Show Working
Open the app

GCSE Religious Studies · Existence of God and revelationAQA, Edexcel, Eduqas and OCR

The existence of God and revelation: GCSE questions with answers

39 GCSE Religious Studies questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working Religious Studies bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 39 questions 6 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

The existence of God and revelation questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Walking across a heath, you find a watch. Its parts fit together so precisely to tell the time that you conclude someone must have made it.

This comparison is used in which argument for the existence of God?

  1. AThe problem of evil
  2. BThe argument from miracles
  3. CThe design argument
  4. DThe First Cause argument
Show the answer

Answer: C The design argument

William Paley argued in Natural Theology (1802) that, just as a watch shows it had a maker, the order and complexity of the world show it had a designer, whom he identified as God.

Checked against darwin-online.org.uk

02 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

The design argument says that God exists because the universe shows:

  1. Athat it had a beginning in time
  2. Border, purpose and complexity
  3. Cthat miracles break natural laws
  4. Dthat suffering has a purpose
Show the answer

Answer: B order, purpose and complexity

The design (teleological) argument starts from the order, purpose and complexity people see in the world and concludes that there must be an intelligent designer, God. The cosmological argument is the First Cause argument.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

03 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Many believers support the design argument by pointing out that:

  1. Aevolution explains how species change over time
  2. Bconditions in the universe seem just right for life
  3. Cthe universe has no clear beginning
  4. Dnatural disasters harm many people
Show the answer

Answer: B conditions in the universe seem just right for life

Many believers say the universe looks “fine-tuned”: if basic conditions were only slightly different, life could not exist. They see this as evidence of a designer. Critics reply that we would only be here to notice it in a universe that allows life.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

04 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Which thinker criticised the design argument by asking whether we have ever seen a world being made?

  1. AThomas Aquinas
  2. BBernadette Soubirous
  3. CWilliam Paley
  4. DDavid Hume
Show the answer

Answer: D David Hume

In Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779) Hume argued that the comparison between the universe and a human machine is weak: we have no experience of worlds being made, and a flawed world might suggest a botched job or several makers rather than one perfect God.

Checked against gutenberg.org

05 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Which scientific theory do many critics say explains the complexity of living things without a designer?

  1. AEvolution by natural selection
  2. BThe theory of gravity
  3. CGerm theory of disease
  4. DThe Big Bang theory
Show the answer

Answer: A Evolution by natural selection

Critics, including many atheists and humanists, argue that evolution by natural selection explains how complex living things developed without a plan, and that natural disasters and disease look like poor or cruel design. Humanists see humans as the product of natural processes.

Checked against understandinghumanism.org.uk

06 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Put the steps of the First Cause argument in order:

  1. AEverything that happens has a cause
  2. BBelievers say this first cause is God
  3. CA chain of causes cannot go back for ever
  4. DSo there must be a first cause that was not caused
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Everything that happens has a cause
  2. A chain of causes cannot go back for ever
  3. So there must be a first cause that was not caused
  4. Believers say this first cause is God

The First Cause argument says that everything has a cause, the chain cannot go back endlessly, so there must have been an uncaused first cause. Thomas Aquinas, and many believers after him, call this first cause God.

Checked against gutenberg.org

07 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Which thinker set out a version of the First Cause argument in the Summa Theologica?

  1. AThomas Aquinas
  2. BEpicurus
  3. CWilliam Paley
  4. DDavid Hume
Show the answer

Answer: A Thomas Aquinas

Thomas Aquinas, a 13th-century Christian thinker, gave “ways” of showing that God exists in his Summa Theologica. One of them argues from cause and effect to a first cause. This is often called the cosmological argument.

Checked against gutenberg.org

08 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Genesis 1:1

Why do some Christians say the Big Bang theory fits the First Cause argument?

  1. AIt suggests the universe had a beginning
  2. BIt proves living things evolved
  3. CIt shows the universe always existed
  4. DIt shows that miracles are impossible
Show the answer

Answer: A It suggests the universe had a beginning

Many Christians accept the Big Bang theory and say it fits with Genesis 1:1: if the universe had a beginning, something must have caused it, and they believe that cause was God. Others say the Big Bang needs no further cause.

Checked against ebible.org

09 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Which is a common criticism of the First Cause argument?

  1. AMany people report seeing visions
  2. BThe universe is too ordered to be the result of chance
  3. CScripture says that God made the world
  4. DIf everything needs a cause, what caused God?
Show the answer

Answer: D If everything needs a cause, what caused God?

