a strong sign of that. Seeing the guard as having the right to give orders moves Ali into the agentic state.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

16 / Social influenceAQA

In Milgram’s 1963 study, how many of the 40 men gave the highest shock on the generator?

  1. A4
  2. B14
  3. C26
  4. D40
Show the answer

Answer: C 26

In Milgram’s 1963 study, 26 of 40 men obeyed all the way to the highest switch on the shock generator; 14 stopped earlier. The learner was a confederate, but many participants showed extreme tension, such as sweating and trembling.

Checked against doi.org

17 / Social influenceAQA and OCR

According to Adorno, which kind of person is most likely to obey authority without question?

  1. ASomeone in the autonomous state
  2. BSomeone with an internal locus of control
  3. CSomeone with high expertise in the task
  4. DSomeone with an authoritarian personality
Show the answer

Answer: D Someone with an authoritarian personality

Adorno’s theory is a dispositional explanation of obedience. People with an authoritarian personality respect authority, see the world in black and white, and are hostile to those they see as lower in status. He traced it to a harsh, strict upbringing.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

18 / Social influenceAQA and Edexcel

What is the bystander effect?

  1. ABeing less likely to help when others are around
  2. BBeing more likely to help when many people watch
  3. CObeying a person in uniform without question
  4. DCopying the majority in order to fit in with them
Show the answer

Answer: A Being less likely to help when others are around

The bystander effect is the finding that people are often less likely to help in an emergency when other people are present. Each person feels less responsible because others could help.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

19 / Social influenceAQA and Edexcel

A man drops his shopping in a busy station. Dozens of people walk past, each assuming someone else will stop.

Which idea explains why nobody stops?

  1. ADiffusion of responsibility
  2. BMinority influence
  3. CThe agentic state
  4. DSocial loafing
Show the answer

Answer: A Diffusion of responsibility

With many people present, responsibility is spread across them all, so each person feels less need to act. This diffusion of responsibility is one reason the presence of others can reduce helping.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

20 / Social influenceAQA

Jas sees someone fall into a freezing river. She is a weak swimmer and fears she might drown too.

Which factor is most likely to stop Jas from helping?

  1. AThe high cost of helping
  2. BHer expertise in first aid
  3. CAnother person helping first
  4. DHer similarity to the victim
Show the answer

Answer: A The high cost of helping

The cost of helping is a social factor: when helping is dangerous, costly or embarrassing, people are less likely to step in. Here the risk to Jas’s own life is a very high cost.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

21 / Social influenceAQA

Bystanders are generally more likely to help a victim who:

  1. Aseems similar to themselves
  2. Bseems very different from them
  3. Cseems to be drunk
  4. Dis surrounded by many people
Show the answer

Answer: A seems similar to themselves

Similarity to the victim is a dispositional factor in bystander behaviour. People tend to help those they see as like themselves, for example the same age or the same group.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

22 / Social influenceAQA

A woman collapses in a busy café. A nurse having lunch at the next table goes straight over to help.

Which dispositional factor best explains why the nurse helps?

  1. ADiffusion of responsibility
  2. BAnonymity
  3. CGroup size
  4. DHer expertise
Show the answer

Answer: D Her expertise

Expertise makes helping more likely: someone trained in first aid knows what to do and feels confident and responsible. Even in a crowd, people with the right skills are more likely to step in.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

23 / Social influenceAQA and Edexcel

Where did Piliavin and colleagues carry out their 1969 study of helping?

  1. AIn a London street
  2. BIn a university laboratory
  3. CIn a mock prison
  4. DOn New York subway trains
Show the answer

Answer: D On New York subway trains

Piliavin and colleagues staged collapses on express trains of the New York subway. Teams changed the victim (ill or drunk, black or white) and whether a model helped, so it was a field experiment in a real setting.

Checked against doi.org

24 / Social influenceAQA and Edexcel

Who was more likely to receive help in Piliavin’s study?

