Show Working
Open the app

GCSE Computer Science · Computer systemsOCR, AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Ethical, legal and environmental impacts: GCSE questions with answers

37 GCSE Computer Science questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working Computer Science bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 37 questions 14 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Ethical, legal and environmental impacts questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

A company does something the law allows, but many people think it is wrong. The action is:

  1. Alegal but unethical
  2. Bboth legal and ethical
  3. Cillegal and unethical
  4. Dillegal but ethical
Show the answer

Answer: A legal but unethical

Legal means allowed by the law; ethical means most people would see it as the right thing to do. They are not the same: an action can be legal but unethical, so exam answers should treat legal and ethical issues separately.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

02 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

Personal data is information that:

  1. Arelates to a person who can be identified
  2. Ba person has typed in for themselves
  3. Cis stored on someone’s own computer
  4. Dis kept in a locked filing cabinet
Show the answer

Answer: A relates to a person who can be identified

Personal data is any information about an identified or identifiable living person, such as a name, address, photo or location. Websites gather it through forms, cookies, location services and social media posts.

Checked against ico.org.uk

03 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

What is the main privacy concern with smart speakers that listen for a wake word?

  1. AThey make the home Wi-Fi network faster
  2. BThey may record conversations people did not mean to share
  3. CThey cannot play music without a cable
  4. DThey use too much electricity to be worth having
Show the answer

Answer: B They may record conversations people did not mean to share

Devices that are always listening, such as digital assistants, may record and store more than people realise, and those recordings could be reviewed, shared or leaked. People may not know what is kept or who sees it.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

04 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR, Edexcel and Eduqas

What is the main purpose of the Data Protection Act 2018?

  1. ATo let anyone ask public bodies for the information they hold
  2. BTo stop software and music being copied
  3. CTo control how organisations use people’s personal data
  4. DTo make hacking into a computer a crime
Show the answer

Answer: C To control how organisations use people’s personal data

The Data Protection Act 2018, together with the UK GDPR, sets rules for how organisations collect, store and use personal data, and gives people rights over their own data. Hacking is covered by the Computer Misuse Act instead.

Checked against ico.org.uk

05 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR, Edexcel and Eduqas

Under data protection law, keeping personal data only for as long as it is needed is called:

  1. Aaccuracy
  2. Bpurpose limitation
  3. Cstorage limitation
  4. Ddata minimisation
Show the answer

Answer: C storage limitation

These are three of the data protection principles. Organisations must collect data for a stated purpose and not reuse it in ways that conflict with that purpose, collect no more than they need, and delete or anonymise it when it is no longer needed.

Checked against ico.org.uk

06 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR, Edexcel and Eduqas

A shop keeps customers' addresses up to date and fixes mistakes quickly. Which principle is it following?

  1. AStorage limitation
  2. BAccuracy
  3. CPurpose limitation
  4. DData minimisation
Show the answer

Answer: B Accuracy

Personal data must be kept accurate and up to date, and kept secure against loss, theft or misuse (the integrity and confidentiality, or security, principle). Under accountability, organisations must be able to prove they follow all the principles. The regulator lists seven principles; some guides list six and treat accountability as a separate duty.

Checked against ico.org.uk

07 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR, Edexcel and Eduqas

A person asks an organisation for a copy of the personal data it holds about them. Which right are they using?

  1. AThe right to object
  2. BThe right to rectification
  3. CThe right to erasure
  4. DThe right of access
Show the answer

Answer: D The right of access

UK data protection law gives people rights over their data, including the right of access (to get a copy), rectification (to have mistakes corrected) and erasure (to have data deleted in some cases).

Checked against ico.org.uk

08 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

An online shop sells its customers' email addresses to a marketing company without telling them.

Which law is the shop most likely to be breaking?

  1. ACopyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
  2. BComputer Misuse Act 1990
  3. CData Protection Act 2018
  4. DFreedom of Information Act 2000
Show the answer

Answer: C Data Protection Act 2018

Using personal data in a way people were not told about, and would not expect, breaks the data protection principles of fairness, transparency and purpose limitation. The Computer Misuse Act is about unauthorised access to computers, not how a firm uses its own data.

Checked against ico.org.uk

09 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

Which law makes it a crime to access a computer without permission?

  1. ACopyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
  2. BComputer Misuse Act 1990
  3. CData Protection Act 2018
  4. DFreedom of Information Act 2000
Show the answer

Answer: B Computer Misuse Act 1990

Section 1 of the Computer Misuse Act 1990 makes it an offence to access programs or data on a computer when you know you are not allowed to. Nothing has to be changed or stolen: getting in without permission is enough.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

10 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

Someone hacks into a bank customer’s account so they can steal money from it. Which offence under the Computer Misuse Act fits best?

  1. AUnauthorised access with intent to commit a further offence
  2. BUnauthorised access to computer material, and nothing more
  3. CMaking or supplying tools for computer crime
  4. DCopying software without the owner’s permission
Show the answer

Answer: A Unauthorised access with intent to commit a further offence

Section 1 (unauthorised access) carries up to 2 years in prison, section 2 (access intending a further crime, such as fraud) up to 5 years, and section 3 (acts that impair a computer, such as spreading malware) up to 10 years.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

11 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

Spreading a virus that damages files on a company’s computers is an offence under:

  1. Athe Freedom of Information Act 2000
  2. Bthe Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
  3. Cthe Computer Misuse Act 1990
  4. Dthe Data Protection Act 2018
Show the answer

Answer: C the Computer Misuse Act 1990

Section 3 of the Computer Misuse Act covers unauthorised acts meant to impair a computer, stop people reaching programs or data, or damage data, or done recklessly. Spreading malware and denial of service attacks both fall under it.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

12 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

Writing hacking software to sell to criminals breaks the Computer Misuse Act because:

  1. Amaking or supplying tools for computer crime is an offence
  2. Bthe software might contain personal data
  3. Cselling any software needs a government licence
  4. Dit breaks the copyright of the buyers
Show the answer

Answer: A making or supplying tools for computer crime is an offence

Section 3A of the Computer Misuse Act makes it an offence to make, adapt, supply or obtain an article, including software, meaning it to be used to commit a computer misuse offence, or to supply it believing it is likely to be.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

13 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

Which law protects software, music and films from being copied without permission?