Critics say the argument contradicts itself: if everything needs a cause, God should too, and the universe might have no beginning or simply be there. Believers reply that God is eternal and uncaused, unlike everything in the universe.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

10 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

In Religious Studies, a miracle is best described as:

  1. Aa vision seen in a dream
  2. Ba story that teaches people a moral lesson
  3. Can event that seems to break natural laws
  4. Dany event that brings good luck
Show the answer

Answer: C an event that seems to break natural laws

A miracle is an amazing event that seems to break the laws of nature, which believers see as God acting in the world. David Hume defined a miracle as a violation of the laws of nature.

Checked against gutenberg.org

11 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“Immediately the girl rose up and walked”

The Bible, World English Bible, Mark 5:42

In Mark’s Gospel this comes after Jesus tells a girl who was thought to be dead to get up. Christians see it as:

  1. Aa parable
  2. Ba vision
  3. Ca prophecy
  4. Da miracle
Show the answer

Answer: D a miracle

Mark 5 tells how Jesus raised the daughter of Jairus. Christians see Jesus' healings and raisings as miracles that show God’s power and love, and some argue that miracles are evidence that God exists.

Checked against ebible.org

12 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“This beginning of his signs Jesus did in Cana of Galilee, and revealed his glory; and his disciples believed in him.”

The Bible, World English Bible, John 2:11

According to this verse, what did Jesus' first sign lead to?

  1. AThe crowd arrested him
  2. BThe wedding was cancelled
  3. CHis disciples believed in him
  4. DHis disciples left him
Show the answer

Answer: C His disciples believed in him

John’s Gospel calls Jesus' miracles “signs”. At Cana the sign “revealed his glory”, and his disciples believed. Many Christians see miracles as a form of special revelation that can lead people to faith.

Checked against ebible.org

13 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

More than 7,000 cures have been reported at Lourdes. How does the Catholic Church treat them?

  1. AOnly about 70 have been recognised as miracles
  2. BNo cure has ever been recognised
  3. CEvery reported cure is declared a miracle
  4. DPilgrims vote on which cures count
Show the answer

Answer: A Only about 70 have been recognised as miracles

At Lourdes doctors in the Medical Bureau, then an international medical committee, check whether a cure can be explained. Only then can the bishop of the person’s home diocese declare a miracle. About 70 cures have been recognised.

Checked against lourdes-france.org

14 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Which was one of David Hume’s reasons for doubting reports of miracles?

  1. APeople love to believe amazing stories
  2. BDoctors always explain every cure
  3. COnly Christians report miracles
  4. DMiracles are described in the holy books
Show the answer

Answer: A People love to believe amazing stories

In “Of Miracles” (1748) Hume argued that no miracle has enough reliable witnesses, that people love the marvellous, that such stories come mostly from times of little learning, and that rival religions' miracles undermine each other.

Checked against gutenberg.org

15 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

A patient recovers from a serious illness after her family prays for her. The doctors are surprised.

Which explanation would an atheist most likely give?

  1. AA natural cause or a coincidence
  2. BGod answered the family’s prayers
  3. CHer recovery was a sign from God
  4. DAn angel came to heal her
Show the answer

Answer: A A natural cause or a coincidence

Atheists and humanists usually explain such events naturally: a cause doctors do not yet understand, a mistaken diagnosis, or coincidence. Many believers see the same recovery as an answer to prayer.

Checked against understandinghumanism.org.uk

16 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

If God is all-powerful, God could stop suffering. If God is all-loving, God would want to stop suffering. Yet suffering exists.

What do many atheists conclude from this argument?

  1. AMiracles prove God is powerful
  2. BGod created the universe out of love for people
  3. CAn all-powerful, all-loving God does not exist
  4. DSuffering is always a punishment
Show the answer

Answer: C An all-powerful, all-loving God does not exist

This is the problem of evil and suffering. In Hume’s Dialogues, Philo repeats Epicurus’s old questions: if God is willing but not able to prevent evil, God is not all-powerful; if able but not willing, not good. Many atheists see this as strong evidence against God.

Checked against gutenberg.org

17 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

An earthquake destroys a town. What kind of evil is this?

  1. ANatural evil
  2. BMoral evil
  3. CFree will
  4. DOriginal sin
Show the answer

Answer: A Natural evil

Moral evil is suffering caused by humans choosing to do wrong, such as murder or war. Natural evil is suffering caused by nature, such as earthquakes, floods and disease.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

18 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Many Christians say moral evil exists because God gave humans:

  1. Afree will
  2. Beternal life on earth
  3. Ca perfect world
  4. Dno conscience
Show the answer

Answer: A free will

Many Christians argue that God gave people free will so they could freely choose to love and do good. Moral evil is the result of humans misusing that freedom, so God is not to blame for it.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

19 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Which response to suffering says it can help people grow in qualities such as courage and compassion?

