Show Working
Open the app

GCSE Business · PeopleEdexcel, AQA, OCR and Eduqas

Human resources: GCSE questions with answers

40 GCSE Business questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working Business bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 40 questions 6 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Human resources questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is the main role of human resources (HR) in a business?

  1. AChoosing the suppliers of raw materials
  2. BDesigning the firm’s adverts
  3. CFinding, keeping and developing staff
  4. DSetting the prices of products
Show the answer

Answer: C Finding, keeping and developing staff

HR makes sure the business has the right number of people with the right skills. It covers recruitment, training, motivation, retention and how staff are organised.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

02 / Human resourcesEvery board

What does an organisation chart show?

  1. AWho is responsible to whom
  2. BHow cash flows in and out
  3. CWhere rivals sit in the market
  4. DSales over a product’s life
Show the answer

Answer: A Who is responsible to whom

An organisation chart shows job roles, the levels of the hierarchy and the lines of authority between them. Staff can see who their manager is and who they are responsible for.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

03 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is a manager’s span of control?

  1. AThe number of staff they directly manage
  2. BThe total staff in the business
  3. CHow far apart the firm’s shops are from each other
  4. DThe number of levels in the firm
Show the answer

Answer: A The number of staff they directly manage

Span of control counts the subordinates who report directly to one manager. A wide span means many people, so each gets less supervision; a narrow span means few people and closer supervision.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

04 / Human resourcesEvery board

A supervisor manages six staff. Two more workers now report directly to her.

What happens to her span of control?

  1. AIt stays the same
  2. BIt becomes a chain of command
  3. CIt becomes wider
  4. DIt becomes narrower
Show the answer

Answer: C It becomes wider

She now directly manages eight people instead of six, so her span of control is wider. She has less time for each worker, so she may need to delegate more.

Checked against aqa.org.uk

05 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is the chain of command?

  1. AA group of shops owned by one firm
  2. BThe order goods move to customers
  3. CThe number of staff each manager looks after
  4. DThe line of authority from top to bottom
Show the answer

Answer: D The line of authority from top to bottom

The chain of command is the path that instructions travel down and reports travel up. In a tall structure it passes through many levels, so messages can be slow or get changed on the way.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

06 / Human resourcesEvery board

A flat structure has:

  1. Amany levels and wide spans of control
  2. Bfew levels and narrow spans of control
  3. Cmany levels and narrow spans of control
  4. Dfew levels and wide spans of control
Show the answer

Answer: D few levels and wide spans of control

Tall structures have many levels, each manager running few people (narrow spans). Flat structures have few levels, each manager running many (wide spans). Examiners report pupils wrongly saying a narrower span makes a structure flatter.

Checked against aqa.org.uk

07 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is an advantage of a flat structure?

  1. AMore chances of promotion up many levels
  2. BCloser supervision of every worker
  3. CQuicker communication from top to bottom
  4. DEach manager supervises only a few staff
Show the answer

Answer: C Quicker communication from top to bottom

Flat structures pass messages quickly and often give staff more freedom, but managers can be stretched. Tall structures allow close supervision and clear promotion steps, but decisions and messages are slower.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

08 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is delegation?

  1. AMoving decisions to head office
  2. BRemoving a layer of managers
  3. CPassing authority for a task lower down
  4. DSharing one full-time job between two people
Show the answer

Answer: C Passing authority for a task lower down

Delegation gives a subordinate the authority to do a task, though the manager stays responsible for it. It frees the manager’s time and can motivate staff who feel trusted, if they have the skills.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

09 / Human resourcesEvery board

Who is mainly responsible for the overall direction of a company?

  1. AThe trade union
  2. BThe directors
  3. CThe operational staff
  4. DThe supervisors
Show the answer

Answer: B The directors

Directors set the long-term aims and strategy. Senior managers turn these into plans for their departments, supervisors or team leaders run small teams day to day, and other staff carry out the work.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

10 / Human resourcesEvery board

Why is good communication important in a business?

