Show Working
Open the app

GCSE Religious Studies · Crime and punishmentAQA, Edexcel, Eduqas and OCR

Crime and punishment: GCSE questions with answers

40 GCSE Religious Studies questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working Religious Studies bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 40 questions 5 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Crime and punishment questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

In Religious Studies, what is a sin?

  1. AA punishment given by a court
  2. BAn act believers say goes against God’s will
  3. CAny act at all that breaks the law of the land
  4. DA feeling of guilt after a crime
Show the answer

Answer: B An act believers say goes against God’s will

A crime breaks the law of the land; a sin, for believers, breaks God’s law. Some acts, like murder and theft, are both. Others, like adultery, are seen as sins by many Christians and Muslims but are not crimes in the UK.

Checked against ebible.org

02 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Sam steals a loaf of bread from a shop because her children have had nothing to eat for two days.

Why might many Christians and Muslims judge Sam less harshly than someone who steals out of greed?

  1. ABecause her intention was to help others
  2. BBecause theft is never a sin for the poor
  3. CBecause UK law allows theft of food
  4. DBecause bread is not worth very much
Show the answer

Answer: A Because her intention was to help others

Religions judge both the action and the intention behind it: Christians often say God “looks at the heart” (1 Samuel 16:7), and a hadith teaches that actions are judged by intentions (Sahih al-Bukhari 1). Many believers would still call the theft wrong but show compassion.

Checked against ebible.org

03 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

A surgeon cuts open a patient, causing pain, in order to save her life.

This example is often used in debates about good and evil to show that:

  1. Aall suffering is evil, whatever the aim behind it
  2. Bintentions never matter in judging an act
  3. Can act that causes pain can have a good aim
  4. Dsurgery is a kind of punishment
Show the answer

Answer: C an act that causes pain can have a good aim

Causing suffering is not always an evil act: what matters is also the intention and the result. Some people use the same idea about punishment, arguing that it can be good if it aims to reform the offender or protect others.

Checked against plato.stanford.edu

04 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Jo is dependent on drugs and steals phones to pay for them.

Which reason for crime does Jo’s case show most clearly?

  1. ASelf-defence
  2. BHatred of a group
  3. COpposition to an unjust law
  4. DAddiction
Show the answer

Answer: D Addiction

Reasons for crime named in GCSE RS include poverty and upbringing, mental illness and addiction, greed and hate, and opposition to an unjust law. Many believers hold offenders responsible but also want help for the addiction behind the crime.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

05 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

In 1963 Martin Luther King was jailed in Birmingham, Alabama, for leading a protest against racial segregation. Which reason for crime does this show?

  1. AGreed
  2. BPoverty
  3. COpposition to an unjust law
  4. DAddiction
Show the answer

Answer: C Opposition to an unjust law

Martin Luther King, a Baptist minister, was arrested in April 1963 for breaking a ban on demonstrations. In his Letter from Birmingham Jail he defended peaceful civil disobedience against laws that upheld segregation.

Checked against kinginstitute.stanford.edu

06 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“We must obey God rather than men.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Acts 5:29

Peter and the apostles said this when they were ordered to stop preaching. How do some Christians use it today?

  1. ATo argue against forgiving criminals
  2. BTo support the death penalty
  3. CTo support breaking a law they believe is unjust
  4. DTo argue that every law must be obeyed
Show the answer

Answer: C To support breaking a law they believe is unjust

Some Christians use Acts 5:29 to argue that conscience and God’s law come before an unjust human law. Most Christians still teach that the law should normally be obeyed (Romans 13:1).

Checked against ebible.org

07 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities”

The Bible, World English Bible, Romans 13:1

Christians who quote this verse usually argue that:

  1. Acriminals should never be punished
  2. Bunjust laws must always be broken
  3. Cgovernments have no authority from God
  4. Dpeople should obey the law of the land
Show the answer

Answer: D people should obey the law of the land

In Romans 13, Paul teaches that rulers have their authority from God. Many Christians use it to argue that obeying the law is part of their faith, which is one reason Christians condemn crime.

Checked against ebible.org

08 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What is a hate crime?

  1. AA crime committed against the state
  2. BA crime that has no victim
  3. CAny crime that causes serious injury to someone
  4. DA crime motivated by hostility to a group
Show the answer

Answer: D A crime motivated by hostility to a group

Police in England and Wales record five strands of hate crime: race or ethnicity, religion or belief, sexual orientation, disability and transgender identity. Many Christians and Muslims condemn hate crimes, teaching that every person is equally valued by God.