  1. ASoul-making
  2. BThe free will defence
  3. CThe design argument
  4. DThe First Cause argument
Show the answer

Answer: A Soul-making

Some Christians argue that a world with challenges and suffering lets people develop good qualities, like courage, patience and compassion, that they could not develop in a world without difficulty. This is often called soul-making.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

20 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“For my thoughts are not your thoughts, and your ways are not my ways”

The Bible, World English Bible, Isaiah 55:8

Some Christians use this verse to respond to suffering by saying that:

  1. AGod’s purposes are beyond human understanding
  2. BGod does not exist at all
  3. Chumans can end all suffering without God’s help
  4. Dsuffering is always a punishment
Show the answer

Answer: A God’s purposes are beyond human understanding

In Isaiah, God says his thoughts and ways are higher than human ones. Some Christians apply this to suffering: God may have reasons people cannot see. The story of Job, who keeps his faith through suffering, makes a similar point.

Checked against ebible.org

21 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“And surely We shall try you with something of fear and hunger, and loss of wealth and lives and crops”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 2:155

Many Muslims understand this verse to mean that suffering is:

  1. Athe work of a second, evil god
  2. Bsomething Allah does not know about
  3. Cproof that Allah is not real
  4. Da test from Allah
Show the answer

Answer: D a test from Allah

Many Muslims see suffering as a test of faith from Allah: the verse goes on to give “glad tidings to the steadfast”. Muslims believe Allah is all-knowing and that patience in hardship will be rewarded.

Checked against gutenberg.org

22 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Many religious believers who accept modern science say that science and religion:

  1. Acan never both be true
  2. Bsay exactly the same things
  3. Canswer different questions, how and why
  4. Dboth prove God exists
Show the answer

Answer: C answer different questions, how and why

Some atheists argue that science, through the Big Bang and evolution, explains the universe so there is no need for God. Many believers reply that science explains how the universe works and religion explains why it exists.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

23 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

What is an agnostic?

  1. ASomeone who worships many gods
  2. BSomeone who believes God exists
  3. CSomeone who thinks we cannot know if God exists
  4. DSomeone who is completely sure God does not exist
Show the answer

Answer: C Someone who thinks we cannot know if God exists

Atheists do not believe in God. Agnostics believe we cannot know whether God exists. Neither word says anything about a person’s morals, and atheists hold many different views.

Checked against understandinghumanism.org.uk

24 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Which statement describes a humanist view?

  1. AHoly books are the main guide to right and wrong
  2. BThere is life after death for everyone
  3. CThe world is best understood through evidence
  4. DGod reveals the truth through visions
Show the answer

Answer: C The world is best understood through evidence

Humanists think the world is natural, with no supernatural side, and is best understood through evidence and science. Many feel deep awe and wonder at nature and science, but they do not see it as revealing God.

Checked against understandinghumanism.org.uk

25 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

In Religious Studies, revelation means:

  1. Aa scientist making a discovery
  2. Ba person working out right and wrong
  3. Ca sudden change in the weather
  4. DGod showing or making himself known
Show the answer

Answer: D God showing or making himself known

Revelation is God showing himself to people. Special revelation is direct and given to particular people, for example in a vision, a dream or a prophecy. General revelation is open to everyone, through nature, scripture, reason or conscience.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

26 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“The heavens declare the glory of God. The expanse shows his handiwork.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Psalm 19:1

Christians often use this verse as an example of:

  1. Athe problem of evil
  2. Bspecial revelation in a vision
  3. Cthe First Cause argument
  4. Dgeneral revelation through nature
Show the answer

Answer: D general revelation through nature

General revelation is God being known through things everyone can experience. Psalm 19:1 says the sky itself shows God’s glory, so many Christians feel close to God when they look at the natural world.

Checked against ebible.org

27 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“For the invisible things of him since the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived through the things that are made”

The Bible, World English Bible, Romans 1:20

What does Paul suggest people can learn about God from creation?

  1. AThe exact date of the end of the world
  2. BThe names of all the angels
  3. CSomething of God’s power and nature
  4. DNothing at all about God
Show the answer

Answer: C Something of God’s power and nature

In Romans 1:20 Paul writes that God’s power and divine nature can be seen through what God has made. Christians use this to support general revelation: anyone can learn something of God from the world around them.

Checked against ebible.org

28 / The existence of God and revelationAQA

In AQA’s terms, a Christian learning about God by reading the Bible is an example of:

  1. Aspecial revelation
  2. Ba miracle
  3. Cenlightenment
  4. Dgeneral revelation
Show the answer

Answer: D general revelation

For AQA, general revelation comes through nature and scripture, which anyone can read and study. Christians believe God speaks through the Bible; Muslims believe the Qur’an is Allah’s final revelation.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

29 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“suddenly a light from the sky shone around him.”

