Show Working
Open the app

GCSE Sociology · TopicsAQA and Eduqas

Crime and deviance: GCSE questions with answers

40 GCSE Sociology questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working Sociology bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 40 questions 6 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Crime and deviance questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Breaking the criminal law is called:

  1. Alabelling
  2. Bcrime
  3. Canomie
  4. Ddeviance
Show the answer

Answer: B crime

Crime means breaking the law. Deviance means going against social norms, so it is wider: some deviance is criminal, but much of it, such as rudeness, breaks no law at all.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

02 / Crime and devianceEvery board

A guest turns up to a formal wedding dinner wearing pyjamas.

How would a sociologist describe this behaviour?

  1. AA white-collar crime
  2. BBoth criminal and deviant
  3. CCriminal but not deviant
  4. DDeviant but not criminal
Show the answer

Answer: D Deviant but not criminal

Wearing pyjamas to a formal dinner breaks the dress norms of the occasion, so it is deviant, but no law forbids it. Examiners warn that deviance is not always legal: some deviant acts are crimes and others break no law.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

03 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Smoking inside pubs in England was legal for many years. The Health Act 2006 made it unlawful from 2007.

What does this show about crime?

  1. ALaws are made by nature, not people
  2. BCrime is the same in every era
  3. CWhat counts as crime changes over time
  4. DOnly young people break laws
Show the answer

Answer: C What counts as crime changes over time

Crime and deviance are socially constructed: what counts as wrong varies with time, place and the people judging. The smoking ban turned a normal act into an offence overnight because the law changed, not the act.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

04 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Which is an example of formal social control?

  1. AFriends ignoring someone
  2. BNeighbours gossiping
  3. CA police officer giving a caution
  4. DParents grounding a teenager
Show the answer

Answer: C A police officer giving a caution

Formal social control uses written rules and laws, enforced by bodies such as the police and courts. Informal social control comes from family, friends and the wider community through approval, disapproval, teasing and gossip.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

05 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Which of these is an agency of formal social control?

  1. AThe courts
  2. BThe family
  3. CReligion
  4. DThe peer group
Show the answer

Answer: A The courts

The courts, the police and the prison service are agencies of formal social control: they enforce the law. The family, peer group, religion and media control behaviour informally, by shaping what people see as acceptable.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

06 / Crime and devianceEvery board

A court orders an offender to do unpaid work in the community. This is:

  1. Aa formal positive sanction
  2. Ban informal positive sanction
  3. Ca formal negative sanction
  4. Dan informal negative sanction
Show the answer

Answer: C a formal negative sanction

Formal sanctions come from official bodies such as courts, police and schools, backed by written rules. Informal sanctions come from family, friends and others around us, such as praise, teasing or being ignored. Both are part of social control.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

07 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Merton argued that crime happens when people:

  1. Aare labelled as deviant by the police
  2. Bare more tightly controlled at home
  3. Ccannot reach shared goals by legal means
  4. Dare exploited by the ruling class
Show the answer

Answer: C cannot reach shared goals by legal means

In 1938 Robert Merton, a functionalist, argued that society sets everyone the same goal of material success but blocks some people’s legitimate means of reaching it. This strain between goals and means pushes some people into deviance.

Checked against doi.org

08 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Sam wants to be rich but cannot find a well-paid job, so starts selling fake designer goods.

Which of Merton’s adaptations does Sam show?

  1. ARitualism
  2. BInnovation
  3. CRebellion
  4. DRetreatism
Show the answer

Answer: B Innovation

Merton called this innovation: the person still wants society’s goal of wealth but turns to illegal means to get it. He linked it to crimes such as theft and fraud.

Checked against doi.org

09 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Jo has given up any hope of promotion at work but still turns up every day and follows every rule.

Which of Merton’s adaptations does Jo show?

  1. ARitualism
  2. BInnovation
  3. CRebellion
  4. DRetreatism
Show the answer

Answer: A Ritualism

Merton called this ritualism: the person has given up on the goal of success but still keeps to the approved means, going through the motions. It is deviant in attitude, though not criminal.

Checked against doi.org

10 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Which of Merton’s adaptations rejects both society’s goals and its means, and drops out?