Checked against gov.uk

09 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“You shall not steal.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Exodus 20:15

This is one of the Ten Commandments. What does it forbid?

  1. AKilling another person
  2. BTelling lies about a neighbour in court
  3. CTaking what belongs to someone else
  4. DWorking on the Sabbath
Show the answer

Answer: C Taking what belongs to someone else

The commandment against stealing (Exodus 20:15) is one reason Christians condemn theft. Many Christians also want to help people whose poverty drives them to steal, following Jesus’ concern for the poor.

Checked against ebible.org

10 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“But whoso repenteth after his wrongdoing and amendeth, lo! Allah will relent toward him.”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 5:39

This verse comes straight after the Qur’an’s punishment for theft (5:38). What does it stress?

  1. AThat the victim must take revenge
  2. BRepentance and Allah’s forgiveness
  3. CThat theft can never be forgiven
  4. DThat thieves must leave the community
Show the answer

Answer: B Repentance and Allah’s forgiveness

The Qur’an sets a severe punishment for theft in 5:38, then says in 5:39 that Allah will relent towards a thief who repents and puts things right. Muslims see crime as breaking Allah’s law, and also teach that Allah is forgiving.

Checked against gutenberg.org

11 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“whosoever killeth a human being for other than manslaughter or corruption in the earth, it shall be as if he had killed all mankind”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 5:32

What does this verse teach about murder?

  1. AMurder is always forgiven if the killer is rich
  2. BKilling one person is like killing all people
  3. COnly the murder of a Muslim is wrong
  4. DMurder is a matter for the family alone
Show the answer

Answer: B Killing one person is like killing all people

Qur’an 5:32 shows how seriously Muslims take murder: every life matters as much as all humanity. Examiners note that pupils sometimes wrongly place this verse in the Bible; it is from the Qur’an.

Checked against gutenberg.org

12 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Which aim of punishment means making the offender pay for what they have done?

  1. AReformation
  2. BRetribution
  3. CProtection
  4. DDeterrence
Show the answer

Answer: B Retribution

Retribution means the punishment should fit the crime, so the offender gets what they deserve. Some people link it to the Old Testament idea of “eye for eye”; others say it can turn into revenge.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

13 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What is deterrence?

  1. AMaking the offender repay the victim
  2. BPutting people off committing crime
  3. CGetting revenge for the victim
  4. DHelping the offender to change
Show the answer

Answer: B Putting people off committing crime

Deterrence uses punishment to put the offender, and others, off committing crime. UK law names “the reduction of crime (including its reduction by deterrence)” as a purpose of sentencing (Sentencing Act 2020, section 57).

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

14 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What is reformation?

  1. AMaking an offender suffer
  2. BPutting other people off crime
  3. CHelping an offender change for the better
  4. DKeeping an offender away from the rest of society
Show the answer

Answer: C Helping an offender change for the better

Reformation aims to help the offender become a law-abiding member of society, for example through education and treatment. Many Christians stress it, believing that everyone can change and be forgiven.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

15 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Which aim of punishment means the offender making up for the harm done to the victim or community?

  1. AReformation
  2. BReparation
  3. CRetribution
  4. DDeterrence
Show the answer

Answer: B Reparation

Besides retribution, deterrence and reformation, UK law names protecting the public and reparation (making amends to those affected) as purposes of sentencing. Unpaid community work is one form of reparation.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

16 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Which law lists the purposes a court in England and Wales must consider when sentencing an adult?

  1. AThe Human Rights Act 1998
  2. BThe Sentencing Act 2020
  3. CThe Modern Slavery Act 2015
  4. DThe Equality Act 2010
Show the answer

Answer: B The Sentencing Act 2020

Section 57 of the Sentencing Act 2020 lists five purposes: punishment, reducing crime (including by deterrence), reform and rehabilitation, protecting the public (including victims), and reparation. This is UK law, not a religious teaching.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

17 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“eye for eye, tooth for tooth”

The Bible, World English Bible, Exodus 21:24

Which aim of punishment do some Christians support with this teaching?

  1. AReformation
  2. BReparation
  3. CRetribution
  4. DForgiveness
Show the answer

Answer: C Retribution

The rule is in Exodus 21:24, part of the Old Testament law, a rule often understood as making punishment fit the harm, not exceed it. Jesus quoted it in Matthew 5:38 to 39 in order to reject personal revenge, so it should not be given as Jesus’ own teaching.

Checked against ebible.org

18 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“Don’t seek revenge yourselves, beloved, but give place to God’s wrath.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Romans 12:19

How might a Christian use this verse in a debate about punishment?