  1. ACopyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
  2. BComputer Misuse Act 1990
  3. CData Protection Act 2018
  4. DFreedom of Information Act 2000
Show the answer

Answer: A Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988

The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 protects original work such as writing, music, films and software. A computer program counts as a literary work, so copying or sharing someone’s code without permission breaks copyright.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

14 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR, Edexcel and Eduqas

Does a programmer need to register their code to get copyright on it in the UK?

  1. AOnly if the code is sold in shops
  2. BYes, by paying a yearly fee
  3. CYes, with a UK copyright register
  4. DNo, copyright applies automatically
Show the answer

Answer: D No, copyright applies automatically

In the UK, copyright applies automatically: there is no register and no fee. It stops others copying, sharing, lending or adapting the work without permission, and for written work usually lasts until 70 years after the author dies.

Checked against gov.uk

15 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEdexcel

Which form of protection suits a new invention, such as a new piece of hardware?

  1. ACopyright
  2. BA trademark
  3. CA patent
  4. DA software licence
Show the answer

Answer: C A patent

A patent protects an invention, such as how a new device works, and lets the owner take legal action if others make, use or sell it without permission. Unlike copyright it must be applied for, the invention must be new, and it lasts up to 20 years if renewed each year.

Checked against gov.uk

16 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEdexcel

A company wants to stop others using its brand name and slogan. What protects these?

  1. AA registered trademark
  2. BData protection law
  3. CA patent
  4. DA software licence
Show the answer

Answer: A A registered trademark

A trademark protects a brand, such as a product name or slogan, so others cannot use it to pass off their goods as yours. A registered UK trademark lasts 10 years and must then be renewed.

Checked against gov.uk

17 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Edexcel

Why does software come with a licence?

  1. AIt proves that the software has no bugs in it
  2. BIt makes copying the software legal for everyone who has it
  3. CIt sets out how the software may be used and shared
  4. DIt hands ownership of the code to the user
Show the answer

Answer: C It sets out how the software may be used and shared

A licence is the legal agreement that says what you may do with software. Open-source software gives access to the source code so users can study, change and share it. Proprietary software keeps the code closed and is usually bought ready to use.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

18 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Edexcel

Which is a drawback of open-source software for a user?

  1. AIt always costs a great deal of money
  2. BThere may be no official support if it goes wrong
  3. CIts source code can never be changed
  4. DIts licence bans any kind of sharing
Show the answer

Answer: B There may be no official support if it goes wrong

Open-source software is often free and can be changed, but support may come only from a community and quality can vary. Proprietary software costs money and cannot be changed, but the maker usually provides support, testing and updates.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

19 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEduqas

A photographer lets anyone reuse her photos online, as long as they name her as the creator.

Which kind of licence fits this?

  1. AA proprietary licence
  2. BA trademark
  3. CA Creative Commons licence
  4. DA patent
Show the answer

Answer: C A Creative Commons licence

A Creative Commons licence lets a creator give permission in advance for others to reuse their work on stated conditions, such as giving credit or not using it commercially. The creator keeps the copyright.

Checked against creativecommons.org

20 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEduqas

Which law lets anyone ask a public body, such as a council or school, for information it holds?

  1. ACopyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
  2. BComputer Misuse Act 1990
  3. CData Protection Act 2018
  4. DFreedom of Information Act 2000
Show the answer

Answer: D Freedom of Information Act 2000

The Freedom of Information Act 2000 gives the public a right to request recorded information held by public authorities, such as councils, schools, the NHS and the police. They must reply within 20 working days. It does not cover ordinary private companies.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

21 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEduqas

Which law sets rules for covert surveillance by public bodies, and lets authorities require the key to encrypted data?

  1. ARegulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000
  2. BCopyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
  3. CComputer Misuse Act 1990
  4. DFreedom of Information Act 2000
Show the answer

Answer: A Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000

The Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 (RIPA) controls how public bodies such as the police may carry out covert surveillance, and Part 3 lets authorities serve a notice requiring encrypted data to be made readable or the key to be handed over.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

22 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEduqas

A written acceptable use policy that staff sign is an example of:

  1. Aa formal code of conduct
  2. Ba patent
  3. Ca software licence
  4. Dan informal code of conduct
Show the answer

Answer: A a formal code of conduct

Professional standards can be formal, such as a written policy or code that people sign up to, or informal, such as expected habits and personal integrity. Computing professionals are expected to follow both.

Checked against eduqas.co.uk

23 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

Which is an environmental impact of using digital devices?

  1. AData being stolen from a company’s servers
  2. BMore people being able to work from anywhere
  3. CThe electricity used, often made by burning fossil fuels
  4. DFewer people being able to shop online from their own homes
Show the answer

Answer: C The electricity used, often made by burning fossil fuels

Devices, networks and data centres all use electricity, and much of it still comes from fossil fuels, which adds to climate change. Data centres need power both for their servers and for cooling them.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

24 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

Why does making smartphones harm the environment?

  1. APhones are made from wood cut down from rainforests
  2. BMetals must be mined and lots of water and energy are used
  3. CFactories cannot make phones without burning plastic
  4. DEach phone is flown around the world many times before it is sold
Show the answer

Answer: B Metals must be mined and lots of water and energy are used

Digital devices need metals such as copper, gold and rare earth elements that have to be mined, and making their parts uses large amounts of water and energy. Mining can damage land, water and wildlife.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

25 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

Why is e-waste dumped in landfill harmful?

  1. AOther people always reuse it there
  2. BIt rots down and turns into compost
  3. CToxic substances can leak into the soil and water
  4. DIt produces free electricity for homes
Show the answer

Answer: C Toxic substances can leak into the soil and water

Old electronics contain harmful substances such as lead and mercury, and valuable metals that are wasted if dumped. UK rules on electrical waste require shops selling a new item to offer a free way to dispose of the customer’s old one of the same type, either by taking it back or through a scheme that pays for local recycling sites.

