Show Working
Open the app

GCSE History · The American WestAQA, Edexcel, OCR A, OCR B (Schools History Project) and Eduqas

Conflict on the Plains and its end: GCSE questions with answers

36 GCSE History questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working History bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 36 questions 5 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Conflict on the Plains and its end questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

The Dakota War broke out in Minnesota in August 1862 at a time when many Dakota were facing:

  1. AA flood on the Mississippi
  2. BA gold rush on their land
  3. CAn attack by the Confederacy
  4. DStarvation
Show the answer

Answer: D Starvation

The war lasted about six weeks. A military tribunal sentenced more than 300 Dakota men to death; Lincoln commuted 262 sentences, and 38 Dakota men were hanged at Mankato on 26 December 1862, the largest mass execution in US history.

Checked against mnhs.org

02 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What happened to the Dakota people after the war of 1862?

  1. AThey were given Minnesota as a reservation
  2. BThey joined the Union army
  3. CThey were forced out of Minnesota
  4. DThey moved to Utah with the Mormons
Show the answer

Answer: C They were forced out of Minnesota

About 1,600 Dakota who had not fought, mostly women, children and elderly people, were marched to Fort Snelling and held there over the winter. They were then forcibly removed from Minnesota to reservations further west.

Checked against mnhs.org

03 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What happened at Sand Creek on 29 November 1864?

  1. ASoldiers attacked a Cheyenne and Arapaho camp
  2. BLakota warriors defeated Custer’s men
  3. CA treaty gave the Cheyenne new land
  4. DThe army escorted migrants to Oregon
Show the answer

Answer: A Soldiers attacked a Cheyenne and Arapaho camp

Volunteer troops under Colonel Chivington attacked a camp of about 750 Cheyenne and Arapaho at Sand Creek, whose chiefs had sought peace. Around 230 people were killed, mostly women, children and elderly people.

Checked against nps.gov

04 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Black Kettle, a Cheyenne chief at Sand Creek, was:

  1. AA peace chief who had met US officials
  2. BThe leader of Red Cloud’s War
  3. CA Lakota holy man
  4. DThe warrior who killed Custer
Show the answer

Answer: A A peace chief who had met US officials

Black Kettle sought peace: in 1864 he arranged talks and the return of captives, and in 1867 he signed the Medicine Lodge Treaty. He survived Sand Creek but was killed when Custer attacked his camp on the Washita on 27 November 1868.

Checked against home.nps.gov

05 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What did a committee of Congress conclude about Sand Creek in 1865?

  1. AIt said no one had been killed
  2. BIt gave Chivington a medal
  3. CIt condemned Chivington
  4. DIt blamed the Cheyenne for the attack
Show the answer

Answer: C It condemned Chivington

Letters from officers who refused to join the attack led to investigations. In July 1865 Congress’s joint committee condemned Chivington. Meanwhile Cheyenne and Arapaho warriors struck back along a 100-mile front, closing parts of the South Platte Road.

Checked against home.nps.gov

06 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Red Cloud’s War (1866 to 1868) was fought over:

  1. AThe Chisholm Trail to Abilene
  2. BThe Oregon Trail to the Willamette
  3. CThe Bozeman Trail to Montana’s goldfields
  4. DThe Black Hills gold rush of 1874
Show the answer

Answer: C The Bozeman Trail to Montana’s goldfields

The Bozeman Trail, opened in 1863, ran through Lakota hunting grounds to the Montana goldfields. When the army built three forts along it in 1866, the Oglala Lakota chief Red Cloud led a two-year war against them.

Checked against nps.gov

07 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What happened in the Fetterman Fight in December 1866?

  1. ACaptain Fetterman captured Red Cloud
  2. BThe army won control of the trail
  3. CCaptain Fetterman’s command of about 80 was wiped out
  4. DFetterman signed a peace treaty
Show the answer

Answer: C Captain Fetterman’s command of about 80 was wiped out

On 21 December 1866 Captain William Fetterman led 79 soldiers and 2 civilians out of Fort Phil Kearny. They were lured into an ambush a few miles from the fort and all were killed.