  1. ARitualism
  2. BInnovation
  3. CRebellion
  4. DRetreatism
Show the answer

Answer: D Retreatism

Retreatists reject both the goals and the means and withdraw from society. Rebels also reject both, but put new goals and means in their place, for example by trying to change society.

Checked against doi.org

11 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Ali works hard at school, then in a job, to earn a good living.

Which of Merton’s adaptations does Ali show?

  1. ARitualism
  2. BConformity
  3. CInnovation
  4. DRetreatism
Show the answer

Answer: B Conformity

Conformity means accepting both society’s goal of success and the legitimate means of reaching it, such as education and work. Merton said it is the most common response and the only one that is not deviant.

Checked against doi.org

12 / Crime and devianceEvery board

What is the term for normlessness, when shared rules break down?

  1. AStatus frustration
  2. BAlienation
  3. CAnomie
  4. DPatriarchy
Show the answer

Answer: C Anomie

Anomie means normlessness: a state where shared norms are weak or unclear, so people are unsure how to behave. Durkheim developed the idea, and Merton built on it in his strain theory.

Checked against doi.org

13 / Crime and devianceEduqas

Durkheim argued some crime is useful to society because:

  1. Ait gives the police more power
  2. Bit makes the ruling class richer
  3. Cit keeps women in the home
  4. Dreactions to it remind people of shared rules
Show the answer

Answer: D reactions to it remind people of shared rules

Functionalists such as Durkheim argued that a limited amount of crime is functional. When people condemn an offence together, the boundaries of acceptable behaviour are made clear and social solidarity is strengthened.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

14 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Albert Cohen argued that working-class boys who fail at school feel:

  1. Aa dual burden
  2. Bfalse class consciousness
  3. Cstatus frustration
  4. Drelative poverty
Show the answer

Answer: C status frustration

In Delinquent Boys (1955) Albert Cohen argued that working-class boys share mainstream goals but often fail at school. The resulting status frustration leads some to form delinquent subcultures, where they gain status by breaking the rules.

Checked against doi.org

15 / Crime and devianceAQA

AQA’s specification places Albert Cohen’s study under which perspective?

  1. AFunctionalist
  2. BFeminist
  3. CInteractionist
  4. DMarxist
Show the answer

Answer: A Functionalist

AQA labels Albert Cohen’s Delinquent Boys as functionalist, because he builds on Merton’s idea that shared goals and blocked opportunities cause deviance. Naming the perspective often earns the last mark on a key-study question.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

16 / Crime and devianceEduqas

On the Eduqas course, Albert Cohen is studied as part of which explanation of crime?

  1. AFeminist theory
  2. BSubcultural theory
  3. CLabelling theory
  4. DMarxist theory
Show the answer

Answer: B Subcultural theory

Eduqas places Albert Cohen under subcultural theory: he explained delinquency through groups whose values give status for breaking rules. His ideas grew out of Merton’s functionalist strain theory.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

17 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Becker argued that an act becomes deviant when:

  1. Aothers label it as deviant
  2. Bit is caused by poverty
  3. Cit breaks the criminal law
  4. Dit harms the economy
Show the answer

Answer: A others label it as deviant

In Outsiders (1963) Howard Becker, an interactionist, argued that no act is deviant in itself: it becomes deviant when others label it so. Whether a label sticks depends on who does the act, where, and who reacts.

Checked against doi.org

18 / Crime and devianceEvery board

When a label such as “offender” overrides every other part of a person’s identity, it becomes a:

  1. Astatus frustration
  2. Brole conflict
  3. Cmaster status
  4. Dachieved status
Show the answer

Answer: C master status

Becker argued that a deviant label can become a master status: others see only the label. Treated this way, the person may join others with the same label and move further into deviance, which he called a deviant career.

Checked against doi.org

19 / Crime and devianceEvery board

A teenager is called a troublemaker by teachers and police. They start to see themselves that way and break more rules.

Which idea does this show?

  1. AThe chivalry thesis
  2. BStatus frustration
  3. CAnomie
  4. DSelf-fulfilling prophecy
Show the answer

Answer: D Self-fulfilling prophecy

A self-fulfilling prophecy is when a label comes true because the person and others act on it. Interactionists such as Becker use it to explain how labelling can create more deviance.