The Bible, World English Bible, Acts 9:3

This describes Saul on the road to which city?

  1. ABethlehem
  2. BJerusalem
  3. CRome
  4. DDamascus
Show the answer

Answer: D Damascus

Acts 9 tells how Saul, who persecuted Christians, saw a light and heard the voice of Jesus on the road to Damascus. He became a Christian, known as Paul. Christians see it as a vision and special revelation that changed his life.

Checked against ebible.org

30 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

In Religious Studies, a vision is:

  1. Aa rule for fighting a just war
  2. Ban argument about how the universe came to exist
  3. Ca scientific theory
  4. Dseeing something sacred that others may not see
Show the answer

Answer: D seeing something sacred that others may not see

A vision is seeing something sacred, such as an angel or a holy figure, sometimes in a dream. Believers may see it as special revelation. Atheists and humanists may explain visions as dreams, hallucinations, illness, drugs, wishful thinking or even lies.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

31 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Catholics believe that in 1858 the Virgin Mary appeared in visions at Lourdes to:

  1. AThomas Aquinas
  2. BSaint Paul
  3. CBernadette Soubirous
  4. DWilliam Paley
Show the answer

Answer: C Bernadette Soubirous

Catholics believe that in 1858 the Virgin Mary appeared to a young girl, Bernadette Soubirous, at Lourdes in France. Lourdes is now a major place of pilgrimage, where many sick people go to pray.

Checked against lourdes-france.org

32 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“Read: In the name of thy Lord Who createth,”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 96:1

Muslims believe these were among the first words revealed to the Prophet Muhammad. Who brought them?

  1. AThe prophet Musa
  2. BThe prophet Ibrahim
  3. CThe angel Jibril
  4. DThe angel Mika’il
Show the answer

Answer: C The angel Jibril

Muslims believe the Qur’an was revealed to the Prophet Muhammad by the angel Jibril (Gabriel), beginning with the word “Read”. They see it as Allah’s final revelation. The Prophet’s sayings are the Hadith, a separate source.

Checked against gutenberg.org

33 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“He who has seen me has seen the Father.”

The Bible, World English Bible, John 14:9

Christians use these words of Jesus to show that:

  1. Anature is the only revelation
  2. BJesus was only a wise teacher
  3. CGod cannot be known at all
  4. DGod is revealed most fully in Jesus
Show the answer

Answer: D God is revealed most fully in Jesus

Christians believe Jesus is God in human form, so in Jesus God is revealed more fully than anywhere else. In John 14:9 Jesus tells Philip that whoever has seen him has seen the Father.

Checked against ebible.org

34 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

“In the creation of the heavens and the earth and (in) the difference of night and day are tokens (of His Sovereignty) for men of understanding”

The Qur’an, Pickthall’s translation, 3:190

Many Muslims use this verse to show that Allah can be known through:

  1. Adreams alone
  2. Bthe natural world
  3. Cvisions of angels only
  4. Dthe Hadith only
Show the answer

Answer: B the natural world

The Qur’an often calls features of nature “signs” or “tokens” of Allah. Many Muslims see the order of creation, like day and night, as pointing to Allah, which is a form of general revelation.

Checked against gutenberg.org

35 / The existence of God and revelationAQA

In Buddhism, enlightenment means:

  1. Aproving that God exists
  2. Breceiving a message from an angel
  3. Cseeing the true nature of reality directly
  4. Dreading the Bible every day
Show the answer

Answer: C seeing the true nature of reality directly

For Buddhists, enlightenment is direct insight into the truth about life. They believe the Buddha gained it while meditating under the Bodhi tree at Bodh Gaya. AQA treats enlightenment as a source of knowledge about ultimate reality that does not depend on God.

Checked against mahabodhi-mahavihara.bodhgayatemple.com

36 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Believers say God is omnipotent. What does this mean?

  1. AAll-loving
  2. BAll-powerful
  3. CPresent everywhere in the world
  4. DAll-knowing
Show the answer

Answer: B All-powerful

Christians and Muslims describe God as omnipotent (all-powerful), omniscient (all-knowing) and benevolent (all-loving). These qualities are what make the problem of evil and suffering so hard for believers to answer.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

37 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Believers who say God is immanent mean that God is:

  1. Aunable to act in the world
  2. Bonly a force with no personality
  3. Cpresent in and active in the world
  4. Dbeyond and outside the universe
Show the answer

Answer: C present in and active in the world

Immanent means God is present in the world and acts in it, for example through miracles and answered prayer. Transcendent means God is beyond the universe, time and space. Many Christians and Muslims believe God is both.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

38 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

A believer who prays to God as a loving father who cares about them sees God as:

  1. Atranscendent only
  2. Bpersonal
  3. Can unknowable force
  4. Dimpersonal
Show the answer

Answer: B personal

A personal God is one people can have a relationship with, who loves and listens, as many Christians and Muslims believe. An impersonal God is a force or power without human qualities. Different revelations give different ideas of the divine.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

39 / The existence of God and revelationEvery board with this unit

Why do some people doubt that revelation gives true knowledge about God?

