Show Working
Open the app

GCSE Geography · Natural hazardsAQA, Edexcel A, Edexcel B, OCR A, OCR B, Eduqas A and Eduqas B

Global circulation and tropical storms: GCSE questions with answers

32 GCSE Geography questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working Geography bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 32 questions 6 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Global circulation and tropical storms questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Put the three circulation cells in order, from the Equator to the North Pole:

  1. AFerrel cell
  2. BPolar cell
  3. CHadley cell
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Hadley cell
  2. Ferrel cell
  3. Polar cell

Each hemisphere has three cells. The Hadley cell runs from the Equator to about 30°, the Ferrel cell from there to about 60°, and the small Polar cell from there to the pole.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

02 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

At the Equator, strongly heated air rises. What does this give at the surface?

  1. AHigh pressure and clear skies
  2. BLow pressure and heavy rain
  3. CHigh pressure and drought
  4. DLow pressure and snow
Show the answer

Answer: B Low pressure and heavy rain

The Sun heats the Equator most, so air rises there in towering thunderstorms. Rising air means low pressure, cooling and heavy rain, which is why tropical rainforests grow in this belt, the Inter-Tropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ).

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

03 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Air sinks in the subtropics, at about 30° north and south. What does this create?

  1. ALow pressure and thunderstorms
  2. BHigh pressure and daily downpours
  3. CHigh pressure and dry weather
  4. DLow pressure and heavy rain
Show the answer

Answer: C High pressure and dry weather

Air that rose at the Equator sinks again in the subtropics. Sinking air warms and dries, giving high pressure, clear skies and little rain, so the world’s great hot deserts, such as the Sahara, lie in these belts.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

04 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Why does the UK often get unsettled, rainy weather?

  1. AIt lies in the Inter-Tropical Convergence Zone
  2. BIt lies under the high pressure of the pole
  3. CIt lies under sinking air at 30° north
  4. DIt lies near the polar front, where air rises
Show the answer

Answer: D It lies near the polar front, where air rises

Around 60° north, cold polar air meets warmer air from the subtropics and the air rises. This polar front gives low pressure systems (depressions) that bring the UK much of its wind and rain.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

05 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Surface winds blow:

  1. Aonly from west to east
  2. Bfrom high pressure to low pressure
  3. Cfrom low pressure to high pressure
  4. Donly from the poles to the Equator
Show the answer

Answer: B from high pressure to low pressure

Air moves from high pressure to low pressure. Air sinking in the subtropics flows back towards the low pressure at the Equator as the trade winds, the surface part of the Hadley cell.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

06 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

The Coriolis effect turns moving air to the right in the northern hemisphere. What causes it?

  1. AThe Earth spinning
  2. BThe Moon’s pull
  3. CHeat from the core
  4. DThe Earth’s tilt
Show the answer

Answer: A The Earth spinning

Because the Earth spins, moving air is turned to the right in the northern hemisphere and to the left in the southern hemisphere. This shapes the trade winds and makes air spiral around areas of low pressure.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

07 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

A tropical storm in the Atlantic Ocean is called a:

  1. Atornado
  2. Btyphoon
  3. Churricane
  4. Dmonsoon
Show the answer

Answer: C hurricane

They are all tropical cyclones with different local names: hurricanes in the Atlantic and north-east Pacific, typhoons in the north-west Pacific, and cyclones in the Indian Ocean and South Pacific.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

08 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Tropical storms need sea temperatures of at least about:

  1. A5 °C
  2. B15 °C
  3. C27 °C
  4. D40 °C
Show the answer

Answer: C 27 °C

Tropical storms need warm seas of at least 27 °C, light winds high up and enough spin, so they form over tropical oceans between about 5° and 30° from the Equator. That is why they cannot form near the UK.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

09 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Why do tropical storms not form right on the Equator?