Checked against gov.uk

26 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

How does a short replacement cycle for phones harm the environment?

  1. AFewer devices are made each year
  2. BOld phones are always recycled in full
  3. CEach phone uses less energy than before
  4. DMore devices are made and thrown away
Show the answer

Answer: D More devices are made and thrown away

When people replace devices every year or two, more raw materials, energy and water go into making new ones and more e-waste is created. Repairing, updating and passing devices on all make them last longer.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

27 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

Which is a way technology can help the environment?

  1. APrinting every email to read it
  2. BBuying a new laptop every year
  3. CLeaving devices on standby all night
  4. DVideo calls can replace some journeys
Show the answer

Answer: D Video calls can replace some journeys

Technology can also reduce harm: video calls and remote working cut travel, smart systems save heating and lighting, and sensors are used to monitor pollution and wildlife. Good exam answers weigh benefits against costs.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

28 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

The gap between people who can get and use digital technology and those who cannot is called:

  1. Athe digital divide
  2. Be-waste
  3. Cthe replacement cycle
  4. Ddata minimisation
Show the answer

Answer: A the digital divide

The digital divide is the gap in access to the internet, devices, data and the skills to use them. People on low incomes, some older or disabled people, and those in areas with poor connections can miss out on services, jobs and learning that move online.

Checked against gov.uk

29 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

Many people now message friends instead of meeting up, and stream films instead of going to the cinema. These changes to how people live are best described as:

  1. Aenvironmental issues
  2. Blegal issues
  3. Ccopyright issues
  4. Dcultural issues
Show the answer

Answer: D cultural issues

Cultural issues are about how technology changes the way people live, behave and relate to each other, such as social media, online shopping and streaming. Exam questions often ask you to weigh cultural impacts against ethical, legal and environmental ones.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

30 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEdexcel

A computer system that picks job applicants to interview was trained mostly on data about past male staff. It now favours men.

What is this problem called?

  1. AAlgorithmic bias
  2. BDenial of service
  3. CA syntax error
  4. DData minimisation
Show the answer

Answer: A Algorithmic bias

Algorithmic bias happens when a system treats some groups unfairly, often because its training data was unbalanced. Using fair, representative data, testing results for each group and keeping human checks all reduce the risk.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

31 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEdexcel

Machine learning means:

  1. Abuilding robots from kits so that they can do simple jobs
  2. Bteaching people how to use computers by working through lessons
  3. Cwriting out every single rule of a task by hand before the system is allowed to run
  4. Dtraining a system on data so it learns a task without being given every rule
Show the answer

Answer: D training a system on data so it learns a task without being given every rule

In machine learning a system improves by learning patterns from data rather than following rules a programmer wrote for the task. With AI and robots making decisions, it is often unclear who is accountable or legally liable when something goes wrong.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

32 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

A fitness tracker records your heart rate and your location all day and uploads it to the maker’s servers.

What is the main privacy concern?

  1. AThe tracker might not be able to connect to the home Wi-Fi
  2. BThe screen could use up too much of the battery during the day
  3. CSensitive data about your health and movements could be shared or leaked
  4. DWearing the tracker all day could make your heart beat faster than normal
Show the answer

Answer: C Sensitive data about your health and movements could be shared or leaked

Wearable devices collect very personal data, such as health readings and where you go. If it is shared with others, sold or leaked in a breach, it could reveal private details about someone’s life and routine.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

33 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

An employer secretly reads every email its staff send and receive.

Why is this an ethical issue?

  1. AIt invades staff privacy without them knowing
  2. BIt uses up too much electricity
  3. CIt is a kind of malware attack
  4. DIt breaks the staff’s copyright
Show the answer

Answer: A It invades staff privacy without them knowing

Monitoring can help keep systems safe, but doing it secretly raises questions of privacy and trust. Many organisations explain in their policies what they monitor, so staff know where they stand.

Checked against ocr.org.uk

34 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

Some governments want a way to read encrypted messages to fight crime. Why do privacy campaigners object?

  1. AEncryption makes phones run much slower
  2. BCriminals never send messages on phones
  3. CEncrypted messages take up too much storage
  4. DA way in for police could also be used by criminals
Show the answer

Answer: D A way in for police could also be used by criminals

This is the privacy versus security debate. Reading messages could help catch criminals and terrorists, but deliberately weakening encryption could expose everyone’s private messages if the weakness is found and misused.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

35 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsEvery board

A hospital moves its patient records to cloud storage. Which is the main legal concern?

  1. AMaking sure the records load in colour
  2. BHow many patients can use the car park
  3. CKeeping the personal data secure and used lawfully
  4. DWhether the cloud company also sells laptops and printers
Show the answer

Answer: C Keeping the personal data secure and used lawfully

Health records are very sensitive personal data. Whoever stores them, the hospital must still make sure they are kept secure and used only in lawful ways, so it needs to check how the cloud provider protects them.

Checked against ico.org.uk

36 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR and Eduqas

A pupil downloads a new film from a website that is sharing it without the film company’s permission.

Which law does this break?

  1. ACopyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988
  2. BComputer Misuse Act 1990
  3. CData Protection Act 2018
  4. DFreedom of Information Act 2000
Show the answer

Answer: A Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988

Films, music, games and software are protected by copyright under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. Copying or sharing them without the owner’s permission is copyright infringement.

Checked against gov.uk

37 / Ethical, legal and environmental impactsOCR, Edexcel and Eduqas

Which body regulates data protection law in the UK?

  1. AThe Information Commission
  2. BThe Competition and Markets Authority
  3. COfcom
  4. DThe National Cyber Security Centre
Show the answer

Answer: A The Information Commission

The Information Commission enforces data protection law: it gives guidance, deals with complaints and can fine organisations. On 30 September 2026 it took over from the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO), under the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, with the same role and powers, so older books say the ICO.

Checked against gov.uk

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

8 marks / Self-service tills onlyOCR

A supermarket chain plans to remove every staffed till from its 40 stores. Shoppers will scan their own items at self-service tills and pay by card or phone only. Cash will no longer be accepted.