  1. ACourts should always give the harshest sentence
  2. BVictims should not take revenge themselves
  3. CRetribution is the only aim of punishment
  4. DOffenders should punish themselves
Show the answer

Answer: B Victims should not take revenge themselves

Paul teaches that Christians should not take revenge but leave judgement to God. Many Christians use this to say that justice belongs to the courts and to God, not to angry individuals.

Checked against ebible.org

19 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents, than over ninety-nine righteous people who need no repentance”

The Bible, World English Bible, Luke 15:7

Which aim of punishment might a Christian support with this teaching of Jesus?

  1. AReformation
  2. BRetribution
  3. CProtection
  4. DDeterrence
Show the answer

Answer: A Reformation

Jesus taught that God rejoices when a sinner turns back. Many Christians use this to support punishments that help offenders change, such as education in prison and community sentences.

Checked against ebible.org

20 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“Retaliation is prescribed for you in the matter of the murdered”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 2:178

Qisas, the principle in this verse, means:

  1. Apaying a tax to the poor
  2. Bforgiving every crime
  3. Cleaving punishment to the next life
  4. Dfair retaliation for a wrong
Show the answer

Answer: D fair retaliation for a wrong

Qur’an 2:178 sets out qisas (fair retaliation) for murder, but says the victim’s family may forgive and accept compensation, called diyah (blood money). The verse calls this a mercy from Allah, so many Muslims see punishment as both justice and a chance for mercy.

Checked against gutenberg.org

21 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“But whosoever pardoneth and amendeth, his wage is the affair of Allah.”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 42:40

What does this verse encourage Muslims to do?

  1. AAvoid people who sin
  2. BReport every wrong to the police
  3. CAlways take full revenge
  4. DPardon those who wrong them
Show the answer

Answer: D Pardon those who wrong them

Qur’an 42:40 allows a wrong to be answered fairly but says that the one who pardons and makes peace will be rewarded by Allah. Many Muslims use it to show that forgiveness is better than revenge.

Checked against gutenberg.org

22 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“I was in prison and you came to me.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Matthew 25:36

In this parable Jesus says that serving people in need is serving him. How do many Christians act on this line?

  1. ABy avoiding people who commit crimes
  2. BBy campaigning for longer sentences
  3. CBy visiting and supporting prisoners
  4. DBy supporting the death penalty
Show the answer

Answer: C By visiting and supporting prisoners

In the parable of the sheep and the goats (Matthew 25), Jesus counts visiting prisoners among the acts done for him. This inspires prison chaplains and Christian volunteers who support prisoners and their families.

Checked against ebible.org

23 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What is Prison Fellowship (England and Wales)?

  1. AA Muslim charity that supports victims
  2. BA Christian charity that supports prisoners
  3. CA government department that runs all prisons
  4. DA humanist group that opposes prisons
Show the answer

Answer: B A Christian charity that supports prisoners

Prison Fellowship is a Christian charity whose volunteers support people in prison, for example through letter writing, prayer and work alongside prison chaplains. It is one way Christians put Jesus’ teaching about prisoners into practice.

Checked against prisonfellowship.org.uk

24 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Elizabeth Fry worked to improve conditions for women in Newgate Prison in the early 1800s. Which religious group did she belong to?

  1. AThe Salvation Army
  2. BThe Catholic Church
  3. CThe Baptist Union
  4. DThe Quakers
Show the answer

Answer: D The Quakers

Elizabeth Fry (1780 to 1845) was a Quaker who campaigned for prison reform. After visiting the women at Newgate she brought them education, work and religious guidance, an early example of Christians caring for prisoners.

Checked against londonmuseum.org.uk

25 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What is a community sentence?

  1. AA ban on leaving the country
  2. BA prison sentence served in a local jail
  3. CA punishment served outside prison, such as unpaid work
  4. DA fine paid to the local council
Show the answer

Answer: C A punishment served outside prison, such as unpaid work

A court may give a community sentence instead of prison, for example unpaid work called Community Payback. Many Christians support it because it allows reform and reparation, and keeps offenders with their families.

Checked against gov.uk

26 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What is restorative justice?

  1. APolice keeping watch on an offender
  2. BAn offender paying a fine to the court
  3. CVictim and offender talking, by choice, to repair harm
  4. DA judge choosing the longest sentence
Show the answer

Answer: C Victim and offender talking, by choice, to repair harm

Restorative justice brings victims and offenders into contact, only if both agree, so the offender can face the harm done and try to put it right. Many Christians support it because it joins justice with forgiveness and reconciliation.