  1. ARevelation is impossible to describe
  2. BRevelations are always the same
  3. COnly scientists have revelations
  4. DDifferent revelations seem to disagree
Show the answer

Answer: D Different revelations seem to disagree

Critics point out that revelations in different religions give different ideas of God, so they cannot all be right. A vision may change the life of the person who has it, but others cannot check it, so they may find it hard to accept.

Checked against cdn.sanity.io

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

12 marks + 3 SPaG / Too complex to be chanceAQA

‘The universe is too complex and ordered to have come about by chance.’

Evaluate this statement. In your answer you should give reasoned arguments to support this statement and to support a different point of view, refer to religious arguments (you may also refer to non-religious arguments), and reach a justified conclusion.

What a full answer includes
  • For: William Paley (1802) compared the universe to a watch found on a heath: complex parts working together imply a designer, whom believers call God.
  • For: fine-tuning: the physical constants seem precisely set to allow life.
  • For: Christians see nature as general revelation (Psalm 19:1, Romans 1:20), and Muslims see creation as signs of Allah (Qur’an 3:190).
  • Against: Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection (1859) explains complex living things without a designer.
  • Against: David Hume argued the universe is not much like a machine and that its flaws could point to a careless designer or several designers.
  • Against: natural evil such as earthquakes and disease seems to fit badly with a loving designer.
  • Many Christians and Muslims accept evolution and the Big Bang and see God as working through them.
  • A justified conclusion that stays on the words ‘by chance’.

Model answer

Many religious believers would agree with this statement. The design argument, set out by William Paley in 1802, asks us to imagine finding a watch on a heath. Its parts fit together so precisely for a purpose that we would conclude it had a designer. Paley argued that the universe, and living things such as the human eye, are far more complex than a watch, so they too must have a designer, whom believers call God. Many believers today add the fine-tuning argument: the strength of gravity and other physical constants seem to be set with great precision, and if they were even slightly different, life could not exist. Christians see the order of nature as general revelation, since ‘The heavens declare the glory of God’ (Psalm 19:1) and God’s power is seen in the things he has made (Romans 1:20). Muslims see the creation of the heavens and the earth and the alternation of night and day as signs of Allah for people of understanding (Qur’an 3:190). This argument is persuasive because order and purpose normally come from a mind. However, there are strong arguments on the other side. Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection, published in 1859, shows how complex living things such as the eye can develop gradually over millions of years without a designer. The philosopher David Hume argued that the universe is not much like a watch, because we have never seen a universe being made, and that even if it was designed, its flaws could point to a careless designer or a team of designers rather than the God of Christianity or Islam. Natural evils such as earthquakes and diseases are hard to reconcile with a loving designer. Atheists such as Richard Dawkins argue that, given billions of years and an enormous universe, ordered patterns are not surprising. Weighing these, I think evolution answers Paley’s examples from living things well, so the argument from the complexity of life is weaker than it seemed in 1802. However, evolution does not explain why the universe has laws that allow life at all, so the fine-tuning version remains a serious argument. Many Christians and Muslims accept evolution and see God as working through it. So I partly agree: science shows that complex things can arise without direct design, but it has not shown that the universe as a whole came about by chance, and believers can reasonably see its order as pointing to God.

Where marks slip

Answers often explain the design argument well but never test it. Give a weakness, say whether believers have a reply, and decide which is stronger, staying on the words ‘by chance’.

12 marks + 3 SPaG / Are visions proof of GodAQA

‘Visions are proof that God exists.’

Evaluate this statement. In your answer you should give reasoned arguments to support this statement and to support a different point of view, refer to religious arguments (you may also refer to non-religious arguments), and reach a justified conclusion.