  1. AA victim who seemed ill
  2. BA victim wearing a uniform
  3. CA victim who seemed drunk
  4. DA victim who called out loudly
Show the answer

Answer: A A victim who seemed ill

An apparently ill victim was more likely to be helped than one who seemed drunk. Race mattered little except when the victim seemed drunk. Unlike lab studies, larger groups did not help more slowly, so there was no diffusion of responsibility.

Checked against doi.org

25 / Social influenceAQA and Edexcel

Which is an ethical problem with Piliavin’s subway study?

  1. APassengers did not give informed consent
  2. BPassengers were all paid far too much money
  3. CPassengers were told the aim first
  4. DIt was carried out in a university laboratory
Show the answer

Answer: A Passengers did not give informed consent

Passengers did not know they were in a study, could not consent or withdraw, and may have been upset by the collapse. But because it happened on a real train, the behaviour is likely to show how people really act.

Checked against doi.org

26 / Social influenceAQA

What is social loafing?

  1. APutting in less effort when working in a group
  2. BLosing your sense of identity in a large crowd
  3. CFollowing the orders of an authority figure
  4. DHelping a stranger in an emergency situation
Show the answer

Answer: A Putting in less effort when working in a group

Social loafing is when people work less hard in a group than alone, because their own effort cannot be picked out. AQA names it as a social factor in collective behaviour, along with deindividuation and culture.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

27 / Social influenceAQA

In a tug of war, Ben pulls less hard in a team of ten than he does when he pulls on his own.

Which idea explains this?

  1. AObedience
  2. BConformity
  3. CDeindividuation
  4. DSocial loafing
Show the answer

Answer: D Social loafing

In a big team nobody can tell how hard Ben is pulling, so he puts in less effort. That drop in individual effort in a group is social loafing.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

28 / Social influenceAQA and OCR

During a riot, Sam refuses to join in looting because he believes stealing is wrong.

Which dispositional factor best explains Sam’s choice?

  1. AAnonymity in the crowd
  2. BThe size of the crowd
  3. CThe culture of the crowd
  4. DHis strong moral values
Show the answer

Answer: D His strong moral values

Morality is a dispositional factor in crowd behaviour. Someone with strong moral values is more likely to resist joining antisocial behaviour, even when many others around them are doing it.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

29 / Social influenceOCR

In Bickman’s study, which three outfits did the experimenter wear?

  1. AGuard, firefighter and priest
  2. BPolice officer, nurse and teacher
  3. CDoctor, soldier and civilian
  4. DCivilian, milkman and guard
Show the answer

Answer: D Civilian, milkman and guard

In two field experiments, people in the street were asked to pick up a bag, give a coin to a stranger or move away from a bus stop. They obeyed the guard more than the civilian or milkman, even when he was not watching.

Checked against doi.org

30 / Social influenceOCR

What did Bickman conclude the guard’s power was most likely based on?

  1. APaying people to obey
  2. BHis physical size
  3. CHis legitimate authority
  4. DHis friendly manner
Show the answer

Answer: C His legitimate authority

Bickman argued the uniform gave the guard legitimacy, a situational factor. Oddly, students in questionnaire studies did not rate the guard as more legitimate. Results from one US city in the 1970s may not generalise to other places or times.

Checked against doi.org

31 / Social influenceOCR

According to the NatCen report, how did the 2011 riots in Tottenham begin?

  1. AAfter a power cut left the area in darkness
  2. BAfter a peaceful protest about a police shooting
  3. CAfter a football match between two rival teams
  4. DAfter a music festival was cancelled at short notice
Show the answer

Answer: B After a peaceful protest about a police shooting

The rioting began in Tottenham on 6 August 2011, after a peaceful protest about the police handling of the shooting of Mark Duggan. NatCen interviewed 206 young people in five areas that rioted, some of them in custody.

Checked against gov.uk

32 / Social influenceOCR

Which situational factor did young people say drew them into the riots?

  1. ABelonging to a community group
  2. BHaving a job they enjoyed
  3. CParents being at home with them
  4. DSeeing many others join in
Show the answer

Answer: D Seeing many others join in

Seeing others riot and loot, in person or on social media, nudged some young people in. Having something to lose, such as hope of work, held others back. People also moved between types, so a curious watcher could become a looter.