Checked against gov.uk

27 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What is corporal punishment?

  1. APunishment by death
  2. BPunishment by a fine
  3. CPunishment that causes physical pain
  4. DPunishment by unpaid work
Show the answer

Answer: C Punishment that causes physical pain

Corporal punishment causes physical pain, for example caning or flogging. Capital punishment is the death penalty. Examiners report that pupils often mix up the two words, so learn them carefully.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

28 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Can a court in England sentence someone to be whipped today?

  1. AYes, for violent crimes only
  2. BNo, courts lost this power in 1948
  3. CNo, courts lost this power in 1998
  4. DYes, but only for young offenders
Show the answer

Answer: B No, courts lost this power in 1948

The Criminal Justice Act 1948 ended sentences of whipping. Today the Education Act 1996 (section 548) means no school staff in England may give corporal punishment, in any kind of school.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

29 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“One who spares the rod hates his son, but one who loves him is careful to discipline him.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Proverbs 13:24

A few Christians use this verse to defend:

  1. Athe death penalty for murder
  2. Bphysical discipline of children
  3. Ccommunity sentences
  4. Dforgiving every offender
Show the answer

Answer: B physical discipline of children

Some Christians read Proverbs 13:24 as allowing physical discipline. Many others say it is about loving discipline, not hitting, and that the Golden Rule (Matthew 7:12) and the dignity of every person rule out causing deliberate pain.

Checked against ebible.org

30 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Why do some Muslims say corporal punishment can be right for certain crimes?

  1. AUK law requires it for theft
  2. BThe Prophet banned all prisons
  3. CThe Qur’an sets it for every single crime
  4. DThe Qur’an sets it for some offences
Show the answer

Answer: D The Qur’an sets it for some offences

The Qur’an sets flogging for some offences, for example 24:2, and some Muslim-majority countries use it under Shari’ah law. Muslims in Britain live under UK law, where no court may sentence anyone to corporal punishment. Views among Muslims about using it today differ.

Checked against gutenberg.org

31 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“until seventy times seven”

The Bible, World English Bible, Matthew 18:22

Jesus said this when Peter asked how often he should forgive. What does it teach?

  1. AForgive exactly seventy times
  2. BForgive only people who apologise in public
  3. CForgive only family members
  4. DForgive without setting a limit
Show the answer

Answer: D Forgive without setting a limit

Peter suggested forgiving seven times; Jesus answered “seventy times seven”, meaning there should be no limit. Christians believe they should forgive because God forgives them.

Checked against ebible.org

32 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“Father, forgive them, for they don’t know what they are doing.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Luke 23:34

Who said these words, and when?

  1. AMoses, on Mount Sinai
  2. BPeter, in prison
  3. CJesus, on the cross
  4. DPaul, on the road to Damascus
Show the answer

Answer: C Jesus, on the cross

Jesus prayed for those who crucified him (Luke 23:34), an example many Christians try to follow. Many Christians teach that a victim can forgive while the offender is still justly punished, since forgiveness is about letting go of hatred.

Checked against ebible.org

33 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“Forgive us our debts, as we also forgive our debtors.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Matthew 6:12

This line from the Lord’s Prayer links God’s forgiveness to:

  1. Aconfessing to a priest
  2. Bbelievers forgiving others
  3. Cgiving to charity
  4. Dpaying all money owed
Show the answer

Answer: B believers forgiving others

Christians pray to be forgiven as they forgive others. Jesus goes on to say that God forgives those who forgive (Matthew 6:14), so many Christians see forgiving offenders as part of their faith.

Checked against ebible.org

34 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Many Muslims teach that one sin will not be forgiven if a person dies without repenting. Which is it?

  1. AStealing from a neighbour
  2. BMurder of another person
  3. CShirk, associating partners with Allah
  4. DTelling a lie
Show the answer

Answer: C Shirk, associating partners with Allah

Qur’an 4:48 says Allah does not forgive shirk but forgives other sins as He wills. Examiners warn that murder is not the one unforgivable sin in Islam; Muslims teach that Allah is merciful to those who repent.

Checked against gutenberg.org

35 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

In which decade was the death penalty for murder abolished in Great Britain?

  1. AThe 1920s
  2. BThe 1940s
  3. CThe 1960s
  4. DThe 1980s
Show the answer

Answer: C The 1960s

The Murder (Abolition of Death Penalty) Act 1965 says no one shall suffer death for murder; the sentence is life imprisonment instead. It ended for the remaining crimes, such as treason and piracy with violence, in 1998.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

36 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Put these changes to punishment in Britain in order, earliest first.