Discuss the impact of this plan. In your answer you should consider: ethical issues, cultural issues, legal issues and environmental issues.

What a full answer includes
  • The company saves on staff wages, and confident shoppers with a few items get through more quickly.
  • Ethically, cashiers may lose their jobs, so the chain should retrain them for other roles in the store.
  • Culturally, older shoppers, some disabled shoppers and people who rely on cash may find the store hard to use or be shut out, which widens the digital divide.
  • Some shoppers value talking to a cashier, so the store loses human contact that matters to lonely or vulnerable people.
  • Legally, card and loyalty card details are personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018, so they must be kept secure and used only for the purpose shoppers were told about.
  • Card payments travel over a network, so they must be encrypted, and the store cannot take any payment at all if the network or payment system fails.
  • Environmentally, hundreds of extra screens and scanners need materials and electricity to make and run and become e-waste later, although digital receipts could save paper.
  • A justified conclusion, for example keeping at least one staffed till and accepting cash so that no group of shoppers is excluded.

Model answer

The plan benefits the company because it pays fewer cashiers, and shoppers with a few items can be quicker at a self-service till. However, cashiers could lose their jobs, which is an ethical issue, so the chain should retrain them, for example to help shoppers at the tills or restock shelves. Culturally, the plan could shut some people out. Older shoppers, some disabled shoppers and people without a bank card who budget with cash may struggle, which widens the digital divide. Some people also value a chat with a cashier, especially if they live alone. Legally, card payments and loyalty card data are personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018. The chain must keep them secure and use them only for the reason it gave. Payments are sent over a network, so they must be encrypted, and if the network fails no one can pay at all, because there is no cash to fall back on. Environmentally, the new tills need metals and energy to make and electricity to run, and they become e-waste when replaced, although emailed receipts would save paper. Overall the plan saves money, but the chain should keep one staffed till and accept cash in every store so that no shopper is excluded.

Where marks slip

Many answers only give drawbacks, or treat profit as the only benefit. Cover every bullet point, look at the plan from both the company and the shopper side, and end with a conclusion that follows from what you wrote.

8 marks / AI to sort hospital X-raysOCR

A hospital trust wants to use an artificial intelligence (AI) system to check chest X-rays as soon as they are taken. Scans that the system judges to be urgent will move to the top of the doctors’ list. The system was trained on scans from hospitals in other countries.

Discuss whether the hospital trust should use this AI system. In your answer you should consider: the benefits and drawbacks for patients and staff, ethical issues, and legal and privacy issues.

What a full answer includes
  • Urgent scans are flagged in minutes at any time of day, so seriously ill patients can be treated sooner and the waiting list falls.
  • Doctors spend less time on clearly normal scans, but they may come to rely on the system and check its results less carefully.
  • The system learned from scans in other countries, so it may be less accurate for some local patients (bias); it should be tested on the trust’s own scans first.
  • If the system wrongly marks a scan as not urgent, it is unclear who is responsible, so a doctor should still make every final decision.
  • Health data is special category personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the UK GDPR, so it needs extra protection and a clear legal reason to use it.
  • Patients should be told how their scans are used, and only the data needed should be shared with the AI supplier.
  • The scans must be stored and sent securely, with encryption and user access levels, especially if the supplier processes them in the cloud.
  • A justified conclusion, for example to use the system only to sort the list, with doctors checking every result.

Model answer

The main benefit is speed. The AI can check every chest X-ray within minutes, day or night, so a patient with a serious problem moves up the list and is treated sooner. Doctors also spend less time on scans that are clearly normal. The drawback is that staff may start to trust the system too much and check its results less carefully. There is also an ethical risk of bias. The system was trained on scans from other countries, so it may be less accurate for some patients in this hospital. The trust should test it on its own past scans before using it. If the AI wrongly marks an urgent scan as routine, it is not clear whether the supplier or the hospital is to blame, so a doctor must still make the final decision. Legally, X-rays are health data, which is special category data under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the UK GDPR. The trust needs a clear legal reason to use them, must tell patients how they are used, and should share only what the supplier needs. The scans must be encrypted when stored and sent, and only authorised staff should be able to see them. I think the trust should use the system, but only to sort the list, with doctors checking every result.

Where marks slip

Answers often say “AI is faster” and stop. Explain what the speed means for these patients and staff, mention that training data from elsewhere can make the system less accurate here, and say who stays responsible for the decision.

8 marks / Cameras and sensors on streetlightsOCR

A town council plans to fit cameras and sensors to its streetlights. They will count people and vehicles, measure air quality and dim the lights when no one is around. The data will be sent over the internet to the council’s servers.

Discuss the impact of this plan on the people who live in the town. In your answer you should consider: privacy issues, legal issues, ethical issues and environmental issues.

What a full answer includes
  • Dimming the lights when the streets are empty saves electricity and money, and air quality data can guide decisions such as where to limit traffic.
  • Making, powering and later replacing thousands of devices and running the servers has its own environmental cost, including e-waste.
  • Cameras could identify people and record where they go and when, so residents may feel watched even though they never agreed to it.
  • Images of people who can be identified are personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018, so the council must have a lawful reason, put up clear signs and explain how the data is used.
  • The council should collect only what it needs and keep it only as long as needed, for example counting people on the device itself and not storing images at all.
  • The data travels over the internet, so it should be encrypted, and the devices could be hacked; the Computer Misuse Act 1990 makes this a crime but does not stop it happening.
  • Ethically, safer and cleaner streets for everyone must be weighed against surveillance, and against who else, such as the police, could ask for the data.
  • A justified conclusion, for example that the sensors are worthwhile if they count without storing images.