Checked against nps.gov

08 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Why is Red Cloud’s War seen as a Lakota victory?

  1. AThe army abandoned its forts on the Bozeman Trail
  2. BThe railroad was moved south
  3. CCuster was killed during it
  4. DThe Lakota were given citizenship
Show the answer

Answer: A The army abandoned its forts on the Bozeman Trail

The 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty recognised the Powder River Country as Lakota hunting land, and the forts were abandoned, closing the trail. It has been called the first time the US government lost a war.

Checked against nps.gov

09 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What did the second Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 create?

  1. AFamily plots of 160 acres on each reservation
  2. BA new homeland for the Sioux in Oklahoma
  3. CThe Great Sioux Reservation, including the Black Hills
  4. DA railroad route through the Black Hills
Show the answer

Answer: C The Great Sioux Reservation, including the Black Hills

The treaty, signed in 1868 by the Sioux bands and the Arapaho, set aside the Great Sioux Reservation, covering much of western South Dakota, for the Sioux’s exclusive use. It recognised the Black Hills as part of it.

Checked against archives.gov

10 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What drew miners into the Black Hills in the mid 1870s?

  1. AA railroad built through the hills
  2. BGold, after Custer’s expedition of 1874
  3. CFree land under the Homestead Act
  4. DThe 1868 treaty opened the hills to them
Show the answer

Answer: B Gold, after Custer’s expedition of 1874

Custer led an expedition with miners into the Black Hills in 1874. Once gold was found, miners poured onto Sioux land, breaking the 1868 treaty. The government took the land in 1877, and its ownership is still disputed today.

Checked against archives.gov

11 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Put these in order, earliest first:

  1. ACuster attacks Black Kettle’s camp on the Washita
  2. BThe Sand Creek Massacre
  3. CThe Wounded Knee Massacre
  4. DThe Fetterman Fight
  5. EThe Battle of the Little Bighorn
  6. FThe Dakota War in Minnesota
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. The Dakota War in Minnesota
  2. The Sand Creek Massacre
  3. The Fetterman Fight
  4. Custer attacks Black Kettle’s camp on the Washita
  5. The Battle of the Little Bighorn
  6. The Wounded Knee Massacre

The Dakota War began in August 1862, Sand Creek was in November 1864, the Fetterman Fight in December 1866, the Washita in November 1868, the Little Bighorn in June 1876 and Wounded Knee in December 1890.

Checked against home.nps.gov

12 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

When was the Battle of the Little Bighorn?

  1. A21 December 1866
  2. B29 November 1864
  3. C25 June 1876
  4. D10 May 1869
Show the answer

Answer: C 25 June 1876

On 25 June 1876 Custer attacked a huge Lakota and Cheyenne camp on the Little Bighorn River. Custer and over 250 of his men were killed. Crook’s column had already pulled back after fighting at the Rosebud on 17 June.

Checked against nps.gov

13 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Why was the army sent against Sitting Bull’s followers in 1876?

  1. AThey had attacked the railroad at Promontory
  2. BThey refused to sign the Dawes Act
  3. CThey ignored an order to return to reservations
  4. DThey had fought for the Confederacy
Show the answer

Answer: C They ignored an order to return to reservations

The government set 31 January 1876 as the deadline for bands living off the reservations to come in. Sitting Bull and his followers ignored it, so the army launched a campaign against them, which led to the Little Bighorn.

Checked against nps.gov

14 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What was Sitting Bull’s role at the Little Bighorn?

  1. AHe was living in Canada at the time
  2. BHe was a prisoner at Fort Buford
  3. CHe led the 7th Cavalry’s Crow scouts
  4. DA spiritual leader whose vision foretold victory
Show the answer

Answer: D A spiritual leader whose vision foretold victory

In mid-June 1876, after a Sun Dance, Sitting Bull said he saw soldiers falling upside down into the camp, which the Lakota read as a coming victory. In the battle he did not fight himself but sent his nephews in with his own medicine.