  1. AThe sea there is too cold
  2. BThe air pressure over the Equator is far too high
  3. CThere is no rising air there
  4. DThe Coriolis effect is too weak to start a spin
Show the answer

Answer: D The Coriolis effect is too weak to start a spin

A tropical storm needs the Coriolis effect to set it spinning, and that effect is almost zero at the Equator. So storms form at least about 5° away from it, even though the sea on the Equator is warm enough.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

10 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Put these steps in order to show how a tropical storm forms:

  1. AWarm, moist air rises quickly from the sea
  2. BThe rising air cools and condenses, giving off heat
  3. CPressure at the centre falls and more air rushes in
  4. DThe Earth’s spin makes the system rotate
  5. EThe Sun heats the ocean to 27 °C or more
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. The Sun heats the ocean to 27 °C or more
  2. Warm, moist air rises quickly from the sea
  3. The rising air cools and condenses, giving off heat
  4. Pressure at the centre falls and more air rushes in
  5. The Earth’s spin makes the system rotate

Warm sea feeds warm, moist air upwards. As it condenses into huge clouds it releases heat, so the air rises even faster, pressure drops and more air is drawn in. The Coriolis effect turns the inflowing air into a spinning storm.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

11 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Where does a tropical storm get most of its energy from?

  1. AElectricity in lightning
  2. BThe pull of the Moon
  3. CHeat rising up from the Earth’s hot core
  4. DHeat released as water vapour condenses
Show the answer

Answer: D Heat released as water vapour condenses

A tropical storm gets most of its energy from heat released as water vapour from the warm sea condenses into cloud. Over land this supply of moisture is cut off, and friction slows the winds, so the storm breaks down.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

12 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

The eye of a tropical storm has:

  1. Asinking air, light winds and few clouds
  2. Brising air and towering clouds
  3. Cfreezing air and snow
  4. Dthe strongest winds and the heaviest rain
Show the answer

Answer: A sinking air, light winds and few clouds

The eye, usually 20 to 40 miles wide, is calm and often clear because air sinks there. Around it the eyewall, a ring of tall thunderstorms, has the heaviest rain and usually the strongest winds. Spiral rain bands trail outwards.

Checked against noaa.gov

13 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Roughly how wide is a mature tropical storm?

  1. A30 to 50 miles
  2. B3 to 5 miles
  3. C300 to 500 miles
  4. D3,000 to 5,000 miles
Show the answer

Answer: C 300 to 500 miles

A mature tropical storm is about 300 to 500 miles across and up to about six miles high. At its centre is the calm eye, ringed by the violent eyewall, with bands of cloud and rain spiralling outwards.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

14 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

The Saffir-Simpson scale rates hurricanes from 1 to 5 using:

  1. Athe number of deaths
  2. Bthe height of the storm surge
  3. Cthe total rainfall
  4. Dmaximum sustained wind speed
Show the answer

Answer: D maximum sustained wind speed

The scale uses only the highest sustained wind speed. Category 1 starts at 74 mph and Category 5 is over 156 mph. It does not measure storm surge or rain, which can still be deadly in a low category.

Checked against nhc.noaa.gov

15 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

A tropical storm becomes a hurricane, typhoon or cyclone when its sustained winds reach:

  1. A200 mph
  2. B10 mph
  3. C39 mph
  4. D74 mph
Show the answer

Answer: D 74 mph

A cluster of storms first becomes a tropical depression. At 39 mph it is a named tropical storm, and at 74 mph it becomes a hurricane, typhoon or cyclone, depending on where it is.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

16 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

A rise in sea level pushed onto the coast by a tropical storm is a:

  1. Atsunami
  2. Bspring tide
  3. Clahar
  4. Dstorm surge
Show the answer

Answer: D storm surge

Strong winds pile sea water onto the coast and low pressure lets the sea rise a little more, giving a storm surge of up to several metres. Tropical storms also bring damaging winds, flooding rain, huge waves and sometimes tornadoes.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

17 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

When is the Atlantic hurricane season?