Checked against gov.uk

33 / Social influenceOCR

Someone with an internal locus of control believes that:

  1. Afate or luck controls their life
  2. Bauthority figures decide for them
  3. Cother people control their life
  4. Dthey control what happens to them
Show the answer

Answer: D they control what happens to them

Locus of control is how much people believe they control events. Those with an internal locus feel in charge of their own actions, so in a crowd they are more likely to decide for themselves. Do not confuse it with conformity itself.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

34 / Social influenceOCR

How is self-esteem usually thought to affect conformity?

  1. ASelf-esteem has no link to it
  2. BLower self-esteem, more conformity
  3. CHigher self-esteem, more conformity
  4. DSelf-esteem only affects obedience
Show the answer

Answer: B Lower self-esteem, more conformity

People with low self-esteem may doubt their own judgement and want approval, so they are more likely to conform. OCR also links self-esteem to the brain, through the volume of the hippocampus.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

35 / Social influenceOCR

Which brain region does your course link with morality?

  1. AThe brainstem
  2. BThe occipital lobe
  3. CThe cerebellum
  4. DThe prefrontal cortex
Show the answer

Answer: D The prefrontal cortex

OCR links morality, a dispositional factor in prosocial and antisocial behaviour, to regions of the prefrontal cortex at the very front of the brain.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

36 / Social influenceOCR

What is minority influence?

  1. ALosing your identity in a crowd
  2. BA few people changing the views of many
  3. CA large group changing the views of one person
  4. DFollowing the orders of an authority
Show the answer

Answer: B A few people changing the views of many

Minority influence is a small group persuading the majority to change. It works best when the minority is consistent and committed over a long time, which makes others stop and think. It can drive social change.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

37 / Social influenceOCR

A small group of people with lived experience of mental illness campaign steadily for years, until many more people feel able to talk openly about mental health.

Which kind of influence is this an example of?

  1. AMajority influence
  2. BObedience
  3. CMinority influence
  4. DDeindividuation
Show the answer

Answer: C Minority influence

A small, consistent group gradually changing the attitudes of the wider public is minority influence. OCR applies it to reducing the stigma and discrimination faced by people with mental health problems.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

38 / Social influenceOCR

A school poster says: “Most pupils here would talk to a friend if they were struggling with their mental health.”

Which kind of influence is this poster using?

  1. AMajority influence
  2. BMinority influence
  3. CDeindividuation
  4. DObedience to authority
Show the answer

Answer: A Majority influence

The poster tells pupils what most people do, hoping they will go along with it. Using the majority to change attitudes and reduce stigma is majority influence.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

39 / Social influenceEdexcel

In Haney, Banks and Zimbardo’s study, how were students given the role of guard or prisoner?

  1. ABy choosing for themselves
  2. BBy their height and strength
  3. CAt random
  4. DBy their personality scores
Show the answer

Answer: C At random

Male college students, screened as stable, were randomly given the role of guard or prisoner in a mock prison in the basement of Stanford’s psychology department. Planned for two weeks, it was stopped after six days because of the extreme behaviour.

Checked against doi.org

40 / Social influenceEdexcel

What did the researchers argue best explained the guards' cruel behaviour?

  1. AThe guards' violent personalities
  2. BThe guards' poor education
  3. CThe roles and the prison situation
  4. DA lack of sleep among the guards
Show the answer

Answer: C The roles and the prison situation

Because roles were given at random, the researchers argued the prison situation, not personality, made guards abusive. Prisoners became withdrawn and distressed, a serious failure to protect participants from harm.

Checked against doi.org

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

9 marks / Piliavin et al.: help on the subwayAQA

Describe and evaluate Piliavin, Rodin and Piliavin’s (1969) subway study of bystander behaviour.