Checked against doi.org

20 / Crime and devianceEvery board

An exaggerated public and media reaction to a group seen as a threat to society is a:

  1. Adark figure
  2. Bglass ceiling
  3. Cmaster status
  4. Dmoral panic
Show the answer

Answer: D moral panic

In 1972 Stanley Cohen studied the reaction to fights between mods and rockers. Newspapers exaggerated the threat, creating a moral panic in which the young people were cast as folk devils.

Checked against doi.org

21 / Crime and devianceEvery board

When media coverage of deviance leads to more of it, sociologists call this:

  1. Astratified diffusion
  2. Bsocial cohesion
  3. Csecularisation
  4. Ddeviancy amplification
Show the answer

Answer: D deviancy amplification

Deviancy amplification is when the reaction to deviance, often from the media and police, makes it grow. Extra attention can make a group more visible, more policed and more likely to see itself as deviant.

Checked against doi.org

22 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Marxists argue that the law mainly:

  1. Ais enforced equally on all classes
  2. Bkeeps men in control of women
  3. Creflects values everyone shares
  4. Dserves the interests of the ruling class
Show the answer

Answer: D serves the interests of the ruling class

Marxists see the law as made and enforced in the interests of the ruling class. They argue the crimes of the poor are targeted, while the crimes of the powerful, such as tax evasion, are less often prosecuted.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

23 / Crime and devianceEduqas

Chambliss studied two groups of boys, the Saints and the Roughnecks. What did he find?

  1. ABoth groups were treated the same
  2. BGirls were treated more leniently
  3. CThe middle-class boys’ offending was overlooked
  4. DThe working-class boys did all the offending
Show the answer

Answer: C The middle-class boys’ offending was overlooked

William Chambliss (1973) found the middle-class Saints offended at least as much as the working-class Roughnecks, yet police and teachers saw the Saints as harmless. He used this to show differential enforcement of the law.

Checked against doi.org

24 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Heidensohn argued that women commit less crime than men because they:

  1. Aare let off by the police
  2. Bare born more law-abiding
  3. Cface more strain to succeed
  4. Dare more tightly controlled
Show the answer

Answer: D are more tightly controlled

In Women and Crime (1985) Frances Heidensohn, a feminist, argued that women are controlled at home by housework and childcare, in public by fear and concern for their reputation, and at work by male bosses. This leaves less chance to offend.

Checked against doi.org

25 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Carlen argued some working-class women offend when two “deals” fail. What are they?

  1. AThe gender deal and the age deal
  2. BThe work deal and the school deal
  3. CThe class deal and the gender deal
  4. DThe class deal and the race deal
Show the answer

Answer: C The class deal and the gender deal

Pat Carlen (1988), a feminist, interviewed 39 convicted women in unstructured interviews. She argued they offended when neither the class deal (a decent living from work) nor the gender deal (the rewards of family life) had been offered to them.

Checked against doi.org

26 / Crime and devianceEvery board

The idea that a mostly male justice system treats women more leniently is called:

  1. Astrain theory
  2. Blabelling theory
  3. Cthe chivalry thesis
  4. Dcontrol theory
Show the answer

Answer: C the chivalry thesis

The chivalry thesis, usually linked to Otto Pollak (1950), suggests that police, courts and judges, mostly men, treat women offenders more gently. If true, official statistics would under-count women’s crime.

Checked against doi.org

27 / Crime and devianceEvery board

What pattern do official statistics show for gender and crime in England and Wales?

  1. AMen make up most convicted offenders
  2. BWomen make up most convicted offenders
  3. CMen and women offend in equal numbers
  4. DWomen make up most of the prison population
Show the answer

Answer: A Men make up most convicted offenders

Ministry of Justice figures show men make up the large majority of people convicted and in prison. Sociologists explain this pattern in different ways: Heidensohn points to tighter control of women, while the chivalry thesis suggests women’s crime is under-counted.

Checked against gov.uk

28 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Official statistics show more recorded offending by young people than older people. Which is a sociological explanation?

