Show Working
Open the app

GCSE History · Elizabethan EnglandAQA, Edexcel, OCR A, OCR B (Schools History Project) and Eduqas

Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the Armada: GCSE questions with answers

30 GCSE History questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working History bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 30 questions 4 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the Armada questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

How was Mary, Queen of Scots related to Elizabeth?

  1. AShe was her aunt
  2. BShe was her half-sister
  3. CShe was her niece
  4. DShe was her cousin
Show the answer

Answer: D She was her cousin

Mary, Queen of Scots was Elizabeth’s Catholic cousin and, by descent, her heir. Catholics who saw Elizabeth as illegitimate saw Mary as the rightful queen, so plots to replace Elizabeth usually aimed to put Mary on the throne. Do not confuse her with Mary I, Elizabeth’s half-sister.

Checked against english-heritage.org.uk

02 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

In which year did Mary, Queen of Scots flee from Scotland into England?

  1. A1558
  2. B1561
  3. C1568
  4. D1572
Show the answer

Answer: C 1568

After defeat in Scotland, Mary fled to England in 1568. Elizabeth did not dare free her or send her back, so Mary was held for about nineteen years in places such as Tutbury, a focus for plots the whole time.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

03 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaAQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Which two earls led the revolt of November 1569?

  1. ALeicester and Essex
  2. BShrewsbury and Huntingdon
  3. CNorfolk and Arundel
  4. DNorthumberland and Westmorland
Show the answer

Answer: D Northumberland and Westmorland

The Revolt of the Northern Earls, or Rising of the North, began in November 1569, led by the Earls of Northumberland and Westmorland. They wanted to restore the Catholic Mass and free Mary. The rising collapsed and many rebels were executed.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

04 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaAQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Which nobleman hoped to marry Mary and was executed in 1572 after the Ridolfi Plot?

  1. AThe Earl of Leicester
  2. BThe Earl of Westmorland
  3. CThe Duke of Norfolk
  4. DLord Burghley
Show the answer

Answer: C The Duke of Norfolk

Thomas Howard, Duke of Norfolk, was the most senior noble in England. He planned to marry Mary, and his part in the Ridolfi Plot led to his execution in 1572. Parliament wanted Mary executed too, but Elizabeth refused.

Checked against historyofparliamentonline.org

05 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaAQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Roberto Ridolfi, who organised a plot in 1571, was:

  1. Aa Spanish admiral
  2. Ban Italian banker
  3. Ca Jesuit from Douai
  4. Da Scottish lord
Show the answer

Answer: B an Italian banker

In 1571 Roberto Ridolfi, an Italian banker living in London, plotted a Spanish invasion and a Catholic rising that would put Mary on the throne, with the Duke of Norfolk as her husband. The plot was uncovered before anything happened.

Checked against historyofparliamentonline.org

06 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

The Throckmorton Plot of 1583 planned an invasion of England led by:

  1. AKing James VI of Scotland
  2. Bthe Duke of Medina Sidonia
  3. Cthe French Duke of Guise
  4. DRobert Dudley
Show the answer

Answer: C the French Duke of Guise

Francis Throckmorton plotted with the Spanish ambassador, Bernardino de Mendoza, for a French Catholic army under the Duke of Guise to invade and free Mary. Walsingham’s agents caught him in 1583, and Mendoza was expelled in 1584.

Checked against historyofparliamentonline.org

07 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaAQA and Edexcel

In the Bond of Association of 1584, nobles swore to:

  1. Apay for new ships for the navy
  2. Bfree Mary, Queen of Scots from prison
  3. Cnever let the queen marry a foreigner
  4. Dkill any plotter and anyone the plot was for
Show the answer

Answer: D kill any plotter and anyone the plot was for

After the Throckmorton Plot, Burghley and Walsingham drew up the Bond of Association in 1584. Those who signed swore to kill anyone who plotted against Elizabeth and anyone who would gain from it, which clearly meant Mary. Parliament then backed it with an Act for the Queen’s Safety.