What a full answer includes
  • Aim: to see how features of a victim affect whether bystanders help.
  • Method: a field experiment on New York subway trains; teams of four (victim, model and two observers) staged a collapse.
  • The victim appeared either ill or drunk, and was either black or white; sometimes a model helped.
  • Results: the ill victim was helped more than the drunk one; race mattered little except for the drunk victim; no diffusion of responsibility in bigger groups.
  • A strength explained: passengers did not know they were being studied, so their behaviour was natural.
  • A weakness explained: no consent, no right to withdraw and possible distress.
  • A judgement.

Model answer

Piliavin et al. wanted to find out how features of a victim affect whether bystanders help. They carried out a field experiment on New York subway trains. Teams of four people took part: a victim, a model and two observers. The victim collapsed in the carriage, appearing either ill or drunk, and was either black or white. In some trials the model stepped in to help, and the observers recorded who helped and how quickly. The ill victim was much more likely to be helped than the drunk victim. Race made little difference, except with the drunk victim, where people were more likely to help someone of their own race. Larger groups did not lead to less help, so there was no diffusion of responsibility. The longer no one helped, the more people left the area. The researchers concluded that bystanders weigh up the costs and rewards of helping, and helping a drunk person seems more costly. One strength is that passengers did not know they were in a study, so they behaved naturally and the findings have high ecological validity. However, the passengers did not give consent, could not withdraw and may have been upset by the collapse, and the researchers could not control who was in each carriage. Overall, Piliavin et al. give realistic evidence about helping, but at an ethical cost.

Where marks slip

Generic points such as “field experiments have high ecological validity” score little on their own. Say why for this study, for example that the passengers did not know a collapse was staged.

6 marks / Why Leah conformedAQA

A Year 10 tutor group of 25 votes by show of hands on where to go for a trip. Leah is new to the school and quite shy. She wanted the climbing centre but put her hand up for the theme park, as nearly everyone else did. Sam, who is confident and goes climbing every weekend, kept his hand up for the climbing centre.

Using your knowledge of social and dispositional factors affecting conformity, explain why Leah conformed but Sam did not.

What a full answer includes
  • Conformity means changing your behaviour to go along with a majority.
  • Group size (a social factor): a large majority puts more pressure on the individual.
  • Anonymity (a social factor): an open show of hands means everyone sees your choice, which increases conformity.
  • Personality (a dispositional factor): a shy, less confident person is more likely to conform than a confident one.
  • Expertise (a dispositional factor): Sam knows a lot about climbing, so he trusts his own view.
  • Each factor is applied to Leah or Sam using details from the scenario.

Model answer

Conformity means going along with a majority. Social factors help to explain why Leah conformed. The group was large, and nearly everyone voted for the theme park, so the majority was big, which increases the pressure to conform. The vote was by show of hands, so it was not anonymous: Leah’s choice could be seen by everyone, and as a new pupil she may have wanted to be accepted rather than stand out. Dispositional factors, which come from the person, help to explain the difference between Leah and Sam. Leah is shy, and people who are less confident are more likely to conform. Sam is confident, so he is less worried about disagreeing with the group. Sam also has expertise: he goes climbing every weekend, so he is sure the climbing centre is a good choice and trusts his own judgement rather than the majority. Leah may have been less sure of her choice, so she was more likely to follow the others.

Where marks slip

Answers often name factors without using the story. Each factor should be tied to a detail: the 25 pupils, the show of hands, Leah being new and shy, Sam’s weekend climbing.

13 marks / Situation or personality? A 13-mark essayOCR

Statement: “People obey because of the situation they are in, not because of their personality.”

Use your knowledge and understanding from across the psychology course to explain how far you agree with the statement. In your answer, you should refer to Bickman’s (1974) study into obedience and at least one other study from another area of psychology.

What a full answer includes
  • Explains situational factors (authority, culture, the setting) and the dispositional factor OCR names for obedience, the authoritarian personality.
  • Describes Bickman: people in the street were asked to do small tasks by a man dressed as a civilian, a milkman or a guard.
  • Results: more people obeyed the guard, and it made no difference whether the guard watched them comply.
  • Explains that a uniform, part of the situation, changed obedience, supporting the statement.
  • Evaluates Bickman: realistic field setting, but one US city in the 1970s, and no information about each person’s personality.
  • Gives the dispositional side, such as the authoritarian personality, and why some people still refused.
  • Uses a study from another area, such as Heaven (1996), on how much personality explains behaviour.
  • Reaches a judgement.