Model answer

The plan has clear environmental benefits. Dimming lights when no one is around saves electricity, and the air quality readings could show the council where to cut traffic. However, thousands of new devices need materials and energy to make, the servers use electricity, and the devices will become e-waste when they are replaced. The biggest concern is privacy. Cameras on every street could identify people and record where they go and when, and residents have not chosen to be filmed. Legally, images of people who can be identified are personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018. The council needs a lawful reason, must put up signs and explain how the data is used, and should collect only what it needs. If the cameras count people on the device itself and send only the numbers, far less personal data is collected and kept. The data is sent over the internet, so it should be encrypted. A hacker who got into the system would be committing an offence under the Computer Misuse Act 1990, but the law cannot stop an attack, so the council needs strong security. Ethically, safer, cleaner streets help everyone, but residents may worry the police could use the data to track people. Overall the plan is worthwhile if the cameras count without storing images.

Where marks slip

Do not just say “it invades privacy”. Say what could be learned about residents, which law applies and what the council must do, and suggest a change that keeps the benefits with less risk.

8 marks / Open source software for a schoolOCR

A secondary school pays a yearly licence fee for proprietary office software on 600 computers. The head teacher suggests switching to free open source office software instead.

Discuss whether the school should switch to open source software. In your answer you should consider: the differences between open source and proprietary licences, legal issues, and the benefits and drawbacks for the school.

What a full answer includes
  • Open source software comes with its source code, which anyone may study, change and share, and is often free; proprietary software keeps its source code hidden and is used under a paid licence.
  • Switching saves the licence fee for 600 computers every year, money that could go on other equipment.
  • Files shared with families, colleges and employers who use the proprietary software may not open or look the same, and pupils may need to learn the software used at work.
  • Proprietary software comes with official support and regular updates; open source support usually comes from a community, although popular projects are updated often.
  • Because open source code can be read by many people, problems can be found and fixed quickly, but the school depends on others to release the fixes.
  • Copying proprietary software onto more computers than the licence allows breaks the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988; open source software is still covered by copyright and its licence has conditions that must be followed.
  • Staff would need time and training to move their files and learn the new software.
  • A justified conclusion, for example to switch after a trial, keeping a few proprietary licences where they are really needed.

Model answer

Open source software is supplied with its source code, so anyone can study, change and share it, and it is usually free. Proprietary software keeps its source code secret and the school pays for a licence to use it. The biggest benefit of switching is cost: the school would stop paying a fee for 600 computers every year and could spend that money on new equipment. Open source code can also be checked by many programmers, so faults are often found and fixed quickly. However, there are drawbacks. Documents sent to families or colleges that use the proprietary software may not open or look the same, and pupils may need skills in software they will meet at work. Proprietary software comes with official support, whereas the school would rely on a community or pay a company for help. Teachers would need training time. Legally, the school must follow either licence. Installing proprietary software on more computers than it has paid for breaks the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. Open source software is still protected by copyright, and its licence has conditions, such as keeping the licence with any copies the school shares. I think the school should switch after a term’s trial, keeping a few proprietary licences for courses that need them.

Where marks slip

Many answers say open source means “anyone can use it”. The key idea is that the source code is available to view and change. Also make sure benefits you give are benefits to the school, not to the company that sells the software.

8 marks / Live location sharing for teenagersOCR

A company runs a social media app for 13 to 17 year olds. It plans a new feature that shows each user’s live location on a map to their friends on the app. The feature will be switched on for every user unless they turn it off.

Discuss the issues the company should consider before launching this feature. In your answer you should consider: privacy issues, legal issues, ethical issues and cultural issues.

What a full answer includes
  • Users could meet up more easily, and the feature would keep people using the app, which benefits the company.
  • A live location shows where a young person lives, goes to school and spends time, and “friends” on the app may include people they have never met.
  • Location is personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the UK GDPR, so the company must explain clearly, in words young people understand, what it collects and why.
  • The Children’s code (the Age appropriate design code, enforced by the Information Commission) expects services likely to be used by under-18s to have high privacy settings by default and to switch location sharing off by default.
  • Ethically, turning the feature on for everyone relies on users not changing settings, which puts the company’s interests ahead of users’ safety.
  • Stored location data must be encrypted and protected, because a data breach could reveal where thousands of children are.
  • Culturally, users may feel pressure to share where they are, and seeing friends meet without them could cause upset or exclusion.
  • A justified conclusion, for example to launch only with the feature off by default, shared with chosen friends and easy to pause.

Model answer

The feature could help friends meet up and would keep users on the app, which is good for the company. However, a live location reveals a lot. It shows where a young person lives and goes to school and when they are alone, and friends on the app may include people they have never met in person, so it could put children at risk. Legally, location is personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the UK GDPR. The company must explain in plain words that teenagers understand what it collects and why. The Children’s code (the Age appropriate design code) also expects apps used by under-18s to have high privacy settings by default and to keep location sharing off unless the user chooses it, so switching it on for everyone is likely to break the code. The location data would also need to be encrypted, because a breach would show where thousands of children are. Ethically, the company knows most users never change their settings, so making the feature on by default puts engagement ahead of safety. Culturally, it could create pressure to share, and seeing friends meet up without you could make people feel left out. The company should only launch the feature if it is off by default, shared with chosen friends only and easy to pause.

Where marks slip

Answers often describe the feature and say it is “dangerous” without explaining why. Say what a location reveals, why “on by default” matters for under-18s, and finish with a clear recommendation.

8 marks / Moving servers to the cloudOCR

An online clothes shop runs its website and customer database on servers in its own server room. It plans to close the server room and move everything to a cloud hosting company whose data centres are in several countries.

Discuss the impact of this move. In your answer you should consider: the benefits and drawbacks for the shop, environmental issues, and legal and ethical issues.

What a full answer includes
  • The cloud company can add server capacity quickly, for example during a sale, and the shop pays for what it uses instead of buying and maintaining servers.
  • The shop depends on its internet connection and on the hosting company, so an outage at either one takes the website offline.
  • Large data centres use a great deal of electricity and water for cooling, but they are often more efficient than a small server room and some run on renewable energy.
  • The old servers become e-waste and should be reused or recycled properly, not sent to landfill.
  • The shop is still responsible for its customers’ personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the UK GDPR, even when another company stores it.
  • Data held abroad may only be transferred where it stays properly protected, so the shop should check where its customers’ data will be kept.
  • The hosting company has specialist security staff, but the data travels over the internet, so it must be encrypted and staff logins protected.
  • Ethically, the shop’s own IT staff may lose their jobs or need retraining.
  • A justified conclusion, for example that the move is sensible if the shop chooses a provider that stores data in the UK and uses renewable energy.