Checked against historyofparliamentonline.org

08 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

The Babington Plot of 1586 aimed to:

  1. Afree the Jesuits from the Tower
  2. Bkill Elizabeth and make Mary queen
  3. Cmake Robert Dudley king
  4. Dhand the navy over to Spain
Show the answer

Answer: B kill Elizabeth and make Mary queen

In 1586 Anthony Babington plotted to kill Elizabeth and free Mary. Walsingham’s agents secretly read Mary’s letters, which were in code, and caught her approving the plot. After the plot was discovered, her rooms were searched and over a hundred cipher keys were found.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

09 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Walsingham’s code-breaker, who read Mary’s secret letters, was:

  1. AThomas Phelippes
  2. BFrancis Throckmorton
  3. CRoberto Ridolfi
  4. DAnthony Babington
Show the answer

Answer: A Thomas Phelippes

Thomas Phelippes was one of the experts who broke codes for Walsingham. Mary wrote in ciphers, codes that swapped letters and words for symbols, but Phelippes could read them, which gave Walsingham the proof he needed against her in 1586.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

10 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Mary was put on trial in 1586 under a law that allowed the trial of anyone who:

  1. Arefused to attend church on Sunday
  2. Bwrote letters in code from prison
  3. Cmarried without the queen’s consent
  4. Dwas involved in a plot against the queen
Show the answer

Answer: D was involved in a plot against the queen

The Act for the Queen’s Safety of 1585 allowed the trial, and death or exclusion from the throne, of anyone involved in an invasion, rebellion or plot against Elizabeth. Mary’s approval of the Babington Plot was used to put her on trial under it.

Checked against historyofparliamentonline.org

11 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Where was Mary, Queen of Scots executed?

  1. AFotheringhay Castle
  2. BThe Tower of London
  3. CHolyrood Palace
  4. DTutbury Castle
Show the answer

Answer: A Fotheringhay Castle

Mary was held at Fotheringhay Castle in Northamptonshire from 1586, tried there and executed there in February 1587. Her death removed the Catholic heir inside England but made Philip II of Spain more determined to invade.

Checked against historicengland.org.uk

12 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

How did Elizabeth react when pressed to sign Mary’s death warrant?

  1. AShe refused and set Mary free
  2. BShe signed it at once and gladly
  3. CShe asked the Pope to decide
  4. DShe was very reluctant and delayed
Show the answer

Answer: D She was very reluctant and delayed

Elizabeth hated the idea of executing a fellow queen, which could encourage others to kill monarchs, and she delayed for months. When Parliament pressed her she gave unclear answers. After the execution she claimed it had been carried out against her wishes.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

13 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaAQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Put these events in order, earliest first:

  1. AMary flees to England
  2. BThrockmorton Plot
  3. CMary is executed
  4. DRidolfi Plot
  5. ERevolt of the Northern Earls
  6. FBabington Plot
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Mary flees to England
  2. Revolt of the Northern Earls
  3. Ridolfi Plot
  4. Throckmorton Plot
  5. Babington Plot
  6. Mary is executed

Mary fled to England in 1568, and the Northern Earls rose in 1569. The Ridolfi Plot came in 1571, the Throckmorton Plot in 1583 and the Babington Plot in 1586. Mary was executed in 1587.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

14 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Put these events in order, earliest first:

  1. ATreaty of Nonsuch
  2. BThe Armada sails
  3. CThrockmorton Plot
  4. DMary is executed
  5. EBabington Plot
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Throckmorton Plot
  2. Treaty of Nonsuch
  3. Babington Plot
  4. Mary is executed
  5. The Armada sails

The Throckmorton Plot was uncovered in 1583. The Treaty of Nonsuch, promising help to the Dutch, came in 1585. The Babington Plot followed in 1586, Mary was executed in February 1587 and the Armada sailed in 1588.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

15 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Who was king of Spain at the time of the Armada?

  1. ACharles V
  2. BPhilip II
  3. CFerdinand II
  4. DPhilip III
Show the answer

Answer: B Philip II

Philip II of Spain was a devout Catholic who ruled Spain, the Netherlands and a huge empire in the Americas. He had been married to Mary I of England. He launched the Armada against England in 1588.

Checked against english-heritage.org.uk

16 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Which of these helped push England and Spain into war in the 1580s?

  1. ASpain’s claim to the Scottish throne
  2. BSpanish support for the Puritans
  3. CEnglish help for the Dutch rebels
  4. DEngland’s alliance with the Pope
Show the answer

Answer: C English help for the Dutch rebels

Religion, trade rivalry in the Americas, English raids on Spanish treasure ships and English help for the Dutch rebels all pushed the two countries apart. The execution of Mary in 1587 hastened the showdown, and Philip launched the Armada the next year.