  1. AIt always lowers the wage bill
  2. BStaff never need training again
  3. CStaff know what to do, so mistakes fall
  4. DIt removes the need for any managers at all
Show the answer

Answer: C Staff know what to do, so mistakes fall

Clear communication helps staff work towards the same aims, make good decisions and feel involved. Poor communication leads to mistakes, low morale, more absence and less efficiency.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

11 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is a part-time worker?

  1. ASomeone on fewer hours than full-time staff
  2. BSomeone hired only for a fixed period of time
  3. CSomeone who works only at night
  4. DSomeone who runs their own small business
Show the answer

Answer: A Someone on fewer hours than full-time staff

Part-time staff work fewer hours than full-time staff (who usually work 35 hours or more a week). They give a firm flexibility at busy times, but by law they must be treated no less favourably than full-time staff.

Checked against gov.uk

12 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is a benefit to a business of full-time staff?

  1. AThey are available all working week
  2. BThey have no right to paid holiday
  3. CThey can be sent home unpaid when it is quiet
  4. DThey never need training
Show the answer

Answer: A They are available all working week

Full-time staff are there throughout the working week, which helps with continuity, customer service and commitment. They cost more in total than part-time staff, and the firm has less flexibility.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

13 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is flexitime?

  1. AWorking full-time hours squeezed into fewer days
  2. BSplitting one full-time job between two people
  3. CChoosing start and finish times, within limits
  4. DHaving no guaranteed hours at all
Show the answer

Answer: C Choosing start and finish times, within limits

Flexible working lets staff change when or where they work, for example flexitime around agreed core hours. It can raise motivation and retention, though it can make planning and cover harder.

Checked against gov.uk

14 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is a temporary contract?

  1. AA contract that ends after a set time
  2. BA contract with no guaranteed hours
  3. CA contract with no end date
  4. DA contract for unpaid volunteers
Show the answer

Answer: A A contract that ends after a set time

A temporary (fixed-term) contract ends on a set date or when a task is done. Permanent contracts have no end date. Temporary staff help firms with busy seasons or one-off projects.

Checked against gov.uk

15 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is a benefit of remote working for a business?

  1. AIt can save on office space
  2. BManagers can see every worker all day
  3. CIt needs no technology at all
  4. DStaff always meet face to face
Show the answer

Answer: A It can save on office space

Technology such as video calls and shared files lets staff work from home or on the move. Firms can save on premises and recruit from further away, but supervision and teamwork can be harder.

Checked against gov.uk

16 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is a reason a business needs to recruit?

  1. ASales have fallen sharply
  2. BIt is cutting its production for the year
  3. CA worker has left and must be replaced
  4. DIt is delayering its managers
Show the answer

Answer: C A worker has left and must be replaced

Firms recruit to replace staff who leave, to grow, and to fill skills gaps when they need abilities their current staff lack. Falling sales or cutbacks usually mean fewer staff, not more.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

17 / Human resourcesEvery board

What does a job description set out?

  1. AThe applicant’s past jobs
  2. BThe answers given at interview
  3. CThe duties and tasks of the job
  4. DThe skills and qualities the person needs
Show the answer

Answer: C The duties and tasks of the job

The job description describes the job: its title, duties and who it reports to. The person specification describes the ideal person: the skills, qualifications, experience and qualities needed. Together they guide the advert and the shortlist.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

18 / Human resourcesEvery board

Put these steps of recruitment and selection in order:

  1. AAppoint the best candidate
  2. BIdentify the vacancy
  3. CShortlist applicants
  4. DWrite the job description and person specification
  5. EAdvertise the job
  6. FInterview
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Identify the vacancy
  2. Write the job description and person specification
  3. Advertise the job
  4. Shortlist applicants
  5. Interview
  6. Appoint the best candidate

A firm first decides a vacancy exists and what the job needs, then advertises, shortlists the best applications, interviews or tests them, and appoints. References are best taken up near the end, when the job is being offered.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

19 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is internal recruitment?