Model answer

Moving to the cloud gives the shop flexibility. During a big sale the hosting company can add server capacity within minutes, and the shop no longer has to buy, cool and repair its own servers. However, the website now depends on the shop’s internet connection and the hosting company, so a fault at either one takes the shop offline. Environmentally, data centres use huge amounts of electricity and water to keep servers cool. On the other hand, a large data centre is usually more efficient than a small server room running all day, and some providers use renewable energy. The old servers will become e-waste, so they should be reused or properly recycled. Legally, the shop is still responsible for its customers’ personal data under the Data Protection Act 2018 and the UK GDPR. Because the data centres are in several countries, the shop must check where the data will be kept, since it may only be sent abroad if it stays properly protected. The provider has expert security staff, but data passing over the internet must be encrypted. Ethically, the shop’s IT staff may lose their jobs unless they are retrained. Overall the move is sensible if the shop picks a provider that keeps its data in the UK and uses renewable energy.

Where marks slip

Do not assume the cloud is automatically more secure or less secure. Weigh what the provider does against what the shop still has to do, and remember the shop stays legally responsible for its customers’ data.

9 marks / Self-driving delivery vansAQA

A supermarket wants to deliver online orders in a city using autonomous (self-driving) electric vans. The vans use cameras, radar and GPS, are connected to the company’s systems over the mobile phone network, and receive software updates wirelessly.

Discuss the ethical, legal and environmental issues of using autonomous vans, and the cyber security risks the supermarket would need to manage.

What a full answer includes
  • Ethically, the vans could cut accidents caused by tired or distracted drivers, but delivery drivers would lose their jobs.
  • Someone must decide in advance how the software acts when a crash cannot be avoided, which is a difficult ethical choice.
  • Legally, it must be clear who is responsible when a van causes a crash: the supermarket, the van maker or the software developer.
  • The cameras record people in the street, so the supermarket must follow data protection law on how long footage is kept and who can see it.
  • Environmentally, electric vans produce no exhaust fumes and the software can plan efficient routes, but the batteries and sensors need mined materials and become e-waste.
  • A hacker who got into the wireless connection or sent a fake update could take control of a van, steal goods or cause a crash.
  • Encrypting communication, accepting only genuine updates, installing security updates automatically and penetration testing before the vans go on the road reduce these risks.
  • A balanced conclusion about whether the benefits outweigh the issues.

Model answer

Autonomous vans could make roads safer, because the software does not get tired or look at a phone, which causes many crashes. However, the supermarket’s delivery drivers would lose their jobs, which is an ethical cost. There is also the question of what the van should do when a crash cannot be avoided, for example whether to swerve towards a wall or a pedestrian. Programmers have to make that choice in advance, which many people find troubling. Legally, if a van hits a cyclist, it must be clear whether the supermarket, the van manufacturer or the software company is responsible. The cameras also film people in the street, so the supermarket must follow data protection law, keeping footage only as long as needed and only letting authorised staff see it. Environmentally, electric vans give off no exhaust fumes, and route planning software can cut wasted journeys. However, their batteries and sensors need mined metals and become e-waste at the end of their life. Cyber security is a serious risk. Because the vans are connected wirelessly, a hacker could intercept the connection or send a fake update and take control of a van. The supermarket should encrypt all communication, only install updates that are checked as genuine, apply security patches automatically and pay for penetration testing before the vans are used. Overall, the vans could be safer and cleaner, but only if responsibility is clear and the security is tested thoroughly.

Where marks slip

Answers that cover only some of the strands asked for, such as ethics but not cyber security, cannot reach the top level. Plan one paragraph for each strand and keep every point about these vans and this supermarket.

9 marks / Fitness trackers from an employerAQA

A delivery firm offers every driver a free wearable fitness tracker. It records heart rate, sleep, steps and location, and sends the data to a cloud service run by the firm. Drivers who share their data get cheaper health insurance through the firm.

Discuss the ethical and legal issues of this scheme, and the cyber security measures the firm should use to protect the data.

What a full answer includes
  • Drivers could become healthier and pay less for insurance, and the firm may have fewer staff off sick.
  • Drivers may feel they have to join to get cheaper insurance or to please their employer, so their agreement may not be truly free.
  • The data could reveal illnesses, tiredness or where drivers go outside work, which the firm might use unfairly, for example when deciding who to promote.
  • Health data has extra protection in data protection law, so the firm must explain exactly what it collects and why, and collect only what it needs.
  • Drivers should be able to see their data and leave the scheme, with their data deleted when it is no longer needed.
  • Weak or reused passwords on the cloud accounts could let attackers in, so strong passwords with a second step, such as a code sent to a phone, are needed.
  • The data should be encrypted when it is sent from the trackers and when it is stored in the cloud.
  • Only the staff who run the scheme should be able to see the data, with access rights set up correctly and checked.
  • A balanced conclusion, for example that the scheme is fair only if it is truly optional and tracks location only during working hours.

Model answer

The scheme could help drivers be healthier and pay less for insurance, and the firm could have fewer staff off sick. However, there are ethical problems. Drivers may feel pushed to join because it saves them money or because they think their manager expects it, so their agreement is not really free. The data also reveals a great deal: a raised heart rate could suggest an illness, poor sleep could suggest tiredness, and location tracking could show where drivers go on their days off. The firm might use this unfairly when choosing who to promote. Legally, health data has extra protection under data protection law. The firm must tell drivers exactly what is collected and why, collect only what the scheme needs, let drivers see their data, and delete it when it is no longer needed or when a driver leaves the scheme. Tracking location outside working hours would be hard to justify. The data is stored in the cloud, so cyber security matters. Weak passwords could be guessed, so accounts should need strong passwords and a second step, such as a code sent to a phone. Data should be encrypted on its way from the tracker and while stored. Access rights should be set so only the staff running the scheme can see it, because misconfigured access could expose every driver’s health records. Overall, the scheme is only acceptable if it is truly optional and does not track drivers outside work.