  1. AThe death penalty for murder is abolished
  2. BCourts lose the power to sentence people to whipping
  3. CThe death penalty for treason and piracy is abolished
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Courts lose the power to sentence people to whipping
  2. The death penalty for murder is abolished
  3. The death penalty for treason and piracy is abolished

Sentences of whipping ended with the Criminal Justice Act 1948. The death penalty for murder ended with the 1965 Act, and the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 (section 36) replaced death with life imprisonment for treason and piracy.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

37 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

Which UK law includes the right not to be condemned to death or executed?

  1. AThe Human Rights Act 1998
  2. BThe Education Act 1996
  3. CThe Modern Slavery Act 2015
  4. DThe Equality Act 2010
Show the answer

Answer: A The Human Rights Act 1998

Schedule 1 of the Human Rights Act 1998 includes Article 1 of the Thirteenth Protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights, which abolishes the death penalty. So the death penalty is now ruled out in UK law for every crime.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

38 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

What does the Catholic Church now teach about the death penalty?

  1. AIt is required for every murder
  2. BIt is allowed only for theft
  3. CIt is a matter for each priest to decide
  4. DIt is inadmissible and should be abolished
Show the answer

Answer: D It is inadmissible and should be abolished

Under Pope Francis, paragraph 2267 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church was revised to call the death penalty inadmissible, because it attacks the dignity of the person. The Church works for its abolition worldwide.

Checked against vatican.va

39 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“Whoever sheds man’s blood, his blood will be shed by man, for God made man in his own image.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Genesis 9:6

Some Christians use this verse to support:

  1. Athe death penalty for murder
  2. Bforgiving all murderers
  3. Ccorporal punishment in schools
  4. Dcommunity sentences
Show the answer

Answer: A the death penalty for murder

Some Christians argue from Genesis 9:6 and “life for life” (Exodus 21:23) that murder deserves death. Many other Christians, including the Catholic Church, oppose the death penalty because it ends any chance of reform and an innocent person may be executed.

Checked against ebible.org

40 / Crime and punishmentEvery board with this unit

“that ye slay not the life which Allah hath made sacred, save in the course of justice”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 6:151

Many Muslims understand this verse to mean that:

  1. Aall punishment is forbidden
  2. Btaking life is forbidden except through lawful justice
  3. Conly Allah may punish any crime
  4. Dtaking life is allowed in any quarrel
Show the answer

Answer: B taking life is forbidden except through lawful justice

Many Muslims accept that Shari’ah allows the death penalty for a few very serious crimes such as murder, through a proper legal process, while the victim’s family may forgive instead (2:178). Muslims hold different views on whether it should be used today.

Checked against gutenberg.org

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

12 marks + 3 SPaG / Do some crimes deserve deathAQA

‘Some crimes deserve the death penalty.’

Evaluate this statement. In your answer you should give reasoned arguments to support this statement and to support a different point of view, refer to religious arguments (you may also refer to non-religious arguments), and reach a justified conclusion.

What a full answer includes
  • For: some Christians cite Genesis 9:6 and ‘life for life’ (Exodus 21:23), seeing execution as just retribution for murder.
  • For: many Muslims accept that Shari’ah allows the death penalty for a few very serious crimes such as murder, with strict proof; the Qur’an allows taking life ‘in the course of justice’ (6:151).
  • For: some argue on utilitarian grounds that it deters others and protects the greatest number.
  • Against: since 2018 the Catholic Catechism teaches that the death penalty is inadmissible because it attacks human dignity (Catechism 2267); most British churches oppose it.
  • Against: Jesus rejected ‘an eye for an eye’ (Matthew 5:38 to 39) and stopped a stoning (John 8:7); execution removes any chance of reform.
  • Against: innocent people can be executed, as Timothy Evans was in 1950 (pardoned in 1966); Humanists UK opposes it as an irreversible breach of human rights.
  • In Islam the victim’s family may forgive or accept compensation instead (2:178), and some Muslims oppose the death penalty in practice.
  • UK law, kept separate: abolished for murder in 1965 and for all crimes by 1998.
  • A justified conclusion that separates ‘deserve’ from ‘should be used’.