What a full answer includes
  • A vision is seeing something, awake or in a dream, which the person believes is sent by God; it is a form of special revelation.
  • For: Saul saw a light and heard Jesus’ voice on the road to Damascus and became Paul, the great missionary (Acts 9:1 to 19).
  • For: Catholics believe Bernadette saw Mary at Lourdes in 1858; Muslims believe the Prophet Muhammad received the first revelation from the angel Jibril on Mount Hira (96:1 to 5).
  • For: the lasting change in a person’s life is argued to be best explained by a real encounter with God.
  • Against: atheists and humanists say visions can be hallucinations caused by illness, tiredness, fasting or drugs, dreams, wishful thinking, or occasionally lies.
  • Against: visions are private and cannot be tested, and people tend to see figures from their own religion.
  • Many Christians are cautious too: the Catholic Church investigates claimed visions and accepts few, and visions must agree with scripture.
  • A justified conclusion on the word ‘proof’.

Model answer

A vision is an experience of seeing something, while awake or in a dream, which the person believes has been sent by God. Many religious believers would argue that visions show God exists. In the Bible, Saul was travelling to Damascus to arrest Christians when a light from the sky shone around him and he heard Jesus’ voice asking why he was persecuting him (Acts 9:3 to 4). He was so changed that, as Paul, he became the greatest Christian missionary. Catholics believe that Bernadette Soubirous saw the Virgin Mary at Lourdes in 1858, and millions of pilgrims visit Lourdes today. Muslims believe that the Prophet Muhammad received the first revelation of the Qur’an from the angel Jibril in a cave on Mount Hira in 610 (Qur’an 96:1 to 5). Believers argue that such life-changing experiences are best explained by God really making Himself known. This is a strong argument for the person who has the vision, because it is direct experience. However, atheists and humanists argue that visions can be explained without God. People may have hallucinations caused by illness, lack of sleep, fasting or drugs; they may be dreaming; or they may see what they hope to see. A few may be lying. Visions are private, so nobody else can check them. People of different religions also tend to see figures from their own faith, which suggests that visions may come from a person’s own mind and culture. Even many Christians are cautious: the Catholic Church investigates claimed visions carefully and accepts only a few, and Christians believe that any genuine vision must agree with the Bible. I think the word ‘proof’ makes the statement too strong. A vision may be powerful evidence for the person who has it, and the change in someone like Paul is hard to explain away. But because visions cannot be tested and have possible natural explanations, they cannot prove to other people that God exists. So I disagree with the statement, while accepting that for believers a vision can be a genuine reason for faith.

Where marks slip

In Theme C, use non-religious arguments as well as religious ones, and remember that a vision is something seen, not the same as a miracle. Focus on whether visions are ‘proof’, not just on whether they happen.

6 marks / What nature shows about GodAQA

Explain two religious beliefs about what the natural world shows about God. Refer to sacred writings or another source of religious belief and teaching in your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Christians believe nature is general revelation that shows God is a great and powerful creator: ‘The heavens declare the glory of God’ (Psalm 19:1).
  • Developed: Paul says God’s everlasting power and divinity are seen through what he has made (Romans 1:20), so people can know God exists even without scripture.
  • Muslims believe creation is full of signs (ayat) of Allah (3:190).
  • Developed: the order and balance of nature show Allah is one, wise and merciful, which leads Muslims to thank Him and care for the world as khalifah.
  • A named source applied to the point.

Model answer

Christians believe that the natural world is a form of general revelation, a way in which God makes Himself known to everyone. Psalm 19:1 says that ‘The heavens declare the glory of God’, meaning that the size, beauty and order of the universe show how great and powerful the creator is. Paul goes further, saying that God’s everlasting power and divinity are clearly seen through the things he has made (Romans 1:20). This shows Christians that people can learn that God exists even without reading the Bible, and it leads many to feel awe and wonder at nature. Muslims believe that creation is full of signs (ayat) of Allah. The Qur’an says that in the creation of the heavens and the earth, and in the difference of night and day, there are signs for people of understanding (3:190). The balance and order of nature show Muslims that Allah is one, wise and merciful, and that everything depends on Him. This encourages them to thank Allah and to care for the world as His khalifah, or stewards.

Where marks slip

Keep to the question: it asks what nature shows about God, so explain the qualities revealed, not just that God made the world. Name the psalm or surah as well as quoting it.

12 marks / Miracles as evidence for GodEdexcel

‘Miracles are good evidence that God exists.’

Evaluate this statement, considering arguments for and against. In your response you must refer to Christian teachings, refer to non-religious points of view, and reach a justified conclusion.

What a full answer includes
  • A miracle is an event that seems to break the laws of nature, which believers see as God’s action.
  • For: Christians point to Jesus’ miracles, such as healing the official’s son (John 4:46 to 54), and above all the resurrection.
  • For: the Catholic Church has recognised about seventy healings at Lourdes as miracles after medical investigation.
  • Against: David Hume argued it is always more likely that a miracle report is mistaken than that a law of nature was broken.
  • Against: healings may have natural explanations such as misdiagnosis, natural remission or the placebo effect, and atheists ask why God heals a few but not millions.
  • Christian responses differ: Jesus refused signs on demand (Mark 8:12) and blessed those who believe without seeing (John 20:29); some Christians read some miracle stories symbolically.
  • A justified conclusion that appraises the strength of the evidence.