  1. AAdvertising the job in a national newspaper
  2. BUsing an agency to find staff
  3. CHiring a freelancer for a project
  4. DFilling a job with an existing employee
Show the answer

Answer: D Filling a job with an existing employee

Internal recruitment is usually quicker and cheaper, the firm knows the person, and promotion chances motivate staff. But it leaves another job to fill and brings in no new ideas.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

20 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which training can a firm usually save by recruiting internally?

  1. AAll training for the new role
  2. BRetraining on new technology
  3. CInduction training
  4. DTraining in the new job’s tasks
Show the answer

Answer: C Induction training

An internal recruit already knows the firm, its people and its rules, so there is no need for induction. They may still need training for the new job itself. Examiners warn against saying internal recruits need less training in general.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

21 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is an advantage of external recruitment?

  1. AThe person already knows the firm and its staff
  2. BNo induction training is needed
  3. CA wider pool of applicants with new ideas
  4. DIt is usually cheaper and quicker
Show the answer

Answer: C A wider pool of applicants with new ideas

Looking outside the firm brings more applicants, fresh ideas and skills the firm lacks. It costs more and takes longer, and the new person needs induction.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

22 / Human resourcesEvery board

A games company needs an expert in a new technology that none of its staff understand.

Which kind of recruitment fits best?

  1. AInternal recruitment
  2. BDelayering
  3. CJob rotation
  4. DExternal recruitment
Show the answer

Answer: D External recruitment

No one inside has the skill, so the firm must look outside, for example through job websites or a recruitment agency. External recruitment is the way to fill a skills gap quickly.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

23 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which of these is part of selection rather than recruitment?

  1. AInterviewing applicants
  2. BPlacing a job advert
  3. CWriting the job advert
  4. DPosting the job on a jobs website
Show the answer

Answer: A Interviewing applicants

Recruitment attracts applicants, for example through job adverts. Selection chooses between them, using application forms, interviews, tests and references. Examiners often see job adverts given as selection methods.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

24 / Human resourcesEvery board

Who provides the CV in a job application?

  1. AThe applicant’s referee
  2. BThe employer
  3. CThe applicant
  4. DThe recruitment agency
Show the answer

Answer: C The applicant

A CV (curriculum vitae) is written by the applicant and lists their education, skills and work history. An application form is set by the firm, so all applicants answer the same questions and are easy to compare.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

25 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is a reference?

  1. AThe firm’s own list of the duties and tasks of the job
  2. BThe applicant’s list of past jobs
  3. CA test of the applicant’s skills
  4. DA report on the applicant by someone who knows them
Show the answer

Answer: D A report on the applicant by someone who knows them

A reference comes from someone such as a past employer or teacher. It helps the firm check what the applicant has said. Acas advises asking for references at the final stage, when making a job offer.

Checked against acas.org.uk

26 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is shortlisting?

  1. ACutting the number of staff
  2. BWriting a short advert for the vacant job
  3. CChoosing which applicants to interview
  4. DListing all the duties of the new job
Show the answer

Answer: C Choosing which applicants to interview

After the closing date, the firm compares applications with the person specification and picks the strongest few for interview or tests. This saves time on applicants who clearly do not fit.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

27 / Human resourcesEvery board

Why does an effective recruitment process matter?

  1. AIt removes the need for managers
  2. BWages can then be set below the minimum wage
  3. CThe right staff work well and stay longer
  4. DStaff then never need training
Show the answer

Answer: C The right staff work well and stay longer

Hiring the right people leads to higher productivity, better quality and customer service, and better retention. A bad appointment wastes the cost of recruiting and training and may mean doing it all again.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

28 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is induction training?