Checked against nps.gov

15 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Where did Crazy Horse surrender in May 1877?

  1. AFort Phil Kearny, Wyoming
  2. BFort Buford, Dakota Territory
  3. CFort Robinson, Nebraska
  4. DFort Laramie, Wyoming
Show the answer

Answer: C Fort Robinson, Nebraska

After the Little Bighorn the army kept up the pressure through the Great Sioux War. Crazy Horse surrendered with more than 1,100 people at Fort Robinson on 6 May 1877. Sitting Bull went to Canada, but hunger drove him to surrender in July 1881.

Checked against nps.gov

16 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What did victory at the Little Bighorn lead to for the Lakota?

  1. AThe government gave up its claim to the Black Hills
  2. BMore army pressure until most bands surrendered
  3. CA law protecting the buffalo herds
  4. DThe Lakota won back all their old land
Show the answer

Answer: B More army pressure until most bands surrendered

The defeat shocked the USA. In August 1876 Congress voted to take the Black Hills, and the army hunted the free bands through the winter. By 1877 most had surrendered and moved onto reservations.

Checked against nps.gov

17 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Roughly how many bison may have lived in North America before the mid 1800s?

  1. A30 to 60 thousand
  2. B30 to 60 million
  3. C3 to 6 billion
  4. D300 to 600
Show the answer

Answer: B 30 to 60 million

Before the mid 1800s, 30 to 60 million bison roamed North America. Commercial hunting, and an army campaign to control the Plains nations by destroying their food, nearly wiped them out; Yellowstone’s wild herd fell to about two dozen by 1902.

Checked against nps.gov

18 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Why was the loss of the buffalo so serious for the Lakota?

  1. AIt took away their main food and materials
  2. BIt ended their trade with the Mormons
  3. CIt meant they could no longer ride horses
  4. DIt cut off their supply of gold
Show the answer

Answer: A It took away their main food and materials

The buffalo gave the Lakota food, hides for clothing and tipis, and bone and horn for tools. Without the herds, Plains peoples could not live independently and had to depend on the reservations.

Checked against ndstudies.gov

19 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What did the Indian Appropriations Act of 1871 end?

  1. AThe Homestead Act
  2. BBuffalo hunting
  3. CMaking treaties with Native nations
  4. DThe reservation system
Show the answer

Answer: C Making treaties with Native nations

In 1867 the Medicine Lodge Treaty sought to move the Southern Cheyenne and Arapaho to Indian Territory (now Oklahoma). In 1871 Congress stopped making treaties with Native nations altogether and pushed instead for assimilation.

Checked against home.nps.gov

20 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

The Dawes Act of 1887 divided reservation land into:

  1. AShared hunting grounds
  2. BRanches for Texas cattlemen
  3. CRailroad land grants
  4. DPlots for individual families
Show the answer

Answer: D Plots for individual families

Senator Henry Dawes’s Act, approved on 8 February 1887, gave each head of a family a quarter section (160 acres). Policymakers hoped that owning and farming private plots would make Native people give up their own cultures.

Checked against archives.gov

21 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Under the Dawes Act, the government held each allotment in trust for:

  1. A25 years
  2. B50 years
  3. C1 year
  4. D5 years
Show the answer

Answer: A 25 years

Allotted land was held in trust for 25 years, so it could not be sold at once, and those who took allotments became US citizens. Allotment still broke up shared tribal land.

Checked against archives.gov

22 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What happened to reservation land left over after allotment under the Dawes Act?

  1. AIt was declared surplus and opened to settlers
  2. BIt was handed to the railroads
  3. CIt was kept for tribal hunting
  4. DIt became national parks
Show the answer

Answer: A It was declared surplus and opened to settlers

Land not allotted was declared surplus and opened to non-Native settlers, sometimes through land runs. Much allotted land was poor for farming. Reservation land fell from 138 million acres in 1887 to 48 million in 1934, a loss of about 65%.