Where marks slip

A list of points such as “privacy, hacking, encryption” stays in the lowest level. Explain each one: what could happen to these drivers, and how the measure you suggest would stop it.

9 marks / Police access to encrypted messagesAQA

Many messaging apps use end-to-end encryption, so only the sender and the receiver can read a message, not even the company that runs the app. A government proposes that messaging companies must be able to show the police the messages of a suspected criminal whenever a judge approves it.

Discuss the ethical, legal and cyber security issues raised by this proposal.

What a full answer includes
  • Supporters say police could stop serious crimes such as terrorism and child abuse, which are planned in encrypted messages.
  • Needing a judge’s approval is a safeguard, so messages would be read only in serious cases.
  • To make messages readable on request, the company must build a way round its encryption, so everyone’s messages become less private, not just criminals’.
  • Any way round the encryption could be found and used by criminal hackers or hostile governments, so the security of all users falls.
  • People such as journalists, doctors and victims of abuse rely on private messages, so weaker privacy could put them at risk.
  • Legally, the law has to balance the right to privacy against preventing crime, and some companies could withdraw their apps rather than weaken encryption.
  • Criminals could move to other apps or write their own encryption, so the law might mostly affect ordinary users.
  • A justified conclusion that weighs privacy against national security.

Model answer

Supporters of the proposal argue that criminals use encrypted messaging to plan serious crimes, such as terrorism or abusing children, and police cannot currently read those messages even with evidence. Requiring a judge to approve each request is a safeguard, so it would only be used in serious cases. However, end-to-end encryption works because no one in the middle has the key. To show police a message, the company would have to build a way round its own encryption into the app, and that weakness would exist in everyone’s app, not only a suspect’s. Criminal hackers or hostile governments could find and use it, so the cyber security of millions of innocent users would be lower. Once a back door exists, no company can promise only the police will ever use it. Ethically, privacy matters to many people with good reason. Journalists protect their sources, doctors discuss patients, and people escaping abuse need to contact help secretly. Legally, the government must balance the right to privacy with the duty to prevent crime. Some companies might remove their apps from the country rather than weaken their encryption, while determined criminals could simply move to other apps, leaving ordinary users less safe. I think the proposal goes too far. Catching criminals matters, but weakening encryption for everyone creates a risk to all users that is greater than the benefit.

Where marks slip

The best answers explain why giving police access weakens security for everyone, not just say “it invades privacy”. Give both sides of the privacy versus state security debate before you reach your judgement.

9 marks / Heart monitors that send data homeAQA

A hospital fits some heart patients with a small implant that monitors their heart rhythm. It sends readings wirelessly to a box in the patient’s home, which passes them over the internet to the hospital. Doctors can also change some of the implant’s settings remotely.

Discuss the ethical and legal issues of using these implants, and the cyber security risks they bring.

What a full answer includes
  • Doctors see problems early and can act before a patient becomes seriously ill, and patients need fewer hospital visits.
  • Patients must understand and agree to what the implant records and who can see it before it is fitted.
  • The system needs a home internet connection, so patients without one may miss out, which is a digital divide issue.
  • Heart readings are health data, which has extra protection in data protection law, so the hospital must keep them secure and use them only for the patient’s care.
  • If the implant or its software fails and a patient is harmed, it must be clear whether the hospital or the manufacturer is responsible.
  • An attacker who intercepted the wireless signal could read the readings, so the data should be encrypted from the implant to the hospital.
  • Someone who changed the implant’s settings could harm the patient, so only authenticated doctors should be able to make changes.
  • Unpatched software in the home box could be attacked, so it should get security updates automatically, and the system should be penetration tested before use.
  • A balanced conclusion about whether the benefits justify the risks.

Model answer

The implants could save lives. Doctors see an irregular heart rhythm as it happens and can call the patient in before they become seriously ill, and patients make fewer trips to hospital for check-ups. However, before the implant is fitted, patients must understand what it records, who can see the readings and that settings can be changed remotely, and they must agree to this. The system also needs a home internet connection, so patients without one could miss out, which is unfair. Legally, heart readings are health data, which data protection law protects more strongly than ordinary personal data. The hospital must keep them secure and use them only to care for the patient. If the device fails and a patient is harmed, it needs to be clear whether the hospital or the manufacturer is responsible. The cyber security risks are serious because a device inside someone’s body is connected to the internet. If the wireless signal were intercepted, an attacker could read private health data, so all data must be encrypted. Worse, someone who could change the implant’s settings could put the patient in danger, so changes should only be possible after a doctor has been strongly authenticated. The home box could have unpatched weaknesses, so it should install security updates automatically, and the whole system should be penetration tested before it is used. Overall, the benefits are worth it, as long as remote changes are tightly protected.

Where marks slip

Do not stop at “hackers could steal the data”. With an implant, the bigger danger is someone changing how it works. Explain the risk, then the specific measure that reduces it.

6 marks / Robots in a warehouseEdexcel

An online retailer plans to replace most of its warehouse pickers with robots. The robots use machine learning to get faster at finding and packing items over time.

Discuss the impact of this plan on the retailer and its workers.

What a full answer includes
  • Robots can work all day and night without breaks, so orders are picked and sent faster.
  • Machine learning lets the robots improve from data about past orders, so they make fewer mistakes over time.
  • Many pickers would lose their jobs, although some could be retrained to maintain and supervise the robots.
  • Robots are expensive to buy and maintain, and if the system fails the whole warehouse could stop.
  • A machine learning system can learn behaviour that no one expected, so it must be monitored.
  • If a robot injures someone, it must be clear who is legally responsible: the retailer or the robot maker.