  1. ATraining current staff on new technology
  2. BStudying at college for a qualification
  3. CTraining to become a manager
  4. DTraining to settle new staff into the firm
Show the answer

Answer: D Training to settle new staff into the firm

Induction helps new employees settle in: they meet colleagues, learn the rules, health and safety and how the firm works. Examiners report pupils wrongly applying induction to staff who already work there.

Checked against aqa.org.uk

29 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is on-the-job training?

  1. AIntroducing new staff to the firm
  2. BStudying for a degree at university
  3. CLearning on a course away from the workplace
  4. DLearning while doing the job at work
Show the answer

Answer: D Learning while doing the job at work

On-the-job training happens at work, through demonstration, coaching, mentoring or job shadowing. It is cheap and practical, and the trainee still produces some work, but they may pick up bad habits.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

30 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is an advantage of off-the-job training?

  1. AIt takes place at the trainee’s workstation
  2. BNo working time is lost
  3. CIt is always cheaper
  4. DExperts teach without work distractions
Show the answer

Answer: D Experts teach without work distractions

Off-the-job training takes place away from the workstation, for example at a college or on an outside course. Trainees can focus and may gain qualifications, but it costs more and the firm loses their work while they are away.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

31 / Human resourcesEvery board

A bank brings in new software that all of its counter staff must use.

Why should it retrain its staff?

  1. ASo they can use the new system well
  2. BTo lower their rates of pay
  3. CTo introduce them to the firm
  4. DTo shorten their weekly working hours
Show the answer

Answer: A So they can use the new system well

Retraining updates the skills of staff who already work there, for example for new technology or new health and safety rules. Without it, mistakes rise and the new system does not deliver its benefits.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

32 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is a benefit of training staff?

  1. AHigher productivity and quality
  2. BLower wages for every worker
  3. CLower skill levels across the whole firm
  4. DNo further need for managers
Show the answer

Answer: A Higher productivity and quality

Training raises productivity, quality and customer service, and helps staff cope with new technology. It also shows staff they are valued, which motivates them and helps retention.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

33 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which is a likely result of a well-motivated workforce?

  1. ALower staff turnover
  2. BLower productivity
  3. CMore absence from work
  4. DMore customer complaints
Show the answer

Answer: A Lower staff turnover

Motivated staff work harder, produce better quality, give better service, take less time off and are less likely to leave. Low staff turnover means good retention.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

34 / Human resourcesEvery board

Why is keeping staff (retention) good for a business?

  1. AWages then never need to rise
  2. BIt saves the cost of recruiting and training
  3. CIt stops rivals from recruiting
  4. DIt removes the need for any staff training at all
Show the answer

Answer: B It saves the cost of recruiting and training

Every leaver must be replaced, which costs time and money for adverts, interviews and training. Staff who stay already know the business and its customers, so retention protects experience and saves money.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

35 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is a salary?

  1. AA fixed yearly amount, paid monthly
  2. BPay for each hour worked
  3. CPay for each item made
  4. DA share of the firm’s profit
Show the answer

Answer: A A fixed yearly amount, paid monthly

A salary is a fixed amount for the year, paid in monthly parts, whatever the hours. A wage is usually worked out from the hours worked (or sometimes the output) and is often paid weekly.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

36 / Human resourcesEvery board

A car salesperson earns 2% of the price of every car she sells.

What is this kind of pay called?

  1. AProfit sharing
  2. BCommission
  3. CA salary
  4. DOvertime
Show the answer

Answer: B Commission

Commission is pay worked out as a percentage of the value of sales a person makes. It rewards effort directly, but it can push staff to oversell and makes pay uncertain.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

37 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is profit sharing?

  1. AStaff get a share of the firm’s profits
  2. BStaff are paid for each item made
  3. CStaff buy products at a discount
  4. DStaff get a percentage of their own sales
Show the answer

Answer: A Staff get a share of the firm’s profits

Profit sharing pays staff part of the firm’s profit, often once a year. Staff have a reason to help the whole business succeed, though the link to each person’s own effort is weak.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

38 / Human resourcesEvery board

What is a bonus?