Checked against nps.gov

23 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Government policy in the 1880s aimed at “assimilation”. This meant:

  1. ALetting each nation govern itself fully
  2. BPaying Native nations for all land taken
  3. CMoving settlers back to the East
  4. DMaking Native people adopt white American ways
Show the answer

Answer: D Making Native people adopt white American ways

Assimilation meant pressing Native people to give up their own languages, beliefs and shared land and live like white Americans. The Dawes Act was built on this idea.

Checked against archives.gov

24 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

On the Standing Rock reservation, who decided that Sitting Bull could not go back on tour with Buffalo Bill’s Wild West?

  1. ABuffalo Bill himself
  2. BSitting Bull’s own band council
  3. CThe governor of Montana
  4. DThe government’s Indian agent
Show the answer

Answer: D The government’s Indian agent

Sitting Bull toured with Buffalo Bill Cody’s show for one season in 1885, but the agent at Standing Rock refused to let him go again. Government agents, backed by reservation police, controlled much of daily life on the reservations.

Checked against nps.gov

25 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

How did the spread of the Ghost Dance in 1890 lead to Sitting Bull’s death?

  1. AHe died while performing the Sun Dance
  2. BHe died of illness in Canada
  3. CHe was killed fighting at Wounded Knee
  4. DPolice came to arrest him, fearing he backed it
Show the answer

Answer: D Police came to arrest him, fearing he backed it

The Ghost Dance reached the Lakota in 1890, and the Standing Rock agent believed Sitting Bull was involved. Lakota Indian Police came to his cabin to arrest him on 15 December 1890; a gunfight broke out and he was shot.

Checked against nps.gov

26 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What happened at Wounded Knee on 29 December 1890?

  1. AThe Ghost Dance was performed for the first time
  2. BLakota warriors defeated Custer’s whole command
  3. CThe 7th Cavalry killed over 150 Lakota while disarming them
  4. DA peace treaty ended the Indian Wars
Show the answer

Answer: C The 7th Cavalry killed over 150 Lakota while disarming them

On 29 December 1890, as the 7th Cavalry disarmed a Lakota band at Wounded Knee Creek, firing broke out and over 150 Lakota, including many women and children, were killed. It is often seen as the end of the Plains wars.

Checked against home.nps.gov

27 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

Put these in order, earliest first:

  1. ACuster’s expedition enters the Black Hills
  2. BSitting Bull surrenders at Fort Buford
  3. CThe Battle of the Little Bighorn
  4. DCrazy Horse surrenders at Fort Robinson
  5. ESitting Bull is killed at Standing Rock
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Custer’s expedition enters the Black Hills
  2. The Battle of the Little Bighorn
  3. Crazy Horse surrenders at Fort Robinson
  4. Sitting Bull surrenders at Fort Buford
  5. Sitting Bull is killed at Standing Rock

Custer’s expedition was in 1874, the Little Bighorn in June 1876, Crazy Horse’s surrender in May 1877, Sitting Bull’s surrender in July 1881 and his death in December 1890, two weeks before Wounded Knee.

Checked against nps.gov

28 / Conflict on the Plains and its endOCR B (Schools History Project)

In 1803 the USA bought the Louisiana territory from:

  1. AFrance
  2. BMexico
  3. CSpain
  4. DBritain
Show the answer

Answer: A France

In 1803 President Thomas Jefferson’s government bought about 828,000 square miles west of the Mississippi from Napoleon’s France for $15 million, roughly doubling the size of the USA.

Checked against archives.gov

29 / Conflict on the Plains and its endOCR B (Schools History Project)

The Lewis and Clark expedition of 1804 to 1806 was sent to:

  1. ALead the Mormons to the Salt Lake valley
  2. BFight the Lakota for the Black Hills
  3. CMap the new territory and find a route west
  4. DSurvey the first transcontinental railroad
Show the answer

Answer: C Map the new territory and find a route west

Jefferson sent Meriwether Lewis and William Clark to explore and map the Louisiana Purchase and find a practical route across the West. Their Corps of Discovery reached the Pacific in November 1805 and returned in 1806.