Checked against english-heritage.org.uk

17 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Seamen such as Drake and Hawkins, who raided Spanish ships and ports with the queen’s backing, are called:

  1. Aprivateers
  2. Brecusants
  3. Cvagabonds
  4. Dseminary priests
Show the answer

Answer: A privateers

Privateers were private captains who attacked enemy ships with the Crown’s approval and shared the loot. Drake spent months raiding Spanish shipping in the West Indies in 1585 to 1586. To Spain this was piracy, and it angered Philip II.

Checked against nps.gov

18 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Under the Treaty of Nonsuch of 1585, Elizabeth agreed to:

  1. Astop English raids on Spain
  2. Bhand Mary over to the Scots
  3. Cmarry the Duke of Anjou
  4. Dhelp the Dutch rebels against Spain
Show the answer

Answer: D help the Dutch rebels against Spain

The Treaty of Nonsuch, signed in August 1585, promised money and an army to the Dutch rebels fighting Philip II. Robert Dudley led the army there. Philip saw this as open war, and it is a key cause of the Armada.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

19 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

What did Drake’s raid on Cadiz in 1587 achieve?

  1. AIt freed English prisoners in Madrid
  2. BIt ended the war with Spain
  3. CIt captured Philip II
  4. DIt delayed the Armada
Show the answer

Answer: D It delayed the Armada

In April 1587 Drake attacked the Spanish port of Cadiz, destroying many ships and supplies being gathered for the Armada. He called it singeing the King of Spain’s beard. It delayed the invasion by about a year.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

20 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Who commanded the Spanish Armada?

  1. AThe Duke of Guise
  2. BThe Duke of Parma
  3. CThe Duke of Medina Sidonia
  4. DKing Philip II himself
Show the answer

Answer: C The Duke of Medina Sidonia

The Duke of Medina Sidonia led the Armada. The plan was to sail up the Channel and meet the Duke of Parma’s army in the Netherlands, then escort it across to invade England. Parma’s army never managed to join the fleet.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

21 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Who commanded the English fleet against the Armada?

  1. ALord Howard of Effingham
  2. BSir John Hawkins
  3. CSir Walter Raleigh
  4. DSir Francis Drake
Show the answer

Answer: A Lord Howard of Effingham

In December 1587 Elizabeth put Lord Howard of Effingham in charge of England’s defence at sea. Drake, the more famous sailor, was his Vice-Admiral. Howard’s noble rank helped him keep strong characters such as Drake in check.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

22 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Where was the Armada first sighted on 19 July 1588?

  1. ANear Gravelines in Flanders
  2. BOff the Lizard in Cornwall
  3. COff Calais in France
  4. DAt the mouth of the Thames
Show the answer

Answer: B Off the Lizard in Cornwall

The Armada was sighted off the Lizard in Cornwall on 19 July 1588 (English dating). A fast ship carried the news and beacons were lit along the coast. The English fleet sailed out of Plymouth and harried the Spanish up the Channel.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

23 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Where was the Armada anchored when the English sent in fireships?

  1. AOff Plymouth
  2. BOff the Lizard
  3. COff Calais
  4. DIn the Thames
Show the answer

Answer: C Off Calais

The Armada anchored off Calais on 27 July 1588. On the night of 28 July the English sent in eight fireships. No Spanish ship caught fire, but the crews panicked, cut their anchor cables and scattered, breaking their tight crescent formation.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

24 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

The fierce battle the day after the fireship attack is called the Battle of:

  1. ACalais
  2. BCadiz
  3. CLepanto
  4. DGravelines
Show the answer

Answer: D Gravelines

The day after the fireships, the English attacked the scattered Spanish ships off Gravelines in a day of fierce fighting. The Spanish were nearly driven onto the sandbanks, then the wind changed and carried them north into the North Sea, away from Parma.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

25 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Which of these was an English advantage at sea in 1588?

  1. AFar more soldiers carried on board
  2. BA Spanish admiral who changed sides
  3. CControl of the port of Calais
  4. DFaster ships that were easier to steer
Show the answer

Answer: D Faster ships that were easier to steer

The English had faster, easier to steer ships and good seamen, and the fireships broke the Armada’s formation. Luck helped: the wind, the failure to meet Parma and storms on the voyage home. Historians weigh these factors differently.