  1. APay for each hour worked
  2. BPay for working extra hours beyond the normal week
  3. CAn extra payment, often for meeting a target
  4. DA share of each sale made
Show the answer

Answer: C An extra payment, often for meeting a target

A bonus is a one-off payment on top of normal pay, often for hitting a target or for a good year. It can reward performance, but if targets are missed staff may feel let down.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

39 / Human resourcesEvery board

Which of these is a financial method of motivation?

  1. APraise from a manager
  2. BCommission
  3. CJob rotation
  4. DJob enrichment
Show the answer

Answer: B Commission

Financial methods reward staff with money, such as wages, salaries, commission and profit sharing. Non-financial methods use the work itself and how people are treated, such as praise, training, responsibility and job rotation.

Checked against filestore.aqa.org.uk

40 / Human resourcesEvery board

A manager gives a certificate and a mention in the staff newsletter to the employee of the month.

What kind of motivation is this?

  1. AProfit sharing
  2. BCommission
  3. CNon-financial
  4. DFinancial
Show the answer

Answer: C Non-financial

Praise and award schemes recognise good work without extra money, so they are non-financial. They cost little and show staff their effort is noticed.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

6 marks / Paying salespeople commissionEdexcel

Marlow Motors is a used-car dealer in Buckinghamshire with six salespeople, each paid a salary of £24,000 a year. Sales have been flat for two years. The owner plans to cut the salary to £18,000 and add commission of 2% of the price of each car a salesperson sells. The average car sells for £12,000.

Analyse the impact on Marlow Motors of paying its salespeople commission.

What a full answer includes
  • Commission is pay linked to sales, here 2% of the price of each car sold.
  • Each average car earns a salesperson £240, so they need 25 sales a year just to make up the £6,000 salary cut.
  • This gives salespeople a strong reason to sell more, which could raise revenue after two flat years.
  • Part of the wage bill falls when sales are slow, which helps cash flow in quiet months.
  • Staff may push customers into unsuitable cars, leading to poor reviews and harm to the dealer’s reputation.
  • Experienced salespeople may leave for dealers that pay a higher fixed salary.

Model answer

Commission is pay linked to how much an employee sells. At Marlow Motors, each salesperson would earn 2% of the price of every car they sell, which is £240 on an average £12,000 car. Because salaries would fall by £6,000, each salesperson would need to sell 25 cars a year just to earn what they earn now. This gives them a strong reason to work harder at closing sales, for example by following up enquiries quickly, so more cars could be sold and the dealer’s revenue could rise after two flat years. Commission also means part of the wage bill falls when sales are slow, which helps the dealer’s cash flow in quiet months. However, commission may change how staff sell. A salesperson who needs 25 sales just to stand still may push customers into buying cars that do not suit them. Unhappy buyers may leave poor online reviews, which damages the dealer’s reputation and future sales. Some experienced salespeople may also dislike losing £6,000 of guaranteed pay and leave for a dealer that pays a higher salary.

Where marks slip

Explain how commission works, not just that it motivates. Edexcel wants the case in every step, such as the £240 a car and the 25 cars needed to make up the salary cut.

9 marks / Recruiting a restaurant managerEdexcel

Saffron Kitchen runs three Indian restaurants in Birmingham and is opening a fourth next spring. It needs a manager for the new restaurant. Option 1: promote Aisha, an assistant manager who has worked at one of the restaurants for four years. Option 2: recruit a manager from outside the business, using a recruitment agency that charges £4,500.

Justify which one of these options Saffron Kitchen should choose.

What a full answer includes
  • Chooses one option clearly and supports it with the case.
  • Internal recruitment is cheaper and quicker: no £4,500 agency fee and no long advertising and interview process before the spring opening.
  • Aisha already knows the menu, suppliers and standards, so the new restaurant can match the other three.
  • Her promotion shows staff they can progress, which may motivate them and help keep good staff.
  • But she has never been a manager, and her old job would still need filling.
  • An outside manager could bring new ideas and experience of opening restaurants, but would take time to learn the business.
  • The conclusion adds what the choice depends on, such as support for Aisha in her first months.