Checked against nps.gov

30 / Conflict on the Plains and its endOCR B (Schools History Project)

How did the cotton gin, patented in 1794, affect slavery?

  1. AIt made cotton more profitable, so slavery grew
  2. BIt replaced enslaved workers, so slavery ended
  3. CIt moved slavery onto the Great Plains
  4. DIt had no effect on the Southern states
Show the answer

Answer: A It made cotton more profitable, so slavery grew

Eli Whitney’s gin removed cotton seeds quickly, making cotton far more profitable. Planters wanted more land and more enslaved people to grow and pick it, so slavery spread rather than shrank.

Checked against archives.gov

31 / Conflict on the Plains and its endOCR B (Schools History Project)

In Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), the Supreme Court:

  1. AGave Black men the right to vote
  2. BEnded segregation on railroads
  3. CAllowed “separate but equal” segregation
  4. DAbolished slavery in the South
Show the answer

Answer: C Allowed “separate but equal” segregation

Homer Plessy challenged an 1890 Louisiana law requiring separate railway carriages. In May 1896 the Supreme Court upheld it, and segregation spread through state Jim Crow laws to most public places until the 1950s and 1960s.

Checked against archives.gov

32 / Conflict on the Plains and its endOCR B (Schools History Project)

Ellis Island in New York opened as an immigration station in:

  1. A1862
  2. B1877
  3. C1892
  4. D1903
Show the answer

Answer: C 1892

From 1892 to 1924 more than 12 million immigrants entered the USA through Ellis Island. Mass immigration was part of the rapid growth of American cities in this period.

Checked against nps.gov

33 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

What was the aim of boarding schools such as Carlisle, opened in 1879?

  1. ATo make Native children give up their own cultures
  2. BTo teach Native languages and religion
  3. CTo prepare Native children for buffalo hunting
  4. DTo train Native children as tribal leaders
Show the answer

Answer: A To make Native children give up their own cultures

Richard Henry Pratt, an army officer, founded Carlisle in Pennsylvania in 1879, summed up as “Kill the Indian, Save the Man”. Children’s hair was cut, their clothes taken, their languages banned and English names given. More than 7,800 children from about 140 nations went there by 1918.

Checked against nps.gov

34 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

From 1883, what could happen to people on reservations who took part in the Sun Dance?

  1. AThey were sent to Washington as guests
  2. BThey were made reservation police
  3. CThey could be punished by reservation courts
  4. DThey were given extra rations
Show the answer

Answer: C They could be punished by reservation courts

In 1883 the government set up special courts on the reservations to punish people who took part in ceremonies such as the Sun Dance. It wanted to replace Native religion with Christianity, and many spiritual leaders were imprisoned.

Checked against nlm.nih.gov

35 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

The 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty promised Lakota settled on the reservation a daily ration of:

  1. ATen acres of farmland
  2. BA buffalo for every family
  3. CA pound of meat and a pound of flour
  4. DA pound of gold dust
Show the answer

Answer: C A pound of meat and a pound of flour

The 1868 treaty promised a pound of meat and a pound of flour a day for four years to people who settled on the reservation. Once the buffalo were gone, families had to rely on rations, so agents could use food to control them, and cuts to rations in the late 1880s left many hungry.

Checked against archives.gov

36 / Conflict on the Plains and its endEvery board with this unit

The Ghost Dance began with the visions of which Paiute holy man?

  1. ACrazy Horse
  2. BSitting Bull
  3. CRed Cloud
  4. DWovoka
Show the answer

Answer: D Wovoka

Wovoka taught that if Native people danced and lived peacefully, the dead would return and the hardships of the present would end, and many believed the buffalo would come back. Lakota dancers wore shirts they believed stopped bullets. White settlers and agents feared the dance, which led to the arrest of Sitting Bull and to Wounded Knee.

Checked against ndstudies.gov

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

8 marks / The conflict over the Black HillsEdexcel

Write a narrative account analysing the key events of the conflict over the Black Hills in the years 1868 to 1877. You may use the following in your answer: the Fort Laramie Treaty (1868); the Battle of the Little Bighorn (1876). You must also use information of your own.