Model answer

A miracle is an event that seems to break the laws of nature and which believers think can only be explained by God’s action. Many Christians would agree that miracles are good evidence that God exists. The Gospels record many miracles of Jesus, such as healing a royal official’s son from a distance simply by saying ‘Go your way. Your son lives’ (John 4:50), after which the boy recovered at that same hour. Above all, Christians believe that God raised Jesus from the dead, which they see as the greatest miracle. Christians also believe miracles still happen. The Catholic Church has recognised about seventy healings at Lourdes as miracles, after detailed medical investigation found no natural explanation. For believers these show not only that God exists but that God is loving and acts in the world, which is a strong argument if the events really happened. Non-religious people, including humanists and atheists, disagree. The philosopher David Hume argued that, because the laws of nature are supported by a huge amount of evidence, it is always more likely that a report of a miracle is mistaken, exaggerated or invented than that a law of nature was really broken. Many apparent healings may have natural explanations, such as a wrong diagnosis, an illness getting better on its own or the placebo effect. Atheists also ask why a loving God would heal a few people at Lourdes but not prevent the suffering of millions, which seems unfair. Some Christians are cautious too. They point out that Jesus refused to perform signs on demand (Mark 8:12) and said that those who believe without seeing are blessed (John 20:29), so faith should not depend on miracles. Some Christians read certain miracle stories as pictures of spiritual truths rather than as literal events. Weighing the evidence, I think miracles can be good evidence for someone who already believes in God, because they fit a world in which God can act. But for someone who does not, Hume’s argument is strong, since the evidence for any single miracle is usually weaker than the evidence for the laws of nature, and the recognised Lourdes cases, while striking, are very few compared with the many millions of visitors. Therefore I conclude that miracles are not good evidence on their own, although they may support a faith that has other foundations.

Where marks slip

Edexcel wants you to appraise the evidence, not just list views. Say why Hume’s argument or the Lourdes evidence is strong or weak, and include the Christian responses to non-religious arguments.

15 marks / Suffering and the existence of GodEduqas

‘The amount of suffering in the world shows that God does not exist.’

Discuss this statement, showing that you have considered more than one point of view. You must refer to religion and belief in your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • The problem of evil: if God is omnipotent, omniscient and all-loving, why is there suffering? Epicurus and later David Hume argued such a God would prevent it.
  • Moral evil is caused by humans (war, murder); natural evil is not (earthquakes, disease), and is harder for believers to explain.
  • For: many atheists and humanists conclude that the amount of suffering, especially of the innocent, makes belief in such a God unreasonable.
  • Against: St Augustine taught that evil comes from the misuse of free will, beginning with the Fall (Genesis 3), so humans, not God, are responsible.
  • Against: St Irenaeus and John Hick argued that the world is a place of ‘soul-making’, where suffering lets people grow in courage and compassion.
  • Against: Christians believe God shares human suffering in Jesus’ death and will end it (Revelation 21:4); the Book of Job suggests God’s reasons are beyond us; Muslims see suffering as a test (Qur’an 2:155).
  • Weaknesses: free will does not explain natural disasters, and soul-making struggles with the sheer amount of suffering.
  • A justified conclusion on the word ‘shows’.

Model answer

This statement raises the problem of evil. Christians believe that God is omnipotent (all-powerful), omniscient (all-knowing) and all-loving. The ancient Greek thinker Epicurus, and later David Hume, argued that such a God would know about suffering, would want to stop it and would be able to stop it, yet suffering exists. Some suffering is moral evil, caused by humans, such as war and murder. Some is natural evil, such as earthquakes, famine and childhood cancer, which no human causes. Many atheists and humanists argue that the sheer amount of suffering, especially the suffering of innocent children and animals, shows that a loving and all-powerful God does not exist, or at least makes belief in one unreasonable. This is a powerful argument, because the scale of suffering, from the Holocaust to the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, is very hard to explain. Christians have given several responses. St Augustine taught that God created a good world and that evil came from the misuse of free will by angels and humans, beginning with Adam and Eve’s disobedience in Genesis 3. Humans, not God, are responsible for moral evil, and a world with real freedom is better than a world of robots. St Irenaeus, and in the twentieth century John Hick, argued instead that the world is a place of ‘soul-making’: suffering gives people the chance to develop courage, compassion and forgiveness, which could not exist in a world without pain. Christians also believe that God is not distant from suffering, since in Jesus God suffered and died on the cross, and they look forward to a time when God will wipe away every tear (Revelation 21:4). The Book of Job suggests that God’s reasons are beyond human understanding. Muslims, too, believe suffering can be a test: the Qur’an says that Allah will try people with fear, hunger and loss, and gives good news to those who are patient (2:155). However, these answers have weaknesses. Free will explains moral evil but not why there are earthquakes or diseases. Soul-making might explain some suffering, but critics ask whether a loving God needs so much of it, when much suffering seems to crush people rather than help them grow. Weighing the arguments, I think the problem of evil is the most serious challenge to belief in God, and the amount of natural suffering is its strongest part. But the statement says that suffering ‘shows’ that God does not exist, which goes too far. The theodicies give reasonable, if incomplete, explanations, and believers can accept that a God great enough to create the universe may have reasons beyond human understanding. So suffering is a strong reason to question belief in God, but it does not show that God does not exist.