Model answer

Saffron Kitchen should choose Option 1 and promote Aisha. Recruiting internally avoids the £4,500 agency fee and a long process of advertising and interviewing, which matters because the new restaurant opens next spring. After four years, Aisha already knows the menu, the suppliers and the standards customers expect, so she could set up the fourth restaurant in the same way as the other three, and customers would get the same experience. Her promotion would also show other staff that they can progress within Saffron Kitchen, which may motivate them and help the business keep good staff. However, Aisha has been an assistant manager, not a manager, and running a new restaurant means building a team, controlling costs and solving problems alone. She may make costly mistakes at first. Her current job would also need to be filled, so Saffron Kitchen would still have to recruit. An experienced outside manager might bring new ideas and know how to open a restaurant, but would take time to learn how the business works, and the £4,500 fee is a large cost. Overall, promoting Aisha is the better choice because her knowledge of Saffron Kitchen is hard to replace. This depends on the business supporting her, for example by having an experienced manager from another branch work alongside her for the first few months.

Where marks slip

Saying internal recruitment “needs less training” is a common error: it saves induction, but a newly promoted manager may still need training. Weigh your choice against its drawbacks using the case.

12 marks / Letting staff work from homeEdexcel and Eduqas

Northgate Insurance Brokers in Exeter employs 40 staff who arrange insurance for local businesses. Its office rent is £60,000 a year. In a staff survey, 70% of employees said they would like to work from home for three days a week. If they did, the business could move to a smaller office and save £25,000 a year in rent. Some managers worry that customer service and the training of new staff would suffer.

Evaluate whether Northgate Insurance Brokers should let its staff work from home three days a week. Use the case and your own knowledge of business.

What a full answer includes
  • Remote working means staff work away from the workplace, such as at home, keeping in touch through technology.
  • A smaller office would save £25,000 a year, over 40% of the £60,000 rent, raising profit every year.
  • 28 of the 40 staff want the change, so motivation and retention could improve, saving recruitment and training costs.
  • Flexible working makes Northgate more attractive to new staff from a wider area.
  • Customers are local businesses who need quick help, so service may suffer if calls go unanswered.
  • New staff learn less by listening to experienced colleagues, so training may take longer.
  • The 12 staff who did not ask for it may feel isolated or take on more calls.
  • A judgement that weighs these and says what it depends on.

Model answer

Remote working means employees work away from the business’s premises, usually at home, and keep in touch using technology such as email, phone and video calls. For Northgate, the clearest benefit is cost. Moving to a smaller office would save £25,000 a year, which is over 40% of its £60,000 rent, and that saving goes straight into profit every year. The change could also help staff. 70% of the 40 employees, which is 28 people, want to work from home three days a week. Being given what they asked for may increase their motivation, and less time and money spent commuting makes the job more attractive. This should make staff less likely to leave, saving Northgate the cost of recruiting and training replacements, and it would help attract new staff from a wider area around Exeter. However, the managers’ worries are real. Northgate’s customers are local businesses who need help quickly when something goes wrong, such as a claim after a fire or flood. If calls go unanswered or staff at home cannot find information quickly, customers could move to another broker. Training is also harder: new staff learn a lot by listening to experienced colleagues on the phone, and this is lost if most people are at home. In addition, the 12 staff who did not ask for the change may feel isolated in a half-empty office, or find themselves answering more calls. Overall, I think Northgate should allow working from home, because a £25,000 saving and happier staff are large and lasting benefits. However, the decision depends on keeping customer service strong. Northgate could make sure enough staff are in the office every day to answer calls, keep new staff in the office full time for their first few months so they learn from others, and check how quickly customers are helped after six months. If service falls, it could reduce home working to two days a week.