What a full answer includes
  • The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 set aside the Great Sioux Reservation, including the Black Hills, which the Lakota held sacred.
  • Custer’s expedition of 1874 found gold, and miners poured onto reservation land, breaking the treaty.
  • The Lakota refused to sell the Black Hills, so the government ordered bands living off the reservation to come in by 31 January 1876.
  • When Sitting Bull’s followers ignored the deadline, the army attacked, leading to the Little Bighorn on 25 June 1876, where Custer and over 250 of his men were killed.
  • As a result, Congress took the Black Hills and the army pursued the free bands through the winter; Crazy Horse surrendered in May 1877.
  • Each event is linked to the next, showing cause and consequence.

Model answer

The conflict began with the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868, which ended Red Cloud’s War. The treaty set aside the Great Sioux Reservation, covering much of what is now western South Dakota, for the Lakota, and it included the Black Hills, which the Lakota regard as sacred. This seemed to settle the question, but it depended on settlers staying out. That changed in 1874, when Lieutenant Colonel George Custer led an army expedition into the Black Hills and reported gold. As a result, thousands of miners poured onto reservation land, breaking the treaty. The government tried to buy the Black Hills, but the Lakota refused to sell. It then ordered all bands living off the reservation to report to agencies by 31 January 1876. Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse’s followers ignored the order, so the army launched a campaign against them. This led to the Battle of the Little Bighorn on 25 June 1876, when Custer attacked a huge Lakota and Cheyenne camp and he and over 250 of his men were killed. The victory, however, brought a fierce response. In August 1876 Congress voted to take the Black Hills, the army pursued the free bands through the winter, and Crazy Horse surrendered in May 1877. The Black Hills were lost to the Lakota.

Where marks slip

Edexcel examiners reward a sequence where each event leads to the next. Avoid writing as a diary or letter, and stop when you reach the end point the question sets.

8 marks / The destruction of the buffaloAQA

In what ways were the lives of the Plains Indians affected by the destruction of the buffalo? Explain your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Tens of millions of buffalo were reduced to under a thousand by about 1889, through commercial hide hunting helped by the railroads.
  • The Plains Indians lost their main source of food and the hides they used for tipis and clothing, and bone and horn for tools.
  • Without the herds to follow, their nomadic way of life ended.
  • They became dependent on government rations on the reservations, which gave agents great power over them.
  • Hunger forced the last free bands to surrender, such as Sitting Bull in 1881.
  • The buffalo was central to their beliefs and to a young man’s status as a hunter and warrior, so its loss also damaged their culture and spirit.

Model answer

The destruction of the buffalo changed the lives of the Plains Indians completely. In the mid 1800s there were tens of millions of buffalo on the Plains, but commercial hide hunting in the 1870s and 1880s, helped by railroads that carried the hides east, reduced them to fewer than a thousand by about 1889. The most immediate effect was on daily survival. Nations such as the Lakota and Cheyenne relied on the buffalo for almost everything: meat for food, hides for tipis and clothing, and bones, horns and sinew for tools. Without the herds there was nothing to follow, so the nomadic way of life came to an end. As a result, the Plains Indians became dependent on the US government. On the reservations they relied on rations of beef and flour handed out by agents, which gave the government great power over them. Hunger also ended resistance. Sitting Bull, who had escaped to Canada after the Little Bighorn, returned and surrendered in July 1881 largely because his people were starving. The loss also changed their culture and beliefs. The buffalo was sacred and central to ceremonies, and hunting it was how a young man proved himself as a hunter and warrior. When the herds vanished, these traditions lost their purpose, which made the government’s pressure to assimilate harder to resist.

Where marks slip

Each paragraph should say what changed in people’s lives because of the buffalo’s destruction. Explaining why the buffalo was killed is only background.

12 marks / Buffalo or the armyAQA

Which of the following was the more important reason why the Plains Indians lost their independence by 1895: the destruction of the buffalo; the actions of the US Army? Explain your answer with reference to both reasons.