  1. AAll year, evenly spread
  2. BJune to November
  3. CMarch to May
  4. DDecember to March
Show the answer

Answer: B June to November

The Atlantic season runs from June to November, when the sea is warmest. The north-west Pacific has typhoons all year, with most from July to November.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

18 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Typhoon Haiyan, called Yolanda in the Philippines, November 2013.

Which country did Typhoon Haiyan hit hardest?

  1. ABangladesh
  2. BJapan
  3. CMozambique
  4. DThe Philippines
Show the answer

Answer: D The Philippines

Haiyan formed in the western Pacific in early November 2013. It first reached land at Guiuan in Eastern Samar early on 8 November, then crossed Leyte near Tacloban on Leyte Gulf.

Checked against reliefweb.int

19 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Typhoon Haiyan, Philippines, November 2013.

Haiyan was one of the strongest storms ever to reach land. Its winds at landfall were roughly:

  1. A30 km/h
  2. B300 km/h
  3. C1,000 km/h
  4. D100 km/h
Show the answer

Answer: B 300 km/h

The US military’s Joint Typhoon Warning Centre put Haiyan’s one-minute winds at about 305 km/h when it reached land in 2013. The Philippine weather service, which averages over ten minutes, gave 235 km/h. Both make it one of the strongest landfalls on record.

Checked against metoc.navy.mil

20 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Typhoon Haiyan, Philippines, November 2013.

Roughly how high was the storm surge in Tacloban?

  1. AAbout 50 metres
  2. BAbout 50 centimetres
  3. CAbout 5 to 6 metres
  4. DAbout 1 metre
Show the answer

Answer: C About 5 to 6 metres

Leyte Gulf funnelled the sea into Tacloban, giving a storm surge of about 5 to 6 m in 2013. Much of the city sits low by the shore, so the surge swept through homes and caused many of the deaths.

Checked against doi.org

21 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Typhoon Haiyan, Philippines, November 2013.

Roughly how many people died?

  1. AOver 6,000
  2. BAbout 600
  3. CAbout 60
  4. DOver 60,000
Show the answer

Answer: A Over 6,000

The Philippine disaster agency counted 6,293 dead, 28,689 injured and 1,061 missing by April 2014. About 14 million people were affected, about 4 million displaced, and over 1.1 million houses damaged.

Checked against reliefweb.int

22 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Typhoon Haiyan, Philippines, November 2013.

Which was a secondary effect of Haiyan?

  1. AHouses flattened by strong winds
  2. BRoofs torn off buildings
  3. CTrees blown down by the wind
  4. DPower cut off for weeks in Tacloban
Show the answer

Answer: D Power cut off for weeks in Tacloban

Primary effects come straight from the storm: wind damage, the surge and flooding. Secondary effects follow from them: in 2013 power was out for weeks in Tacloban, the airport worked only partly for months, and farming and jobs were lost.

Checked against reliefweb.int

23 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Typhoon Haiyan, Philippines, November 2013.

Which was an immediate response?

  1. AHomes rebuilt away from the coast
  2. BA long-term rebuilding plan launched in December 2013
  3. CThe government declared a state of national calamity
  4. DNew storm shelters built over years
Show the answer

Answer: C The government declared a state of national calamity

The Philippines declared a state of national calamity on 11 November 2013 and accepted international help. The UN’s plan of 10 December 2013 asked for US$791 million. One year on, about 475,000 people were still in unsafe shelters.

Checked against reliefweb.int

24 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

What do scientists expect warmer seas to do to tropical storms?

  1. AMake every single one of them weaker and drier
  2. BStop them forming at all
  3. CMake the strongest ones fiercer and wetter
  4. DMake their rain lighter
Show the answer

Answer: C Make the strongest ones fiercer and wetter

Warmer seas give storms more energy and warmer air holds more water, so the strongest storms are expected to have stronger winds and heavier rain. Rising sea levels also let storm surges reach further inland.