Checked against english-heritage.org.uk

26 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

How did the Armada try to get back to Spain?

  1. ABy landing at Calais and marching
  2. BBy sailing round Scotland and Ireland
  3. CBack down the English Channel
  4. DBy sailing round Cornwall
Show the answer

Answer: B By sailing round Scotland and Ireland

Unable to turn back against the wind to meet Parma, the Spanish sailed north round Scotland and then down past Ireland. Storms wrecked many ships on those coasts, and only about half the fleet got back to Spain.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

27 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

In August 1588 Elizabeth spoke to her army, gathered to meet an invasion, at:

  1. AGreenwich
  2. BPlymouth
  3. CTilbury
  4. DDover
Show the answer

Answer: C Tilbury

With a Spanish landing still feared, an English army camped at West Tilbury beside the Thames. In August 1588 Elizabeth visited and rallied the troops in a famous speech. Its text survives in later copies, so its exact words are not certain.

Checked against english-heritage.org.uk

28 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Why do English and Spanish accounts give Armada dates ten days apart?

  1. ANews took ten days to reach Spain
  2. BThe battles lasted for ten days
  3. CSpain counted its years from Easter
  4. DEngland still used the older Julian calendar
Show the answer

Answer: D England still used the older Julian calendar

England still used the old Julian calendar, ten days behind the Gregorian calendar used in Spain. So the Battle of Gravelines is 29 July 1588 in English dating but 8 August in the new style. Always say which calendar a date uses.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

29 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaEvery board with this unit

Put these Armada events of 1588 in order, earliest first:

  1. AThe Battle of Gravelines
  2. BThe Armada anchors off Calais
  3. CThe English send in fireships
  4. DThe Armada is sighted off the Lizard
  5. EThe Armada sails north round Scotland
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. The Armada is sighted off the Lizard
  2. The Armada anchors off Calais
  3. The English send in fireships
  4. The Battle of Gravelines
  5. The Armada sails north round Scotland

The Armada was sighted off Cornwall on 19 July and anchored off Calais on 27 July. Fireships went in on the night of 28 July, Gravelines was fought the next day, and the Spanish then sailed north round Scotland.

Checked against rmg.co.uk

30 / Plots, Mary Queen of Scots and the ArmadaAQA, OCR B (Schools History Project) and Eduqas

What happened in the war with Spain after 1588?

  1. AEngland conquered the Netherlands
  2. BIt went on, and new invasions were feared
  3. CPhilip II became Elizabeth’s ally
  4. DSpain made peace straight away
Show the answer

Answer: B It went on, and new invasions were feared

Defeating the Armada did not end the war, which lasted until 1604. Spain built new fleets and further invasions were feared in the 1590s, and the war spread to Ireland. It was a heavy cost for Elizabeth’s government in her last years.

Checked against english-heritage.org.uk

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

12 marks / Why Mary, Queen of Scots, was a threatEdexcel

Explain why Mary, Queen of Scots, was a threat to Elizabeth I in the years 1568 to 1587. You may use the following in your answer: the Revolt of the Northern Earls (1569); the Babington Plot (1586). You must also use information of your own.

What a full answer includes
  • Mary had a strong claim to the English throne as Henry VII’s great-granddaughter, and Catholics who saw Elizabeth as illegitimate thought Mary was the rightful queen.
  • Once she fled to England in 1568 she became a focus for English Catholics, shown when the Northern Earls rebelled in 1569 to free her and restore Catholicism.
  • The papal bull of 1570 excommunicated Elizabeth and released Catholics from obeying her, which made plotting for Mary seem justified.
  • Mary was linked to foreign Catholic powers: the Ridolfi Plot (1571) planned a Spanish invasion and the Throckmorton Plot (1583) a French-led one.
  • In the Babington Plot (1586) Mary approved a plan to kill Elizabeth, which Walsingham’s agents uncovered by reading her letters.
  • Mary was hard to deal with: executing an anointed queen risked angering Catholic Europe, so she stayed a living threat for 19 years.
  • Each paragraph explains how the factor made Mary a threat, with no need to rank them.