Model answer

For the retailer, the robots could pick orders 24 hours a day without breaks, so customers receive parcels sooner. Because they use machine learning, the robots learn from data about past orders, for example which routes through the warehouse are quickest, so they become faster and make fewer mistakes over time. However, the robots are expensive to buy and repair, and the retailer becomes dependent on them. If the software fails, the whole warehouse could stop. A machine learning system can also learn behaviour that no one planned, so staff must monitor it. If a robot injures a worker, there is a question of legal liability: is the retailer or the robot maker responsible? For workers the impact is mostly negative. Many pickers would lose their jobs, which could hit a town where the warehouse is a major employer. Some could be retrained to maintain or supervise the robots, which may be better paid but needs new skills. Overall, the plan helps the retailer’s speed, but it has a high cost for workers unless the retailer retrains them.

Where marks slip

A definition of machine learning on its own stays at the lowest level. Develop each point with an example from this warehouse and cover both the retailer and its workers.

6 marks / Replacing school tablets every two yearsEdexcel

A school gives every pupil a tablet computer. Its supplier offers to replace all 900 tablets with new models every two years.

Discuss the environmental impact of replacing the tablets every two years.

What a full answer includes
  • Making each tablet uses energy and raw materials, including metals that must be mined, so replacing all 900 every two years multiplies this impact.
  • New tablets are shipped from factories, often abroad, which adds transport emissions.
  • Newer tablets may use slightly less electricity, but this saving is small compared with the energy used to make them.
  • Old tablets become e-waste that contains harmful substances, which can pollute soil and water if sent to landfill or broken up unsafely.
  • Refurbishing, reusing or properly recycling the old tablets recovers materials and reduces waste.
  • A longer replacement cycle, such as four years with repairs and battery replacements, would greatly reduce the impact.

Model answer

Most of a tablet’s environmental impact comes from making it. Factories use a lot of energy, and the battery and circuit boards need metals that must be mined, which damages landscapes and uses water. Replacing 900 tablets every two years means making 450 new tablets a year on average, so this impact keeps repeating. The new tablets also have to be shipped from factories, often overseas, which adds transport emissions. The supplier may argue that newer models use less electricity. This is true, but tablets use little power, so the saving is small compared with the energy used to make new ones. The old tablets become e-waste. They contain harmful substances that can pollute soil and water if they go to landfill or are broken up unsafely abroad. If the school sends them to be refurbished and given to people who need them, or recycled properly so materials are recovered, the harm is reduced. Overall, a two-year replacement cycle is bad for the environment. Keeping the tablets for four years or more, with repairs and new batteries, would cut the impact a lot.

Where marks slip

Answers often say “it creates e-waste” and stop. Give the linked expansion each time: for example, a longer replacement cycle means fewer tablets are made, so fewer materials need to be mined.

6 marks / Protecting a smart bike lightEdexcel

Two friends start a company that sells a smart bike light. They invented a new way for the light to sense when a car is close behind, wrote the app that goes with it, and chose a name and logo for the product.

Discuss how the company can use the law to protect its work.

What a full answer includes
  • Copyright protects the app’s source code and the artwork automatically, with no need to register, so others cannot copy it without permission.
  • Copyright does not protect the idea behind the sensor, only the way it is written or drawn.
  • A patent could protect the new way of sensing cars if it is new and inventive, stopping others making or selling it for up to 20 years.
  • Applying for a patent costs money and makes the invention public, and the company must pay to enforce it.
  • Registering the name and logo as a trademark stops other firms using them to sell similar products.
  • A licence for the app sets out how customers may use it, and the company could license its patent to other makers for a fee.

Model answer

Copyright would protect the app’s source code and the logo artwork automatically, without registering anything. It would be against the law for another company to copy the code or the logo without permission. However, copyright only protects how something is written or drawn, not the idea, so a rival could write its own app that does the same thing. The new way of sensing cars is an invention, so the company could apply for a patent. If it is new and inventive, the patent would stop anyone else making or selling a light that uses it for up to 20 years. The drawbacks are that applying costs money, the details of the invention become public, and the company would have to take rivals to court itself. The product name and logo could be registered as a trademark, so other firms could not sell bike lights with a confusingly similar name. Finally, the app would come with a licence telling customers what they can and cannot do with it. The company could also license its patent to bigger manufacturers in return for a fee. Using all four together gives the company the strongest protection.

Where marks slip

Many answers mix up the protections. Copyright covers the code and artwork, a patent covers an invention such as new hardware, and a trademark covers names and logos. Say which one fits each part of this company’s work.

6 marks / Collecting data with a loyalty cardEdexcel

A chain of chemists launches a loyalty card. Each time customers shop, the card records what they buy, when and in which store. Customers get money-off vouchers based on what they buy.

Discuss the issues of the chemist chain collecting this personal data.

What a full answer includes
  • Customers get vouchers for things they actually buy, and the chain can plan stock and make offers that bring customers back.
  • Shopping at a chemist can reveal health conditions, such as buying pregnancy tests or medicines, which is very private.
  • Customers must be told clearly what is collected and how it is used, and asked before their data is shared or sold to other companies.
  • The data must be stored securely, with encryption and access control, because a breach would expose private health information.
  • Customers should be able to see the data held about them, correct it and leave the scheme.
  • Personalised offers could reveal private information, for example if someone else sees the vouchers.

Model answer

The loyalty card benefits both sides. Customers get vouchers for products they actually use, and the chain learns what sells in each store, so it can plan stock and send offers that bring customers back. However, what people buy at a chemist can reveal their health. Buying pregnancy tests or a particular medicine could show a pregnancy or an illness, so this data is very private. The chain must tell customers clearly what it records and why, and ask before sharing or selling it to other companies, such as advertisers. The data also has to be kept secure. If hackers stole it, thousands of customers’ private health details could be exposed, so the chain should encrypt the data and only let staff who need it have access. Customers should be able to see what is held about them, correct mistakes and leave the scheme. There is also a risk from personalised offers themselves. If a voucher for baby products arrives at a family home, it could reveal something a customer had not told anyone. Overall, the card is acceptable if customers clearly agree and the data is well protected.

Where marks slip

General points such as “data could be hacked” stay at a low level. Explain why this data, from a chemist, is especially sensitive, and tie each point to these customers.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 37 questions in Show Working

This page shows 37 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE Computer Science topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free