  1. ALaws only apply to people under 25
  2. BYoung people spend more time in public view
  3. CYoung people are born with criminal genes
  4. DOlder people are never stopped by police
Show the answer

Answer: B Young people spend more time in public view

Recorded offending is highest among teenagers and young adults. Sociologists point to social reasons, such as peer group pressure, more time spent in public places where police see them, and being the focus of police attention.

Checked against assets.publishing.service.gov.uk

29 / Crime and devianceEvery board

In England and Wales, the age of criminal responsibility is:

  1. A8
  2. B10
  3. C12
  4. D14
Show the answer

Answer: B 10

Children under 10 cannot be charged with a crime in England and Wales. The Children and Young Persons Act 1963 raised the age from eight to ten, which shows how the law decides who can count as an offender.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

30 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Racism built into the rules and everyday practices of an organisation, such as a police force, is called:

  1. Aa moral panic
  2. Bfalse consciousness
  3. Cscapegoating
  4. Dinstitutional racism
Show the answer

Answer: D institutional racism

The Macpherson report (1999) into the police investigation of Stephen Lawrence’s murder found the Metropolitan Police institutionally racist. Sociologists also give other explanations for ethnic patterns in crime figures, such as poverty and how police use their powers.

Checked against gov.uk

31 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Crime that is never reported to the police, or never recorded by them, is called:

  1. Athe dark figure of crime
  2. Bcorporate crime
  3. Crecorded crime
  4. Dwhite-collar crime
Show the answer

Answer: A the dark figure of crime

The dark figure is crime that never appears in police figures because it is not reported or not recorded. Victims may think it too trivial, fear revenge, or not know a crime happened, and police may decide not to record it.

Checked against ons.gov.uk

32 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Which is a weakness of police recorded crime figures?

  1. AThey are published once a decade
  2. BThey miss crime that is never reported
  3. CThey only cover crimes against shops
  4. DThey cost the public money to read
Show the answer

Answer: B They miss crime that is never reported

Police recorded crime only counts offences that are reported and recorded, and it changes when recording rules or police priorities change. The ONS still uses it for offences the survey cannot cover, such as homicide.

Checked against ons.gov.uk

33 / Crime and devianceEvery board

The Crime Survey for England and Wales asks people:

  1. Ato count arrests in their street
  2. Bto read out police records
  3. Cabout crimes they have experienced
  4. Dabout crimes they have committed
Show the answer

Answer: C about crimes they have experienced

The Crime Survey for England and Wales interviews people aged 16 and over in private households about crimes they have experienced, including ones never reported. It cannot cover homicide, crimes against businesses or people living in institutions, so the ONS uses police figures for those.

Checked against ons.gov.uk

34 / Crime and devianceEvery board

A study asking people which crimes they have committed themselves is a:

  1. Acontent analysis
  2. Bvictim survey
  3. Ccensus
  4. Dself-report study
Show the answer

Answer: D self-report study

Self-report studies ask people, often anonymously, what offences they have committed. They reveal crime that was never detected, but people may exaggerate, hide serious offences or forget, which lowers validity.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

35 / Crime and devianceEvery board

A bank manager secretly moves customers’ money into their own account.

What kind of crime is this?

  1. AWhite-collar crime
  2. BCorporate crime
  3. CStreet crime
  4. DYouth crime
Show the answer

Answer: A White-collar crime

White-collar crime is committed by people in good jobs, using their position for their own gain, such as fraud or embezzlement. It is different from corporate crime, which is done by or for a company.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

36 / Crime and devianceEvery board

A company ignores safety laws to save money, and a worker is injured.

What kind of crime is this?

  1. AWhite-collar crime
  2. BCorporate crime
  3. CStreet crime
  4. DYouth crime
Show the answer

Answer: B Corporate crime

Corporate crime is committed by or for a company, such as breaking safety laws or fixing prices. Marxists argue the crimes of the powerful are hard to detect, often have no single victim and are rarely prosecuted, so they are invisible in official figures.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

37 / Crime and devianceEduqas

Official statistics suggest the “typical offender” is:

  1. Ayoung, male and working class
  2. Bolder, female and middle class
  3. Cmiddle-aged, wealthy and female
  4. Dretired, male and upper class
Show the answer