Model answer

Some religious believers agree with this statement. Some Christians point to God’s words to Noah, that whoever sheds human blood will have their own blood shed, because humans are made in God’s image (Genesis 9:6), and to the law of ‘life for life’ (Exodus 21:23). They argue that murder is so serious that justice, or retribution, requires the murderer to pay with their own life. Many Muslims accept that Shari’ah allows the death penalty for a few very serious crimes, such as murder, but only after a fair trial with very strict standards of proof. The Qur’an forbids taking a life that Allah has made sacred ‘save in the course of justice’ (6:151), and says that there is life for people in the law of retaliation (2:179), meaning it protects society. Some non-religious people agree, arguing on utilitarian grounds that executions may deter others and so protect the greatest number. This argument has force because it takes the value of the victim’s life seriously. However, many believers disagree. Since 2018 the Catholic Catechism has taught that the death penalty is inadmissible, because a person’s dignity is not lost even after very serious crimes (Catechism 2267), and the Church works for its abolition worldwide. Most British churches also oppose it. Jesus rejected ‘an eye for an eye’, telling his followers not to take revenge (Matthew 5:38 to 39), and when a woman was about to be stoned he said that whoever was without sin should throw the first stone (John 8:7). Execution removes any chance for the offender to repent and be reformed. There is also the risk of killing an innocent person: Timothy Evans was hanged in 1950 and pardoned in 1966. Humanists UK opposes the death penalty as a breach of human rights that cannot be put right if a mistake is made. Even in Islam, the victim’s family may forgive the killer or accept compensation instead (2:178), and some Muslims oppose the death penalty in practice. In Great Britain it was abolished for murder in 1965 and for all crimes by 1998. I think the statement mixes two questions: whether some crimes are terrible enough to ‘deserve’ death, and whether the state should carry it out. Many people would agree that crimes such as mass murder are terrible enough. But the risk of executing the innocent and the loss of any chance of reform are strong reasons not to use it, and these arguments apply whatever a person believes. So I disagree that the death penalty should be used, although I accept that, for those who stress retribution, some crimes can seem to deserve it.

Where marks slip

Do not mix up capital punishment (the death penalty) with corporal punishment (physical pain). Remember that ‘an eye for an eye’ comes from Exodus, and that Jesus quotes it in order to reject revenge.

12 marks + 3 SPaG / Reform as the aim of punishmentAQA

‘Reforming offenders is the most important aim of punishment.’

Evaluate this statement. In your answer you should give reasoned arguments to support this statement and to support a different point of view, refer to religious arguments (you may also refer to non-religious arguments), and reach a justified conclusion.

What a full answer includes
  • The aims of punishment: retribution, deterrence, protection of society and reformation.
  • For: Christians believe everyone can repent; there is more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents (Luke 15:7), and Jesus told the woman caught in adultery to sin no more.
  • For: Jesus said visiting prisoners is visiting him (Matthew 25:36); Christian chaplains and the Quaker Elizabeth Fry, who visited Newgate Prison from 1813, show this concern.
  • For: Muslims believe Allah relents towards whoever repents and makes amends (5:39); Muslim chaplains support offenders; humanists favour rehabilitation.
  • Against: justice may require retribution; the Qur’an says the reward of an ill deed is an ill like it (42:40), and ‘eye for eye’ (Exodus 21:24) set fair limits.
  • Against: rulers punish wrongdoers (Romans 13:4), the public must be protected from offenders who will not change, and deterrence may prevent more victims.
  • A justified conclusion.

Model answer

Punishment has several aims: retribution, which makes the offender pay for what they did; deterrence, which puts others off committing crime; protection of society; and reformation, which helps the offender change so that they do not offend again. Many religious believers think reformation is the most important. Christians believe that every person can repent and be forgiven. Jesus said there is more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents than over ninety-nine who do not need to (Luke 15:7), and he told the woman caught in adultery to go and sin no more. Jesus also taught that visiting someone in prison is like visiting him (Matthew 25:36). This is why Christians work as prison chaplains and volunteers, and why the Quaker Elizabeth Fry campaigned, after visiting Newgate Prison in 1813, for better conditions and education for women prisoners. Muslims also believe that Allah will relent towards anyone who repents after wrongdoing and makes amends (Qur’an 5:39), and Muslim chaplains work in British prisons to help offenders change. Humanists support rehabilitation because it reduces future harm and treats offenders as people who can do better. This argument is strong because a reformed offender no longer harms anyone. Others think different aims matter more. Many religious believers stress that justice requires the offender to pay. The Qur’an says that the reward of an evil deed is an evil like it, although it praises those who forgive (42:40), and the Old Testament law of ‘eye for eye’ (Exodus 21:24) set out punishment that fits the crime. Paul taught that rulers are God’s servants who punish wrongdoers (Romans 13:4). Protecting the public also matters: some violent offenders refuse to change, and society must be kept safe from them. Deterrence may stop others committing crime in the first place, which would prevent more victims than reforming offenders afterwards. Weighing these, I think reformation is the most important aim, because it is the only one that deals with the causes of the crime and gives the offender a future, and it fits the belief, shared by Christians, Muslims and humanists, that people can change. But it cannot be the only aim. Victims need to see justice done, and the public must be protected while reform happens. So I agree with the statement, as long as reformation works alongside fair retribution and protection rather than replacing them.