Model answer

I mostly agree with the statement. Situational explanations say obedience depends on the setting, such as the authority of the person giving the order. Dispositional explanations say it depends on the person, for example people with an authoritarian personality, who respect rank, follow rules and tend to have had a strict upbringing. Bickman (1974) supports the situational view. In two field experiments, a man stopped people in the street and asked them to do small things, such as picking up a bag, giving a coin to a stranger or moving away from a bus stop. He was dressed as a civilian, a milkman or a guard. Far more people obeyed the guard, and in one experiment it made no difference whether the guard stayed to watch. The man and his requests were the same, so the uniform, a feature of the situation, changed obedience. The study took place in a real street, so people behaved naturally. However, it was carried out in one American city in the 1970s, when attitudes to uniforms may have been different. Bickman also did not measure personality, so it cannot rule out that the people who obeyed had different personalities from those who refused. This matters because not everyone obeyed the guard. Dispositional explanations can account for these individual differences: someone with an authoritarian personality may be more likely to follow an order from a uniformed figure. Research from another area suggests personality explains only part of behaviour. Heaven (1996) found that personality traits explained just over 16% of self-reported delinquency among Australian 14-year-olds, and only 6.61% two years later. If personality explains so little of whether teenagers break rules, it is unlikely to be the main reason people follow them. Overall, I mostly agree. Bickman shows that a change in the situation alone can change obedience, while personality explains only a small part of behaviour. However, the statement goes too far in saying personality plays no part, since it may explain why some people refuse when most obey.

Where marks slip

A common error is giving examples of obedience instead of explaining how a factor affects it. Say how the uniform changed people’s behaviour in Bickman’s study, then judge the statement.

9 marks / Who helps at the station?Edexcel

At a busy railway station, a man sits down suddenly on the floor and looks unwell. Dozens of people walk past. A woman with first aid training, who is waiting alone for her train, goes over to help him.

Assess why some bystanders help and others do not. You must refer to the context and to two areas of psychology in your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Names two core areas, such as the social area (features of the situation) and individual differences (features of the person).
  • Social area: the number of bystanders, how costly helping seems and whether the victim seems to deserve help.
  • Individual differences: expertise, similarity to the victim and mood differ from person to person.
  • Applies the social area: many people walked past, and the busy station may make each person feel less responsible.
  • Applies individual differences: the woman’s first aid training gave her the confidence and skill to help.
  • Piliavin et al. (1969): an ill victim was helped more than a drunk one, and bigger groups did not reduce help.
  • Evaluates: Piliavin et al. found no diffusion of responsibility, so group size may matter less than the cost of helping.
  • Concludes that the two areas together explain the behaviour.

Model answer

Bystander behaviour can be explained by two areas of psychology. The social area looks at features of the situation, such as how many bystanders there are and how costly helping seems. The individual differences area looks at what makes people different from each other, such as expertise or mood. The social area may explain why dozens of people walked past. In a busy station, each person may assume someone else will help, so they feel less responsible. People hurrying for a train may also see helping as costly, because they might miss it. Piliavin et al. (1969) found that bystanders weigh costs: on the New York subway, a victim who appeared ill was helped more often than one who appeared drunk. Individual differences may explain why the woman helped when others did not. Her first aid training means she knows what to do, so helping feels less risky and she is more confident. She was waiting for her train rather than rushing, so the cost of helping was lower for her than for others. However, Piliavin et al. found that larger groups did not lead to less helping, which questions whether the crowd explains why so many people walked past. Their study was in a subway carriage where people could not leave easily, which differs from a station. Overall, both areas are needed: the busy station made helping feel costly for most people, but the woman’s expertise, an individual difference, outweighed those costs.