Answer: A young, male and working class

Official statistics suggest most recorded offenders are young, male and working class. Sociologists question whether this shows who really commits crime, or whom the police target and record, since white-collar crime is often missed.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

38 / Crime and devianceAQA

A serious offence that can be tried in the Crown Court before a judge and jury is:

  1. Aa police caution
  2. Ba non-indictable offence
  3. Ca probation order
  4. Dan indictable offence
Show the answer

Answer: D an indictable offence

Indictable offences are the more serious crimes, such as robbery, that can be tried in the Crown Court. Less serious, non-indictable offences are dealt with by magistrates. A caution is an official warning that avoids a court case.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

39 / Crime and devianceAQA

Supervision of an offender in the community, by an officer they must report to, is called:

  1. Aa caution
  2. Ba fine
  3. Cprobation
  4. Da jury trial
Show the answer

Answer: C probation

Probation means an offender is supervised in the community by a probation officer, often as part of a community sentence or after release from prison. It is part of the public debate about prisons and how to stop reoffending.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

40 / Crime and devianceEvery board

Put these studies of crime and deviance in date order, earliest first:

  1. AAlbert Cohen’s Delinquent Boys
  2. BBecker’s Outsiders
  3. CHeidensohn’s Women and Crime
  4. DCarlen’s Women, Crime and Poverty
  5. EMerton on strain and anomie
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Merton on strain and anomie
  2. Albert Cohen’s Delinquent Boys
  3. Becker’s Outsiders
  4. Heidensohn’s Women and Crime
  5. Carlen’s Women, Crime and Poverty

Merton wrote in 1938, Albert Cohen in 1955, Becker in 1963, Heidensohn in 1985 and Carlen in 1988. The order shows sociology moving from functionalist ideas to labelling, then to feminist studies of women and crime.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

3 marks / The dark figure of crimeAQA

Describe what is meant by the dark figure of crime.

What a full answer includes
  • Defines the dark figure as crime that is never reported to or recorded by the police.
  • Gives a reason why a crime may go unreported or unrecorded.
  • Gives an example.
  • Notes the effect: police recorded crime underestimates the true amount of crime.

Model answer

The dark figure of crime is the crime that takes place but never appears in police recorded crime, because it is not reported to the police or, if it is reported, is not recorded by them. Victims may not report a crime because they think it is too trivial, do not realise they are a victim, or believe the police can do nothing. For example, many people who lose a small sum through an online fraud never report it. This means official statistics underestimate the true amount of crime, which is why sociologists also use victim surveys such as the Crime Survey for England and Wales.

Where marks slip

Give a clear description and an example. “Crime that is hidden” with nothing more is too vague for full marks.

4 marks / Victim surveys and hidden crimeAQA

Identify and explain one advantage of using victim surveys to research the amount of crime in society.

What a full answer includes
  • Identifies one advantage, such as uncovering crime that was never reported to the police.
  • Explains why: people tell the survey about crimes against them that they did not report.
  • Links it to researching the amount of crime, including the dark figure.
  • Uses a term such as validity or the dark figure, and names a survey such as the Crime Survey for England and Wales.

Model answer

One advantage is that victim surveys can reveal crime that is missing from police recorded crime. In a victim survey such as the Crime Survey for England and Wales, a large sample of people is asked whether they have been a victim of crime in the last year, whether or not they told the police. Many people tell the interviewer about thefts, damage or frauds that they never reported. This uncovers part of the dark figure of crime, so a victim survey can give a more valid picture of the true amount of crime than police figures alone. For example, the survey estimated about 9.7 million incidents of crime in the year ending June 2026.

Where marks slip

Make the advantage about researching crime. “They are cheap” or “they are quick” could fit any topic and will not reach full marks without a link to the amount of crime.

4 marks / Carlen on women and crimeAQA

Item B Pat Carlen (1988) carried out unstructured interviews with 39 women aged 15 to 46 who had been convicted of crimes. Most were working class. She argued that many had turned to crime when the rewards that women are promised for conforming had not been available to them.

From Item B, identify and describe one idea in Carlen’s research, including what you know of the perspective Carlen worked within.