Where marks slip

Name each aim of punishment correctly and keep reformation separate from forgiveness. The best answers compare reformation with the other aims instead of only praising it.

6 marks / How criminals should be treatedAQA

Explain two religious beliefs about the treatment of criminals. Refer to sacred writings or another source of religious belief and teaching in your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Christians believe criminals must be treated with dignity, because every person is made in God’s image (Genesis 1:27).
  • Developed: Jesus taught that visiting someone in prison is visiting him (Matthew 25:36), so many Christians work as prison chaplains or volunteers.
  • Muslims believe criminals must be treated with justice, with a fair trial and a fair punishment (4:135).
  • Developed: offenders should be helped to change, since Allah relents towards whoever repents and makes amends (5:39).
  • A named source applied to the point.

Model answer

One religious belief is that criminals must still be treated with dignity, because every person is made in the image of God (Genesis 1:27). Committing a crime does not take this worth away, so Christians oppose cruel or degrading treatment of prisoners. Jesus taught that when people visit someone in prison they are visiting him (Matthew 25:36). This shows Christians that caring for prisoners is a way of serving Christ, which is why many Christians work as prison chaplains or volunteer with groups such as Prison Fellowship. A second belief is that criminals must be treated with justice and given the chance to change. Muslims believe that Allah commands justice: the Qur’an tells believers to be staunch in justice, even against themselves, their parents or their relatives (4:135). So an offender must have a fair trial and a punishment that fits the crime, with no favouritism. The Qur’an also says that Allah will relent towards whoever repents after wrongdoing and makes amends (5:39), which is why Muslims believe offenders should be helped to reform, for example by Muslim prison chaplains.

Where marks slip

Make sure you explain beliefs about how offenders should be treated, not about the causes of crime or the aims of punishment in general.

12 marks / Forgiveness or punishmentEdexcel

‘Forgiveness is more important than punishment.’

Evaluate this statement, considering arguments for and against. In your response you must refer to Muslim teachings, refer to different Muslim points of view, and reach a justified conclusion.

What a full answer includes
  • For: Allah is the Forgiving and the Merciful, and Muslims should forgive as they hope to be forgiven (24:22).
  • For: whoever pardons and makes amends is rewarded by Allah (42:40), and the Qur’an urges believers to overlook and forgive (64:14).
  • For: in murder cases the victim’s family may forgive and accept compensation, which the Qur’an calls a mercy (2:178); giving up retaliation is an expiation (5:45).
  • For: the Prophet forgave the people of Makkah when he returned in 630.
  • Against: justice is a command of Allah (4:135, 16:90), and punishment protects society and gives victims justice.
  • Against: some Muslims stress the Shari’ah punishments as Allah’s law; a victim’s forgiveness does not remove society’s duty to keep people safe.
  • Many Muslims see the two working together: repentance and forgiveness alongside a fair sentence, supported by chaplains and restorative justice.
  • A justified conclusion.

Model answer

Many Muslims would agree that forgiveness is more important. Allah is described in the Qur’an as the Forgiving and the Merciful, and Muslims believe they should forgive others just as they hope Allah will forgive them; the Qur’an asks believers, ‘Yearn ye not that Allah may forgive you?’ (24:22). The Qur’an says that the reward for an evil deed is an evil like it, but whoever pardons and makes amends will be rewarded by Allah (42:40). Even in cases of murder, the family of the victim may forgive the killer and accept compensation instead of retaliation, which the Qur’an calls an alleviation and a mercy from Allah (2:178), and whoever gives up the right to retaliation earns forgiveness for themselves (5:45). The Prophet Muhammad set an example when he returned to Makkah in 630 and forgave the people who had persecuted him. This is a strong argument because it shows that Allah rewards forgiveness above revenge. However, other Muslims would say punishment is equally or more important. Justice is a command from Allah: the Qur’an tells Muslims to stand firm for justice even against themselves or their families (4:135), and says that Allah enjoins justice and kindness (16:90). Punishment protects society, deters others and shows victims that wrongdoing is taken seriously. Some Muslims emphasise the Shari’ah punishments set out in the Qur’an as part of Allah’s law, which shows that crimes must have consequences. A victim may forgive, but that does not always remove the need for society to keep people safe. Many Muslims see the two as working together. An offender who repents can be forgiven by Allah and welcomed back by the community while still serving a fair sentence. Muslim chaplains in British prisons support offenders in this way, and many Muslims support restorative justice, in which offenders meet their victims and try to make amends. Weighing the evidence, I think the Qur’an itself gives forgiveness the higher place, because it repeatedly praises those who forgive even when punishment or retaliation would be allowed. But the strongest argument against the statement is that forgiveness is a choice for the victim, while justice is a duty for society. So I conclude that, for Muslims, forgiveness is more important in the heart of the believer, but it does not replace fair punishment.