Checked against science.nasa.gov

25 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

How do forecasters track a tropical storm days before it reaches land?

  1. AWith satellites and computer models
  2. BWith tiltmeters on volcanoes
  3. CWith rain gauges in towns
  4. DWith seismometers on the sea bed
Show the answer

Answer: A With satellites and computer models

Satellites watch storms form far out at sea, and computer models forecast their path and strength days ahead. Warnings give time to evacuate, board up homes and move to storm shelters.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

26 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Hurricane Katrina, USA, August 2005.

About 80% of New Orleans flooded. Why?

  1. AHeavy snow melted suddenly
  2. BThe Mississippi froze over and burst its banks
  3. CA tsunami struck the city
  4. DLevees failed under the storm surge
Show the answer

Answer: D Levees failed under the storm surge

Katrina reached land on 29 August 2005 as a strong Category 3 hurricane. Its storm surge broke through the levees protecting New Orleans, flooding about 80% of the city. Damage was about US$125 billion.

Checked against nhc.noaa.gov

27 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Cyclone Idai, March 2019.

Idai reached land near which city in Mozambique?

  1. ATacloban
  2. BNew Orleans
  3. CManila
  4. DBeira
Show the answer

Answer: D Beira

Idai reached land near Beira, Mozambique, on 14 to 15 March 2019. Mozambique’s government counted 598 dead by early April, over 198,000 houses were damaged or destroyed, 715,000 ha of crops were lost and cholera broke out in Beira.

Checked against reliefweb.int

28 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

What does sinking air usually bring?

  1. AThunderstorms and hail
  2. BHigh pressure and clear skies
  3. CLow pressure and gales
  4. DLow pressure and rain
Show the answer

Answer: B High pressure and clear skies

Rising air cools, so its water vapour condenses into cloud and rain, and pressure at the surface is low. Sinking air warms and dries, so clouds clear and pressure is high.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

29 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Why is the Equator warmer than the poles?

  1. AIt has fewer oceans
  2. BIt has more volcanoes
  3. CIt is much closer to the Sun than the poles are
  4. DThe Sun’s rays strike it more directly
Show the answer

Answer: D The Sun’s rays strike it more directly

Near the Equator the Sun is high in the sky, so its energy is concentrated on a small area. Near the poles the same energy is spread over a bigger area. This uneven heating drives the global circulation of the atmosphere.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

30 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

A typical eye of a tropical storm is roughly how wide?

  1. A200 to 400 miles
  2. B2,000 to 4,000 miles
  3. C20 to 40 metres
  4. D20 to 40 miles
Show the answer

Answer: D 20 to 40 miles

The eye is usually 20 to 40 miles wide, a small calm patch in a storm hundreds of miles across. People sometimes go outside as the eye passes, only to be caught when the other side of the eyewall arrives.

Checked against noaa.gov

31 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEvery board

Air sinks over the North and South Poles. What does this give?

  1. ATropical storms
  2. BHeavy rain all year
  3. CWarm, wet low pressure
  4. DCold, dry high pressure
Show the answer

Answer: D Cold, dry high pressure

In the small Polar cell, cold dense air sinks over the poles, giving high pressure and very little precipitation. It then flows back towards lower latitudes along the surface.

Checked against weather.metoffice.gov.uk

32 / Global circulation and tropical stormsEdexcel A, OCR A and OCR B

El Niño is an unusual warming of the sea surface in which ocean?

  1. AThe central and eastern Pacific
  2. BThe Arctic Ocean
  3. CThe North Atlantic
  4. DThe Mediterranean Sea
Show the answer

Answer: A The central and eastern Pacific

Every few years the sea surface in the central and eastern Pacific warms unusually: El Niño. It shifts where rain falls. The WMO lists drought in eastern and northern Australia, Indonesia, southern Africa and parts of South Asia, but more rain and flooding in East Africa and parts of the Americas.