Where marks slip

Many answers list the benefits and drawbacks of home working in general. Use Northgate’s figures and its customers (local businesses who need quick help), and make a judgement that says what it depends on.

9 marks / Removing a layer of managementAQA

Ashby Electrical Ltd makes electrical parts in a factory in Leicestershire. Its structure has five levels: directors, managers, area supervisors, team leaders and shop floor workers. There are four area supervisors, each paid £32,000 a year. The directors are thinking of removing the area supervisor level, so that team leaders report straight to managers.

Should Ashby Electrical remove the area supervisor level? Justify your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Removing a layer of management is called delayering, and it makes the structure flatter.
  • It saves 4 × £32,000 = £128,000 a year in salaries.
  • With fewer levels, messages pass more quickly between managers and the shop floor, so decisions are faster.
  • Team leaders gain responsibility, which some may find motivating.
  • Managers’ spans of control widen, so they may have less time to support each team and problems may be missed.
  • The supervisors’ experience is lost, and workers may fear further job cuts, lowering morale.
  • A justified decision that says what it depends on, such as training team leaders first.

Model answer

Removing the area supervisors is delayering, which makes Ashby’s structure flatter, with four levels instead of five. The main benefit is cost: four supervisors at £32,000 each cost £128,000 a year, so this saving goes straight to profit and could help keep the factory’s prices competitive. With one fewer level, instructions from managers reach team leaders directly and problems on the shop floor reach managers more quickly, so decisions can be made faster. Team leaders would also take on more responsibility, which some may find motivating. However, each manager’s span of control would widen, because all the team leaders would now report straight to them. Managers may not have time to support every team, so problems in production, such as faults or delays, may be missed. The four supervisors’ knowledge of the factory would also be lost, and workers who see colleagues lose their jobs may fear they are next, which could lower morale and productivity. On balance, Ashby should remove the supervisor level, because £128,000 a year is a large saving and a flatter structure should speed up communication. This depends on the team leaders being able to handle more responsibility, so Ashby should train them first. It could also offer one or two of the best supervisors a manager’s role, which would cut the saving a little but keep their knowledge.

Where marks slip

Delayering is not the same as decentralisation, and a narrower span of control does not make a structure flatter. Use the case figures and judge whether the saving is worth the wider spans of control.

12 marks / Reducing staff turnoverAQA

Riverside Care Home in Kent employs 50 care workers, who are paid an average of £24,000 a year. Last year 15 of them left, a staff turnover of 30%. Each replacement costs about £2,000 to recruit and train. The managers want to reduce staff turnover and are considering two options. Option 1: give every care worker a 5% pay rise. Option 2: offer a training programme leading to a recognised care qualification, with a new senior carer role, paid £1,500 a year more, for those who complete it. The programme, including the senior carers’ extra pay, would cost about £20,000 a year in all.

Analyse each option and evaluate which one would have the biggest impact on the care home’s objective of reducing staff turnover. Justify your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Staff turnover is the share of staff who leave in a year; at Riverside it is 30%, costing about £30,000 a year to replace them.
  • Option 1, a financial method, raises average pay by £1,200 to £25,200, costing £60,000 a year.
  • Higher pay makes leaving for a similar job elsewhere less tempting, so some carers may stay.
  • But £60,000 is twice what turnover now costs, and rival care homes may raise pay too, so the advantage may fade.
  • Option 2, a non-financial method, gives a qualification and a route to promotion, a reason to build a career at Riverside.
  • At £20,000 it costs a third of Option 1, and better-trained carers give better care to residents.
  • But qualified carers may be tempted away by other employers, and it does little for staff who leave mainly for higher pay.
  • A judgement on which reduces turnover most, saying what it depends on, such as why staff are leaving.