Where marks slip

Do not write that murder is unforgivable in Islam; mainstream teaching names shirk, not murder. Edexcel credits different Muslim views here, so avoid treating all Muslims as holding one view.

15 marks / Conscience as a moral guideEduqas

‘Your conscience is the best guide to what is right and wrong.’

Discuss this statement, showing that you have considered more than one point of view. You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Conscience is a person’s inner sense of right and wrong.
  • For: Paul says God’s law is written on people’s hearts, with conscience bearing witness (Romans 2:15); the Catechism calls conscience the core where a person is alone with God (1776).
  • For: Catholic teaching says a person must always follow the certain judgement of their conscience; Dietrich Bonhoeffer followed his conscience in resisting Hitler.
  • For: Muslims believe Allah inspired each soul with a sense of right and wrong (91:8); humanists see conscience, shaped by empathy and reason, as a key guide.
  • Against: conscience can be wrong; the Catechism says it must be educated and can err (1783, 1790), and people have done terrible things feeling sure they were right.
  • Against: Christians also use the Bible, Church teaching and prayer; Muslims treat the Qur’an and Sunnah as the surest guide; some philosophers trust reasoning about consequences more.
  • Absolute morality (fixed rules) and relative morality, such as situation ethics, give conscience different roles.
  • A justified conclusion on the word ‘best’.

Model answer

Conscience is a person’s inner sense of right and wrong, which makes them feel guilty when they do wrong. Many religious believers think conscience is a very important guide. Paul wrote that people who do not have God’s law still show that it is written on their hearts, with their conscience bearing witness (Romans 2:15). The Catholic Church teaches that conscience is a person’s most secret core, where they are alone with God, whose voice echoes within them (Catechism 1776), and that a person must always obey the certain judgement of their conscience. History gives examples of conscience standing against wrong: Dietrich Bonhoeffer, a German pastor, followed his conscience in resisting Hitler even though it broke the law. Muslims believe that Allah inspired every soul with an awareness of what is wrong and what is right for it (Qur’an 91:8). Humanists, who do not rely on scripture, also see conscience, shaped by empathy and reason, as a central guide to how to treat others. This argument is strong because every person has a conscience, whatever they believe. However, there are strong reasons to doubt that conscience is the best guide. Conscience can be wrong. The same Catholic teaching says that conscience must be educated and can make mistaken judgements (Catechism 1783 and 1790). People have done terrible things while feeling sure they were right, which suggests that conscience can be shaped by upbringing, culture or selfishness. For this reason Christians also look to the Bible, the teaching of the Church and prayer to guide them. Many Protestants see the Bible as the highest authority, and Catholics believe conscience must be formed by the Church’s teaching. Muslims believe the clearest guide is the Qur’an and the Sunnah of the Prophet, because human feelings can be misled. Some philosophers argue that reason, for example weighing up the consequences of an action, is more reliable than a feeling of guilt. There are also different views about morality itself. Those who believe in absolute morality think some actions are always wrong, so conscience must follow fixed rules. Those who believe in relative morality, such as supporters of situation ethics, think the most loving action depends on the situation, and conscience is needed to judge it. Weighing these views, I think conscience is essential but not the best guide on its own. The strongest argument for it is that every person must finally decide for themselves, as Bonhoeffer did. The strongest argument against it is that conscience can be wrong, which even the religious traditions that value it most accept. So I conclude that conscience is the best guide only when it is formed by something more reliable, whether scripture, religious teaching or careful reasoning.

Where marks slip

Eduqas examiners warn against rehearsed answers that do not fit the statement. Keep testing the word ‘best’ by comparing conscience with other guides, such as scripture, religious leaders and reason.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 44 questions in Show Working

This page shows 40 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE Religious Studies topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free