Where marks slip

Eduqas examiners reward answers that weigh views, not ones that describe Augustine and then Irenaeus. After each response, say how well it answers the amount of suffering named in the statement.

12 marks / Suffering and a compassionate AllahEdexcel

‘The suffering in the world shows that Allah is not compassionate.’

Evaluate this statement, considering arguments for and against. In your response you must refer to Muslim teachings, refer to non-religious points of view, and reach a justified conclusion.

What a full answer includes
  • The problem of suffering: if Allah is all-powerful and compassionate, why do people suffer?
  • For (non-religious): atheists and humanists argue that the suffering of innocent people, such as children in earthquakes, fits badly with a compassionate God, or with any God.
  • Against: Muslims believe this life is a test; the Qur’an says Allah will try people with fear, hunger and loss and gives good news to the patient (2:155 to 156), and that life and death were created to see who is best in conduct (67:2).
  • Against: every surah but one opens by calling Allah the Beneficent, the Merciful, and Muslims believe the patient who suffer will be rewarded in the hereafter.
  • Against: much suffering comes from human choices; the Qur’an says corruption appears on land and sea because of what people have done (30:41).
  • Practical responses: prayer, zakah, sadaqah and charities such as Islamic Relief show compassion in action.
  • Divergent Muslim views on how far these answers succeed: some stress that Allah’s wisdom is beyond human understanding, others that a test must be fair.
  • A justified conclusion that appraises how strong each argument is.

Model answer

Some non-religious people would agree with this statement. Atheists and humanists point out that a great deal of suffering is not caused by anyone’s choices. Children die in earthquakes and floods, and many people suffer from painful illnesses. If Allah is all-powerful and truly compassionate, they argue, He would prevent such suffering. For many atheists this shows that there is no compassionate God at all. This argument is strong because the suffering of innocent people is real and very hard to explain. Muslims would disagree. They believe that this life is a test. The Qur’an says that Allah will try people with fear, hunger and the loss of wealth, lives and crops, and gives good news to those who are patient and who say that they belong to Allah and will return to Him (2:155 to 156). It also says that Allah created life and death to see which people are best in conduct (67:2). A test that had no hardship would not be a real test, and Muslims believe that those who stay patient will be rewarded in the life to come, so suffering is not the end of the story. Every surah of the Qur’an but one begins by calling Allah the Beneficent and the Merciful, and Muslims believe His compassion is shown in this reward. Much suffering is also caused by people, not by Allah: the Qur’an says that corruption has appeared on land and sea because of what people’s hands have done (30:41). Muslims also answer suffering in practical ways. They pray for those who suffer, and through zakah, sadaqah and charities such as Islamic Relief they help victims of disaster and poverty. Many Muslims see this as Allah’s compassion working through people. Muslims differ about how far these answers solve the problem. Some say that Allah’s wisdom is beyond human understanding, so people should trust Him even when they cannot see the reason. Others accept that the suffering of young children, who cannot be tested in the same way, remains hard to explain. Weighing the evidence, I think the non-religious argument is strongest for natural suffering of the innocent, which the idea of a test does not fully explain. But the statement says suffering ‘shows’ that Allah is not compassionate, and that is too strong. If life after death is real, a short time of suffering can be outweighed by a reward that lasts for ever, and the Muslim answer also explains why believers are called to relieve suffering. So I disagree with the statement, while accepting that suffering remains a serious challenge to belief.

Where marks slip

Edexcel wants judgements about how strong each argument is, not a list of views. Stay on the word ‘compassionate’, and give Muslim responses to the non-religious argument rather than describing them separately.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 39 questions in Show Working

This page shows 39 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE Religious Studies topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free