Checked against wmo.int

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

6 marks / How global circulation shapes climateAQA, OCR A, OCR B, Eduqas A and Eduqas B

Explain how global atmospheric circulation affects weather and climate in different parts of the world.

What a full answer includes
  • The Sun heats the Equator most strongly, so warm air rises there.
  • Rising air at the Equator gives low pressure, cloud and heavy rain all year, the climate of tropical rainforests.
  • Air sinks at about 30° north and south, giving high pressure, clear skies and little rain, where most hot deserts lie.
  • Air moves along the surface from high to low pressure as winds, such as the trade winds, turned by the Earth’s spin.
  • Each hemisphere has three cells: the Hadley, Ferrel and Polar cells.
  • At about 60° cold polar air meets warmer air and rises, giving depressions that bring wind and rain to places such as the UK.
  • At the poles air sinks, giving high pressure and cold, dry conditions.

Model answer

Global circulation is driven by uneven heating. The Sun heats the Equator most, so warm air rises there. As it rises it cools and its water vapour condenses, so the Equator has low pressure, towering clouds and heavy rain almost every day. This explains why tropical rainforests grow there. The risen air spreads towards the poles and sinks at about 30° north and south. Sinking air warms and dries, giving high pressure and clear skies, so these latitudes have very little rain. That is why most hot deserts, such as the Sahara, lie near 30°. The air then flows back along the surface towards the Equator as the trade winds, turned by the Earth’s spin. This loop is the Hadley cell. Nearer the poles are the Ferrel and Polar cells. At about 60° cold polar air meets warmer air from the south and is forced to rise along the polar front. This gives low pressure and depressions, which bring the UK much of its wind and rain. At the poles cold air sinks, giving high pressure and dry, freezing conditions.

Where marks slip

Describing the three cells without saying what weather they cause. For each belt, say whether air rises or sinks, what pressure that makes and what weather follows.

6 marks / How tropical storms formAQA, OCR A, OCR B, Eduqas A and Eduqas B

Explain how tropical storms form and develop.

What a full answer includes
  • They need sea water of at least 27 °C, which heats the air above and supplies water vapour.
  • They form between about 5° and 30° from the Equator, because the spin from the Coriolis effect is almost zero at the Equator itself.
  • Warm, moist air rises quickly, cools and condenses, releasing heat that drives more rising air: about 90% of the storm’s energy comes from this.
  • Low pressure at the surface draws in more warm, moist air, so the storm feeds itself and grows.
  • Light winds high up let the storm grow tall without being torn apart.
  • Air sinks in the calm eye, while the eyewall around it has the strongest winds and heaviest rain.
  • Over land or cooler sea the supply of moisture is cut and friction slows the winds, so the storm weakens.

Model answer

Tropical storms form over oceans where the water is at least 27 °C. The warm sea heats the air above it, and lots of water evaporates, so the air is warm and moist. This air rises quickly, creating low pressure at the surface. As the air rises it cools and the water vapour condenses into towering clouds. Condensation releases heat, which makes the air rise even faster; the Met Office says about 90% of a storm’s energy comes from this. More warm, moist air rushes in at the surface to replace it, so the storm keeps feeding itself. Light winds high in the atmosphere allow it to grow tall without being torn apart. The storm must form at least about 5° from the Equator, because the Coriolis effect, which sets it spinning, is almost zero at the Equator. As it spins faster, air sinks in the centre to form the calm eye, surrounded by the eyewall with the strongest winds. When the storm moves over land or cooler water, its supply of moisture is cut and friction slows the winds, so it dies out.

Where marks slip

Listing the conditions without explaining the order of events. Show how each step leads to the next, and remember storms do not form on the Equator itself because there is too little spin.

9 marks + 3 SPaG / Typhoon Haiyan: which effects were worse?AQA

“The secondary effects of a tropical storm are more serious than its primary effects.”

Using a named example of a tropical storm, to what extent do you agree with this statement?