Where marks slip

Edexcel caps answers that do not use two areas of psychology when the question asks for them. Name both areas, and use the busy station, the people hurrying and the woman’s first aid training in every paragraph.

4 marks / Changing attitudes to mental healthOCR

In a large secondary school, many pupils make jokes about mental health, and pupils who see the counsellor are sometimes teased. Four Year 11 pupils want to change this.

Explain how minority influence could be used by the four pupils to reduce the stigma around mental health in their school.

What a full answer includes
  • Minority influence is when a small group changes the views of the majority.
  • The pupils must be consistent: giving the same message over a long time, such as at every assembly and in every tutor group.
  • They should show commitment, for example by speaking about it even when teased, which makes others take them seriously.
  • Over time, a few pupils change their minds, others follow, and the new view spreads through the school.

Model answer

Minority influence is when a small group changes the attitudes of the majority. The four pupils are a minority, because most pupils joke about mental health. To succeed, they need to be consistent, giving the same message again and again over several months, for example that seeing the counsellor is as normal as seeing a doctor, in assemblies, posters and tutor time. Consistency makes other pupils stop and think about why the group feels so strongly. They also need to show commitment, for example by carrying on even when they are teased, because this suggests they really believe what they say. They should still be flexible, listening to other pupils rather than lecturing them, so they do not seem rigid. At first only a few pupils may change their minds, but as more join in, the view spreads and the majority’s attitude to mental health and to pupils who see the counsellor can shift.

Where marks slip

Answers often describe minority influence in general terms. Use the school: the four pupils, the jokes, the teasing and the counsellor.

9 marks / The situation or the person?Edexcel

A school gives some Year 9 pupils yellow “corridor monitor” badges and tells them to keep order at lunchtime. Within a week, several monitors are shouting at younger pupils and sending them to the back of the lunch queue, although the same pupils were described by teachers as friendly before.

Assess whether the situation explains people’s behaviour in groups better than personal factors do. You must refer to the corridor monitors in your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Situational factors are features of the setting, such as roles, uniforms and authority; personal factors are features of the person, such as personality.
  • Applies the situation: the badge and the role gave the monitors power, and the friendly pupils changed once they had it.
  • Haney, Banks and Zimbardo (1973): male students screened as stable were randomly made guards or prisoners in a mock prison; it was stopped after six days as guards became abusive.
  • Explains why this supports the situation: random allocation means personality could not explain who became a guard.
  • Evaluates Haney et al.: the guards may have been acting out what they thought guards do (demand characteristics), and the study caused distress.
  • Personal factors: an authoritarian personality may make some people more likely to abuse power; not all monitors shouted.
  • A justified judgement, such as the situation having a strong effect that personal factors make stronger or weaker.

Model answer

Situational factors are features of the setting, such as roles, uniforms and authority. Personal factors are features of the individual, such as personality. The corridor monitors were described as friendly before, but once they had a badge and a role with power, several began shouting at younger pupils. This suggests the situation changed their behaviour. Haney, Banks and Zimbardo (1973) support this. Male students who had been screened as psychologically stable were randomly given the role of guard or prisoner in a mock prison in the basement of Stanford University. The study was planned to last two weeks but was stopped after six days, because guards became abusive and prisoners became distressed. As the roles were given at random, the guards’ behaviour is unlikely to be explained by their personalities, so the role itself seems to have caused it, just as the badge seems to have changed the monitors. However, the guards may have been acting out what they thought guards were supposed to do, which is a demand characteristic, so the study may show role-play rather than real behaviour. It also caused real distress, so it could not be repeated today to check the results. Personal factors also matter. Only several monitors shouted, not all of them, which suggests differences between people. Someone with an authoritarian personality, who respects rank and looks down on those below them, may be more likely to misuse a position of power. Overall, the situation explains the monitors’ change well, because the same friendly pupils behaved differently once they had a role, but personal factors help explain why some monitors abused their power and others did not.

Where marks slip

Answers often describe Haney et al. at length without using it to judge the question. Say what it shows about the situation and then apply it to the monitors.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 42 questions in Show Working

This page shows 40 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE Psychology topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free