What a full answer includes
  • Identifies the class deal or the gender deal, which Item B hints at.
  • Describes the idea in your own words: women are promised rewards in return for conforming.
  • Explains how the deal failing made crime seem worth the risk to some of the women.
  • States that Carlen was a feminist sociologist and links this to her focus on women’s lives.

Model answer

One idea in Carlen’s research is the gender deal. Carlen argued that women are promised rewards for conforming to their expected role, such as the love, support and financial security of family life, in return for caring for a partner and children. Many of the women she interviewed had never been offered this deal or had found it broken, for example because they had grown up in care or lived in poverty for years, so they felt they had little to lose by breaking the law. Carlen was a feminist sociologist. Her focus on how women’s lives are shaped by class and patriarchy, and on women’s own accounts, fits the feminist view that women’s crime must be understood from women’s experience.

Where marks slip

Use your own words rather than copying the item, and say that Carlen was a feminist: the perspective is the mark examiners most often see lost. Do not mix her up with Heidensohn, who wrote about why most women conform.

12 marks / Is crime caused by blocked opportunitiesAQA

Discuss how far sociologists would agree that crime is mainly caused by a lack of opportunities to succeed by legal means.

What a full answer includes
  • Uses Merton: shared goals of success, blocked legitimate means, strain and five adaptations.
  • Explains innovation as the adaptation that leads to crimes such as theft.
  • Uses Albert Cohen: status frustration and delinquent subcultures among working-class boys.
  • Criticises: Merton cannot explain why many never offend, or white-collar crime by the successful.
  • Uses a Marxist view: capitalism encourages greed at every level and crimes of the powerful are under-policed.
  • Uses Heidensohn: women have faced blocked opportunities yet commit less crime, because of social control.
  • Uses Becker: crime is partly created by labelling, which shifts the question of cause.
  • Compares the views and concludes how far, with a judgement on “mainly”.

Model answer

Some sociologists argue that crime is mainly caused when people cannot reach society’s goals by legal means. This view comes from functionalist and subcultural theories, but other perspectives challenge it. Merton (1938) argued that American society encourages everyone to aim for the same goal of material success, but does not give everyone the same legitimate means, such as a good education and a well-paid job. This mismatch creates strain. Merton identified five ways people adapt: conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism and rebellion. Innovators accept the goal but use illegal means to reach it, for example theft or fraud. This helps explain why property crime is more common among people with fewer opportunities. Albert Cohen (1955) built on Merton. He argued that many working-class boys share mainstream goals but fail at school, so they suffer status frustration. They form delinquent subcultures that turn mainstream values upside down and give status for breaking rules. This explains group offending, such as vandalism, that Merton’s focus on money cannot. However, both theories have weaknesses. Merton cannot explain why many people with blocked opportunities never commit crime, or why successful people commit white-collar and corporate crime. Marxists argue that capitalism encourages greed at every level of society and that crimes of the powerful are under-policed, so blocked opportunities are not the main cause. Heidensohn (1985) also challenges the view. Women have often had fewer opportunities than men in work and pay, yet they commit far less crime. She argued that this is because women are more closely controlled at home, in public and at work, so social control rather than blocked opportunity is the key. Interactionists such as Becker (1963) shift the question altogether: an act is deviant only when others label it so, and the label can push a person into a deviant career. On this view, the people seen as criminals are partly those who have been labelled, not simply those with blocked opportunities. Overall, sociologists would agree only to a limited extent. Merton and Cohen offer a useful explanation of some property and group crime, and they rightly link crime to inequality. But their view cannot explain crimes of the powerful, the low female crime rate or the effect of labelling, so a lack of legal opportunities is one cause of crime rather than the main one.

Where marks slip

Do not just describe Merton’s five adaptations. Use them to answer the question, set other perspectives against them, and finish with a judgement on the word “mainly”.

8 marks / Why white-collar crime stays hiddenEduqas

Explain why white-collar and corporate crime are often invisible. Explore at least two reasons.

What a full answer includes
  • Separates white-collar crime (by individuals in their jobs, for their own gain) from corporate crime (by or for a company).
  • Victims often do not know they have been harmed, so the crime is never reported.
  • The crimes happen in private offices and complex records, so they are hard to detect and prove.
  • Many cases are dealt with inside the company or by regulators, so they are not recorded as crime.
  • Marxists argue that the powerful shape how laws are enforced and the media focus on street crime.
  • Each reason is linked to why the crime stays out of official statistics or public view.