What a full answer includes
  • Names the storm and place: Typhoon Haiyan, the Philippines, November 2013.
  • Primary effects come straight from the storm: winds of about 305 km/h at landfall and a storm surge of about 5 to 6 m in Tacloban.
  • Primary effects caused most deaths: 6,293 dead, 28,689 injured and 1,061 missing, many swept away by the surge.
  • Over 1.1 million houses were damaged and about 4 million people displaced.
  • Secondary effects followed: power out for weeks in Tacloban, the airport only partly working for months, farming and jobs lost.
  • Secondary effects lasted far longer: a year later about 475,000 people were still in unsafe shelters.
  • Weighs short-term loss of life against long-term hardship.
  • Reaches a supported judgement that answers “to what extent”.

Model answer

For Typhoon Haiyan I mostly disagree: the primary effects were more serious because they caused nearly all the deaths, although the secondary effects lasted much longer. Haiyan reached land at Guiuan in the Philippines on 8 November 2013, with one-minute winds of about 305 km/h. Leyte Gulf funnelled the sea into Tacloban, giving a storm surge of about 5 to 6 m. Much of the city sits low by the shore, so the surge swept through homes. The disaster agency counted 6,293 dead, 28,689 injured and 1,061 missing. Over 1.1 million houses were damaged and about 4 million people were displaced. These primary effects destroyed lives and homes in a few hours. The secondary effects were serious in a different way. Power was cut for weeks in Tacloban and the airport worked only partly for months, which slowed the delivery of aid. Crops and jobs were lost, so many families lost their income as well as their homes. A year later about 475,000 people were still living in unsafe shelters, which shows how long the secondary effects lasted, especially for poorer families. Overall, the primary effects were more serious because of the scale of death and destruction. However, the secondary effects turned a few days of disaster into years of hardship, so the statement is partly true for the long term.

Where marks slip

Mixing up primary and secondary effects. Primary effects come straight from the wind, rain and surge; secondary effects follow from them. Then judge “more serious” instead of writing two lists.

8 marks + 4 SPaG / Cyclone responses in two countriesEdexcel A

Evaluate the effectiveness of the responses to a tropical cyclone in a developed country and in an emerging or developing country.

What a full answer includes
  • Names a developed-country example: Hurricane Katrina, USA, landfall 29 August 2005 as a strong Category 3.
  • Katrina: an evacuation was ordered before landfall, but many people without cars stayed; levees failed and about 80% of New Orleans flooded.
  • Katrina: the relief effort was widely criticised as slow, and deaths reached 1,392 (National Hurricane Center, 2023 revision), with damage of about US$125 billion.
  • Names an emerging or developing example: Typhoon Haiyan, the Philippines, November 2013.
  • Haiyan: a national calamity was declared on 11 November and international help accepted; the UN’s plan asked for US$791 million.
  • Haiyan: recovery was slow, with about 475,000 people still in unsafe shelters a year later.
  • Evaluates how wealth, planning and access shaped the responses in each country.
  • Ends with a supported judgement on which responses were more effective.

Model answer

Neither response was fully effective, but the USA’s wealth gave it a better chance of recovering, even though its emergency response failed many people. Hurricane Katrina reached land on 29 August 2005. An evacuation of New Orleans was ordered before landfall, which saved lives, but many poorer people without cars could not leave. When the levees broke, about 80% of the city flooded. The relief effort was widely criticised as slow, and the National Hurricane Center’s revised count is 1,392 deaths. Damage was about US$125 billion, but the USA could pay to rebuild the levees and the city. Typhoon Haiyan struck the Philippines on 8 November 2013. The government declared a national calamity on 11 November and accepted international help, and the UN asked for US$791 million in December. This brought food, water and shelter to millions, but recovery depended on outside money. A year later about 475,000 people were still in unsafe shelters, so long-term rebuilding was slow. In conclusion, the short-term responses in both countries were weakest for the poorest people. The USA’s long-term response was more effective because it had its own money to rebuild, while the Philippines relied on aid, so its recovery took much longer.