What a full answer includes
  • The army fought the Plains Indians in wars such as Red Cloud’s War (1866 to 1868) and the Great Sioux War (1876 to 1877), and built forts across their lands.
  • After the Little Bighorn (1876) the army hunted the free bands through the winter until Crazy Horse surrendered in 1877.
  • Army attacks on camps, such as Sand Creek (1864, by volunteer troops) and the Washita (1868), and finally Wounded Knee (1890), broke resistance by terror.
  • But the army did not always win: Red Cloud’s War ended with the Bozeman forts abandoned in 1868.
  • The destruction of the buffalo, from tens of millions to under a thousand, removed food, shelter and the means to live independently.
  • Without the buffalo the bands had to accept reservations and government rations; hunger forced surrenders such as Sitting Bull’s in 1881.
  • Judgement: the buffalo’s destruction was more important, because it made military resistance impossible to sustain and the army’s victories permanent.

Model answer

The actions of the US Army were an important reason why the Plains Indians lost their independence. From the 1860s the army built forts across their lands and fought a series of wars. Some attacks were massacres of people who were not fighting: volunteer troops killed around 230 Cheyenne and Arapaho, mostly women, children and old people, at Sand Creek in 1864, and in 1868 Custer attacked Black Kettle’s camp on the Washita. After the Lakota and Cheyenne defeated Custer at the Little Bighorn in June 1876, the army kept up a winter campaign that destroyed camps and supplies. Crazy Horse surrendered in May 1877, and the Black Hills were taken. In 1890, at Wounded Knee, soldiers killed over 150 Lakota, ending armed resistance. However, the army alone could not defeat the Plains Indians. In Red Cloud’s War of 1866 to 1868, the Lakota forced the army to abandon its forts on the Bozeman Trail, and the Little Bighorn showed they could beat American soldiers in battle. Bands could move fast and live off the land, so as long as they could hunt they could keep resisting. That is why the destruction of the buffalo was so important. The Plains Indians depended on the buffalo for food, tipi covers, clothing and tools. In the 1870s and 1880s commercial hunters, using the railroads to ship hides east, cut the herds from tens of millions to fewer than a thousand by about 1889. Many army officers welcomed this, because they saw that the herds kept the free bands alive. With no buffalo, the bands could not feed themselves, and they had to accept life on reservations and depend on government rations. Overall, the destruction of the buffalo was the more important reason. The army won battles, but the Plains Indians had shown they could survive defeats and win victories while the herds remained. Once the buffalo were gone, independence was impossible however well they fought: Sitting Bull, for example, was not captured but came back from Canada and surrendered in 1881 because his people were starving. The buffalo’s destruction turned the army’s victories into a permanent loss of freedom.

Where marks slip

AQA wants both bullet points explained before you judge, then a reason why one matters more. Linking them, here how the loss of the buffalo made the army’s job possible, earns the top level.

9 marks / Changing policy towards Native AmericansOCR B (Schools History Project)

Write a clear and organised summary that analyses how the US government’s policy towards Native Americans on the Plains changed in the years 1851 to 1887. Support your summary with examples.

What a full answer includes
  • The summary is organised around change over time, from separation to concentration to assimilation.
  • 1851: the first Fort Laramie Treaty gave each nation a territory and promised goods, in return for safe passage for migrants.
  • The 1850s and 1860s: concentration on reservations, as land was needed for settlers, railroads and miners.
  • 1868: the second Fort Laramie Treaty created the Great Sioux Reservation, but it was broken after gold was found in the Black Hills (1874).
  • After 1876: military force and smaller reservations, with rations used to control the people.
  • 1887: the Dawes Act split reservations into family plots and sold the “surplus”, aiming to destroy Native ways of life (assimilation).