Model answer

Staff turnover is the share of employees who leave in a year. At Riverside, 15 of 50 care workers left last year, so turnover is 30%. At about £2,000 each, replacing them cost around £30,000, and a constant stream of new faces can also unsettle residents. Option 1 is a financial method of motivation. A 5% rise would lift average pay from £24,000 to £25,200, an extra £1,200 each. Care work is often low paid, so carers can leave for a similar job that pays a little more, and a pay rise makes this less tempting, so some who would have left may stay. However, it is expensive: £1,200 for 50 staff is £60,000 a year, twice the £30,000 that turnover currently costs. Other care homes may also raise pay, so the advantage could disappear within a year or two, while the higher cost carries on. Option 2 is a non-financial method. A recognised qualification and a senior carer role give staff a reason to stay and build a career at Riverside, rather than seeing the job as a short-term one. Staff who feel valued and can see a future are less likely to leave, and better-trained carers give better care to residents, which helps the home’s reputation. At £20,000 a year it costs a third of Option 1. The risk is that once staff are qualified, other employers may offer them more, so Riverside could end up training staff for its rivals. It also does little for carers who leave mainly because the pay is too low to live on. Overall, I think Option 2 would have the biggest impact on staff turnover. It gives staff something a small pay rise elsewhere cannot easily match, a clear career path, and the senior carer role pays £1,500 a year more, so it rewards the staff Riverside most wants to keep. It also costs £40,000 a year less than Option 1. However, this depends on why staff are leaving. If exit interviews show that most leave purely for higher pay at nearby homes, a pay rise would have a bigger impact, and Riverside might combine a smaller rise with the training programme.

Where marks slip

Chains that stop at “staff are happier, so they stay” keep answers in the middle levels. Use the figures (the £30,000 cost of turnover against £60,000 and £20,000) and finish with a judgement that says what it depends on.

9 marks / A bonus for personal trainersOCR

Kestrel Gym in Wolverhampton has eight personal trainers, each paid a salary. Together they sign up about 20 new members a month. Membership costs £30 a month, but many new members leave within three months. The manager is thinking of paying trainers a bonus of £40 for each new member they sign up who is still a member after three months.

Evaluate whether Kestrel Gym should introduce the bonus scheme.

What a full answer includes
  • A bonus is a financial reward paid on top of normal pay for reaching a target.
  • Paying only for members who stay three months rewards trainers for helping new members get results, not just for signing them up.
  • This tackles the gym’s real problem, that many new members leave within three months.
  • A member who stays three months has paid at least £90, so after the £40 bonus the gym keeps at least £50.
  • Even if all 20 new members a month qualified, the £800 of bonuses would be covered by their fees.
  • Trainers may compete rather than work as a team, reception staff get nothing, and some may push people to join who will not stay.
  • A clear decision with a justification that uses the figures and says what it depends on.

Model answer

A bonus is an extra payment on top of normal pay for reaching a target. Kestrel’s scheme is well designed because trainers are rewarded only when a new member is still there after three months. This gives trainers a reason to help new members get results, such as planning their workouts and checking on their progress, rather than just signing them up. As many new members now leave within three months, this tackles the gym’s real problem. The scheme also pays for itself. A member who stays three months has paid at least 3 × £30 = £90, so after the £40 bonus the gym keeps at least £50, and every month the member stays after that adds another £30. Even if all 20 new members a month qualified, the £800 of bonuses would be covered by their fees. However, trainers may compete for new members rather than share them, which could damage teamwork. Reception staff, who often sign people up too, would get nothing, which may feel unfair. Some trainers may also push people into joining who are unlikely to stay. I think Kestrel should introduce the bonus, because it costs nothing unless members stay, and members who stay bring in income every month. This depends on avoiding rivalry between trainers, so the manager could add a small team bonus for the whole gym as well.

Where marks slip

OCR rewards using the figures in the case. Work out what each member who stays brings in compared with the £40 bonus, and make a clear decision backed by that context.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 69 questions in Show Working

This page shows 40 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE Business topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free