Where marks slip

Writing about damage instead of judging how well the responses worked. Edexcel examiners capped answers at Level 1 when a developed-country example was used where an emerging or developing one was asked.

8 marks / The impacts of Cyclone IdaiEdexcel B

Assess the impacts of a tropical cyclone on a developing or emerging country.

What a full answer includes
  • Names the event: Cyclone Idai, which reached land near Beira, Mozambique, on 14 to 15 March 2019.
  • Social impact: Mozambique’s government counted 598 dead by early April 2019.
  • Over 198,000 houses were damaged or destroyed, leaving many families homeless.
  • Economic impact: 715,000 ha of crops were lost, cutting food supply and farm incomes.
  • A secondary impact: cholera broke out in Beira from 27 March, because water and sanitation were damaged.
  • Explains why impacts were severe: a poor country with weak housing and limited money for recovery.
  • Weighs short-term against long-term impacts and decides which mattered most.

Model answer

The most serious impacts of Cyclone Idai were the long-term ones, because they hit food, health and homes in a country with little money to recover. Idai reached land near Beira in Mozambique on 14 to 15 March 2019. The immediate impact was loss of life: by early April the government had counted 598 dead. Over 198,000 houses were damaged or destroyed, so many families lost everything they owned, and in a developing country few have insurance. The economic impact was even wider. About 715,000 ha of crops were lost. Most people in rural Mozambique grow their own food, so this meant hunger as well as lost income, and it lasted until the next harvest or longer. There was also a health impact. Floodwater damaged water supplies and sanitation, and cholera broke out in Beira from 27 March. This secondary impact could have killed many more people without treatment and clean water. Overall, the deaths were the most tragic impact, but the loss of homes and crops affected far more people for far longer. Because Mozambique is poor, these long-term impacts were the most significant.

Where marks slip

“Assess” means weighing the impacts and deciding which mattered most, not listing them. Say who was affected, for how long, and why the country’s level of development made it worse.

8 marks / Haiyan: physical or human causes?OCR B, Eduqas A and Eduqas B

Using a located example, to what extent were the effects of a tropical storm caused by human factors rather than physical ones?

What a full answer includes
  • Names the event: Typhoon Haiyan, the Philippines, November 2013.
  • Physical: one of the strongest landfalls on record, one-minute winds of about 305 km/h.
  • Physical: Leyte Gulf funnelled the sea into Tacloban, giving a surge of about 5 to 6 m.
  • Human: much of Tacloban is built low by the shore, so many homes were in the path of the surge.
  • Human: weak housing and poverty meant over 1.1 million houses were damaged and recovery was slow.
  • Effects to link to: 6,293 dead, about 4 million displaced, about 475,000 still in unsafe shelters a year later.
  • Decides which set of factors mattered more, with a reason.

Model answer

Haiyan’s effects started with physical factors, but human factors decided how many people were harmed and for how long. Physically, Haiyan was extreme. When it reached land on 8 November 2013, its one-minute winds were about 305 km/h, one of the strongest landfalls on record. The shape of the coast made things worse: Leyte Gulf funnelled the sea into Tacloban, giving a storm surge of about 5 to 6 m. No country could have stopped a storm of that power. However, human factors turned the hazard into a disaster. Much of Tacloban is built low by the shore, so many homes stood right in the path of the surge, which caused many of the 6,293 deaths. Many houses were lightly built, so over 1.1 million were damaged and about 4 million people were displaced. Poverty also slowed recovery: a year later about 475,000 people were still living in unsafe shelters. Overall, the physical strength of the storm caused the hazard, but human factors, especially where and how people lived, explain most of the deaths and the long recovery. So the effects were caused more by human factors than physical ones.

Where marks slip

Writing only about the storm’s strength. The question asks you to weigh physical against human factors, so give both sides and finish with a clear judgement.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 32 questions in Show Working

This page shows 32 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap. This topic is free to try.

More GCSE Geography topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free