Model answer

Government policy changed from separating Native Americans from settlers, to confining them on reservations, and finally to trying to end their separate way of life. In 1851 the policy was separation. At the first Fort Laramie Treaty, Plains nations were given recognised territories and promised goods each year, in return for allowing migrants to cross safely. The aim was to keep settlers and Native Americans apart. As more settlers, miners and railroads moved onto the Plains in the 1850s and 1860s, policy changed to concentration on reservations. The second Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 created the Great Sioux Reservation, including the Black Hills. But this promise did not last: after gold was found in 1874, the government took the Black Hills, and after the Great Sioux War of 1876 to 1877 the army forced bands onto smaller reservations, where agents controlled food rations. By the 1880s the aim had become assimilation. The Dawes Act of 1887 broke reservations into family plots of 160 acres and sold the land left over to settlers. It was meant to turn Native Americans into individual farmers and make them give up shared land, their own culture and their beliefs. Over the period, policy moved from respecting Native lands to trying to destroy Native ways of life.

Where marks slip

OCR B rewards a summary organised around a concept, here change. A list of treaties and battles in date order with no sense of how policy changed stays in the lowest level.

18 marks / Railroads and the loss of the PlainsOCR B (Schools History Project)

‘The building of the railroads was the main reason Native Americans lost control of the Great Plains by 1890.’

How far do you agree with this statement? Explain your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • For: the Pacific Railroad Act (1862) allowed Native land titles to be extinguished, and railroads brought settlers, soldiers and supplies onto the Plains.
  • For: railroads split the buffalo herds and carried hunters and hides, speeding the buffalo’s destruction.
  • Against: the destruction of the buffalo was the direct cause of lost independence, and hide hunting was driven by demand in the East.
  • Against: the US Army defeated the Plains nations in wars such as the Great Sioux War, and massacres such as Sand Creek and Wounded Knee broke resistance.
  • Against: government policy took land through broken treaties (Fort Laramie 1868, the Black Hills), reservations and the Dawes Act (1887).
  • Against: gold rushes and migration came before the railroads, such as California (1848), Pikes Peak (1858) and the Black Hills (1874).
  • Judgement with a clear criterion, for example that the railroads speeded up a process driven by government policy and the loss of the buffalo.

Model answer

The railroads were an important reason why Native Americans lost control of the Plains. The Pacific Railroad Act of 1862 gave the companies land and allowed Native land titles along the route to be extinguished. After the first transcontinental line was completed in 1869, and more lines followed, settlers, soldiers and supplies could reach the Plains in days. Railroad companies sold their land grants to homesteaders, so farms and towns spread onto lands the Lakota, Cheyenne and other nations had used for hunting. The railroads also split the great buffalo herd in two and carried hunters out and hides back east. However, the railroads were not the only cause, and some of the loss happened before them. Gold rushes drew migrants across Native lands long before 1869: to California from 1848 and to Pikes Peak in 1858, when settlers moved onto Cheyenne and Arapaho land and conflict followed, ending in the Sand Creek Massacre of 1864. In 1874 gold in the Black Hills brought miners onto the Great Sioux Reservation, though no railroad ran there. The US government’s policies were a major reason. It made treaties and then broke them. The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 promised the Black Hills to the Lakota, but they were taken in 1877. Bands were forced onto ever smaller reservations, where agents controlled food. The Dawes Act of 1887 broke up reservations into family plots and sold the “surplus” to settlers, so Native land fell sharply. The army enforced these policies. After the Little Bighorn in 1876 it pursued the free bands until they surrendered, and the killing of more than 150 Lakota at Wounded Knee in December 1890 ended armed resistance on the Plains. Above all, the destruction of the buffalo made independence impossible. The herds fell from tens of millions to fewer than a thousand by about 1889, leaving the Plains nations without food or shelter and dependent on government rations. Overall, I disagree with the statement. The railroads mattered because they sped up everything else: settlement, troop movements and the hide trade. But they were a means, not the main cause. The decisive reason was a government determined to take the land, backed by the army, and the loss of the buffalo, which ended any chance of living independently. Native Americans would have lost control of the Plains even without the railroads, though more slowly.

Where marks slip

OCR B examiners want at least one developed point for and one against, with precise examples. Make your judgement clear, and say how the factors are linked rather than treating each as separate.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 36 questions in Show Working

This page shows 36 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE History topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free