Model answer

Mary, Queen of Scots, was a threat first because of her claim to the throne. She was the granddaughter of Margaret Tudor, Henry VIII’s sister, and so Elizabeth’s heir. Many Catholics believed Henry’s marriage to Anne Boleyn had never been valid, which made Elizabeth illegitimate and Mary the rightful queen. When Mary fled to England in May 1568 after being forced to give up the Scottish crown, this claim came with her into the heart of the kingdom. Mary was also a threat because she became a focus for discontented Catholics at home. In November 1569 the Earls of Northumberland and Westmorland led the Revolt of the Northern Earls, aiming to free Mary and restore Catholicism. The rebels heard Mass in Durham Cathedral before the revolt collapsed and about 450 rebels were executed. The papal bull of February 1570, which excommunicated Elizabeth and released Catholics from obeying her, made plots in Mary’s name seem lawful to devout Catholics. Finally, Mary was a threat because plots for her were linked to foreign powers. The Ridolfi Plot of 1571 planned a Spanish invasion to put Mary on the throne married to the Duke of Norfolk, who was executed in 1572. The Throckmorton Plot of 1583 planned a French-led invasion backed by Spain, and the Spanish ambassador Mendoza was expelled. In the Babington Plot of 1586, Mary wrote approving a plan to murder Elizabeth. Her letters, smuggled in beer barrels, were read by Walsingham’s agents, which gave the proof needed to try her. Because killing a queen was so dangerous, Elizabeth delayed for years, and Mary remained a threat until her execution at Fotheringhay on 8 February 1587.

Where marks slip

Edexcel gives no marks for ranking causes in the 12-mark question, so spend the time explaining three causes instead. Use the two stimulus points if you like, but you must add a third aspect of your own.

8 marks / Mary’s execution in 1587AQA

Explain what was important about the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots, in 1587.

What a full answer includes
  • It removed the main focus for Catholic plots inside England, since there was no longer a Catholic heir to put on the throne.
  • It made the succession clearer: Mary’s son James VI of Scotland, a Protestant, became the likely heir.
  • It gave Philip II of Spain a further reason to invade, as he could present the Armada of 1588 as avenging a Catholic queen.
  • Elizabeth tried to avoid blame, claiming the warrant had been sent without her approval, which shows how dangerous killing a queen was.
  • James protested but did not break his alliance with England, so Scotland stayed friendly.

Model answer

The execution of Mary, Queen of Scots, at Fotheringhay on 8 February 1587 was important because it removed the main focus of Catholic plotting in England. For 19 years plots such as Ridolfi, Throckmorton and Babington had aimed to replace Elizabeth with Mary. With Mary dead, English Catholics had no Catholic heir to rally round, so the danger of a rising at home was greatly reduced. It was also important for the succession. Mary’s son, James VI of Scotland, was a Protestant, so the obvious heir was now someone Protestants could accept. James protested about his mother’s death, but he kept his alliance and pension from England, and in 1603 he became James I. However, the execution made war with Spain more likely. Philip II was already planning to invade, and Mary’s death let him present the Armada of 1588 as a crusade to avenge a Catholic queen, with the Pope’s backing. Elizabeth herself was so worried about the reaction that she claimed the death warrant had been sent without her consent and had her secretary, William Davison, sent to the Tower. This shows how important, and how risky, the execution was.

Where marks slip

Telling the story of the Babington Plot is not the same as explaining importance. Spend most of the answer on what changed because Mary died.

16 marks / Was the weather why the Armada failed?AQA

‘The weather was the main reason why the Spanish Armada failed.’

How far does a study of the Spanish Armada support this statement? Explain your answer. You should refer to the Spanish Armada and your contextual knowledge.

What a full answer includes
  • The Spanish plan was weak: the Armada had to meet the Duke of Parma’s army in the Netherlands, but there was no deep-water port where they could join up.
  • Medina Sidonia had little experience at sea, and Drake’s raid on Cadiz in 1587 destroyed seasoned barrel staves, so the Armada’s food and water spoiled.
  • English ships were faster and handier, and English guns could be reloaded more quickly, though the Spanish crescent formation held all the way up the Channel.
  • The fireships sent in at night off Calais (28 July 1588, English dates) broke the formation, and the Battle of Gravelines next day scattered the Armada.
  • The wind then drove the Armada into the North Sea, so it could not return to meet Parma: the invasion had failed before the storms.
  • Storms off Scotland and Ireland wrecked many ships on the way home, and only about half the ships returned to Spain.
  • Judgement: weather caused the heaviest losses, but the invasion was defeated by the plan’s flaws and English tactics at Calais and Gravelines.