Model answer

White-collar crime is committed by middle-class people in the course of their work for their own gain, such as an accountant stealing from a client. Corporate crime is committed by or on behalf of a company, such as breaking health and safety laws to save money. Both are often called invisible crimes, for several reasons. First, victims are often unaware of them. If a company secretly fixes prices with its rivals, thousands of customers each pay a little more without realising a crime has taken place, so no one reports it and it never enters police recorded crime. Second, these crimes are hard to detect and prove. They happen inside offices, hidden in complex accounts or computer systems, and the people involved have the knowledge to cover their tracks, so investigations can take years. Third, many offences are dealt with by regulators or inside the company rather than by the police. An employee caught stealing may simply be dismissed to protect the firm’s reputation, so the crime is never recorded. Marxists add that the powerful have the money and influence to shape how laws are enforced, and that the media focus on street crime, so crimes of the powerful receive less attention and seem less of a problem.

Where marks slip

Keep the two kinds apart: white-collar crime is done by people for themselves, corporate crime for the company. Then explain why each reason keeps the crime out of sight, not just that it happens.

15 marks / Labelling and the crime statisticsEduqas

Discuss the view that patterns in official crime statistics are mainly the result of labelling by the police and courts.

What a full answer includes
  • Describes the patterns: official statistics show more young, male and working-class offenders.
  • Uses Becker: deviance is created by the reaction of others, and a label can become a master status.
  • Explains the typical offender stereotype and how it focuses policing on some groups.
  • Uses Chambliss: the Saints and the Roughnecks show differential enforcement of the law by class.
  • Gives the other side: Merton and Albert Cohen argue some groups really do offend more.
  • Uses self-report studies as evidence, and Heidensohn or the chivalry thesis on gender.
  • Notes limits of labelling theory, such as not explaining the first act.
  • Evaluates throughout and reaches a judgement on “mainly”.

Model answer

Official crime statistics show that people convicted of crimes are more likely to be young, male and working class. Interactionists and Marxists argue that these patterns are created mainly by the way the police and courts react to different groups, while other sociologists argue that they reflect real differences in offending. Becker (1963) argued that deviance is not a quality of an act but the result of other people labelling it as deviant. Whether a label is applied depends on who commits the act, where, and who sees it. Once applied, the label can become a master status, so the person is seen as a criminal above all else, which may push them into a deviant career. If the police hold a stereotype of the typical offender as a young working-class man, they will stop, search and arrest such people more often, so this group appears more often in the statistics. Chambliss’s study of the Saints and the Roughnecks (1973) supports this. Two groups of American high school boys both broke the law, but the middle-class Saints were seen as harmless and were rarely caught, while the working-class Roughnecks were seen as trouble and were often arrested. This shows differential enforcement of the law by class. Marxists add that white-collar and corporate crimes by the powerful are rarely recorded at all. However, labelling may not be the main explanation. Merton argued that people with blocked opportunities may turn to crime to reach the goal of success, and Albert Cohen showed how status frustration leads some working-class boys into delinquent subcultures. On this view, some groups really do commit more of the crimes that are policed. Self-report studies, in which people admit offences they have committed, generally still find that young people, especially young men, commit more crime, although the difference between classes is smaller than in official statistics. For gender, Heidensohn argued that women really do commit less crime because they are more tightly controlled, although the chivalry thesis suggests that women may also be treated more leniently by a mostly male justice system. Labelling theory also has limits. It does not explain why people commit an act before anyone has labelled them, and it can make offenders seem like passive victims with no choices of their own. On balance, labelling explains a good deal of the class pattern in official statistics, as Chambliss showed, but it is less convincing for age and gender, where other evidence also points to real differences in offending. So the patterns are partly, but not mainly, the result of labelling.

Where marks slip

Keep to the question: why some groups appear in the statistics more often. Explaining only why people commit crime, without discussing how the police and courts react, misses half of the debate.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 40 questions in Show Working

This page shows 40 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE Sociology topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free