Model answer

A study of the Armada does give some support to the statement. After the Battle of Gravelines on 29 July 1588 (English dates), a strong south-westerly wind drove the Spanish fleet north into the North Sea, and it could not turn back to the Channel. Medina Sidonia had to sail home round the north of Scotland and the west of Ireland. There, autumn gales wrecked dozens of ships on the rocky coasts, and thousands of men drowned or died ashore. Only about half of the roughly 130 ships that set out returned to Spain, and most of the losses came from the weather, not English guns. The English saw it as the “Protestant wind”, a sign that God was on their side. However, by the time the storms struck, the invasion had already failed. The Armada’s task was to escort the Duke of Parma’s army across from the Netherlands, but the plan had a fatal flaw: there was no deep-water port where the fleet and Parma’s barges could meet, and Dutch ships blockaded the coast. When the Armada anchored off Calais on 27 July, Parma was not ready. Spanish preparation was also weakened by Drake’s raid on Cadiz in April 1587, which destroyed ships and the seasoned wood for barrels; new barrels made of green wood leaked, so food rotted and water went bad. Medina Sidonia himself had little experience of war at sea. English tactics were decisive at the key moment. All the way up the Channel, from the first sighting off the Lizard, the Spanish kept a tight crescent formation that the English could not break, even with faster ships and guns they could reload more quickly. Then, on the night of 28 July, the English sent eight fireships into the anchored fleet off Calais. The Spanish captains cut their anchor cables and scattered in panic, and the next day at Gravelines the English attacked the broken formation at close range, sinking or wrecking several ships. Overall, a study of the Armada supports the statement only partly. If the question is why Spain lost so many ships and men, the weather is the main reason. But the Armada’s aim was to invade England, and that aim was defeated off Calais and Gravelines by a flawed Spanish plan and the English fireships, before the storms. So the main reason the Armada failed was the combination of Spanish weaknesses and English tactics; the weather turned that failure into a disaster.

Where marks slip

Use what happened at each stage of the Armada as your evidence, and define “failed” before you judge. Many answers list reasons for the English victory without ever weighing them against the weather.

10 marks / Connecting the bull and the Babington PlotEduqas

Explain the connections between any two of the following: the religious settlement of 1559; the papal bull of 1570; the Babington Plot (1586).

What a full answer includes
  • Choose two features and explain the links between them, not each one on its own.
  • The religious settlement made Elizabeth Supreme Governor of a Protestant Church, which the Pope could not accept.
  • After the failure of the Revolt of the Northern Earls, Pope Pius V issued the bull Regnans in Excelsis (February 1570), excommunicating Elizabeth.
  • The bull released Catholics from obedience to Elizabeth, so to some Catholics killing or overthrowing her now seemed justified.
  • The government answered with harsher laws and Walsingham’s spy network, which is how the Babington Plot was discovered.
  • The Babington Plot aimed to murder Elizabeth and crown Mary, which the bull had encouraged plotters to see as lawful.
  • Use linking language throughout: “this led to”, “because of this”, “as a result”.

Model answer

I will explain the connections between the papal bull of 1570 and the Babington Plot of 1586. The papal bull of February 1570, called Regnans in Excelsis, was issued by Pope Pius V after the failure of the Revolt of the Northern Earls. It excommunicated Elizabeth and declared that her subjects no longer owed her obedience. This is directly connected to the Babington Plot, because the bull turned plotting against the queen into something that devout Catholics could believe was lawful. If Elizabeth was a heretic who had no right to rule, then replacing her with the Catholic Mary, Queen of Scots, could be seen as a religious duty. Anthony Babington and his fellow plotters planned in 1586 to murder Elizabeth, free Mary and support a foreign Catholic invasion, which was exactly the kind of action the bull had encouraged. The two are also connected through the government’s response. Because the bull made every Catholic a possible traitor, Elizabeth’s government became far more watchful. This led to harsher laws against Catholic priests and to Sir Francis Walsingham building a network of spies and agents. As a result, Walsingham was able to use a double agent, Gilbert Gifford, to carry Mary’s secret letters in beer barrels, so that every letter was intercepted and read. That is how the Babington Plot was uncovered, and Mary’s written approval of it led to her execution in 1587. So the bull helped cause the plot and also the system that defeated it.

Where marks slip

Describing the two features one after the other earns little. Every paragraph should show a link, using words such as “led to”, “because” and “as a result”.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free