Show Working
Open the app

GCSE History · Health and medicineAQA, Edexcel, OCR A, OCR B (Schools History Project) and Eduqas

Medicine c1700 to c1900: GCSE questions with answers

35 GCSE History questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working History bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 35 questions 5 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Medicine c1700 to c1900 questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

In 1796, Edward Jenner gave cowpox to James Phipps. What did he then show?

  1. APhipps did not catch smallpox
  2. BPhipps was cured of plague
  3. CPhipps caught cholera
  4. DCowpox killed Phipps
Show the answer

Answer: A Phipps did not catch smallpox

Jenner had heard that milkmaids who caught cowpox did not get smallpox. In 1796 he gave eight-year-old James Phipps cowpox, then exposed him to smallpox, and Phipps stayed well.

Checked against nlm.nih.gov

02 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

In which year did Jenner publish his findings on vaccination?

  1. A1543
  2. B1665
  3. C1798
  4. D1842
Show the answer

Answer: C 1798

The Royal Society asked for more proof, so Jenner repeated his experiment on other children, including his own son, before publishing his Inquiry in 1798.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

03 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Why could Jenner not convince everyone that vaccination worked?

  1. AIt was too expensive to make
  2. BIt used dangerous X-rays
  3. CIt did not prevent smallpox
  4. DHe could not explain why it worked
Show the answer

Answer: D He could not explain why it worked

Nobody yet knew about germs, so Jenner could not explain how cowpox protected people. Some thought it unnatural or against God to give people an animal disease, and doctors who earned money from inoculation also objected.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

04 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA and Edexcel

In which year was smallpox vaccination made compulsory for babies?

  1. A1796
  2. B1832
  3. C1853
  4. D1875
Show the answer

Answer: C 1853

After smallpox epidemics, vaccination was offered free from 1840 and made compulsory by an Act of 1853. Some people believed the government should not force this, and anti-vaccination groups formed.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

05 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA

Which surgeon taught Edward Jenner and urged experiment and observation?

  1. AJoseph Lister
  2. BJohn Hunter
  3. CThomas Sydenham
  4. DJames Simpson
Show the answer

Answer: B John Hunter

John Hunter (1728 to 1793) was a Scottish surgeon and anatomist who dissected many bodies and believed in testing ideas by experiment. He taught Jenner and influenced a new, more scientific approach to surgery.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

06 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

In which year did Louis Pasteur publish his germ theory?

  1. A1796
  2. B1842
  3. C1861
  4. D1882
Show the answer

Answer: C 1861

Pasteur, a French chemist, showed that germs in the air made liquids decay. His germ theory of 1861 replaced the idea of spontaneous generation, though he had not yet proved germs caused human disease.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

07 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Before germ theory, many scientists believed in spontaneous generation. What was it?

  1. AThe idea that cowpox protects against smallpox
  2. BThe idea that the heart makes blood
  3. CThe idea that germs were made by decay
  4. DThe idea that blood circulates
Show the answer

Answer: C The idea that germs were made by decay

Scientists saw microbes on rotting food and thought decay created them. Pasteur showed the opposite: germs from the air cause the decay. This was a key step towards understanding infection.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

08 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

What did Robert Koch show that Pasteur had not?

  1. AThat a specific germ causes a specific disease
  2. BThat cowpox prevents smallpox
  3. CThat the heart pumps blood
  4. DThat germs in the air make milk and beer go sour
Show the answer

Answer: A That a specific germ causes a specific disease

Koch, a German doctor, linked particular microbes to particular diseases: anthrax (1876), tuberculosis (1882) and cholera (1883). He also improved ways of staining bacteria with dyes so they could be seen and identified.

Checked against nobelprize.org

09 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Put Koch’s discoveries in time order, earliest first.

  1. AThe anthrax germ
  2. BThe cholera germ
  3. CThe tuberculosis germ
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. The anthrax germ
  2. The tuberculosis germ
  3. The cholera germ

Koch identified the germ that causes anthrax in 1876, tuberculosis in 1882 and cholera in 1883. Each discovery made germ theory harder to deny.

Checked against nobelprize.org

10 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

How did Pasteur’s team find a way to vaccinate chickens against chicken cholera in 1879?

  1. ABy chance, using a culture left out over a holiday
  2. BBy studying cholera deaths around the Broad Street pump
  3. CBy reading Jenner’s book
  4. DBy using cowpox
Show the answer

Answer: A By chance, using a culture left out over a holiday

Pasteur’s assistant Chamberland injected chickens with an old, weakened culture left during a holiday. They did not get ill, and later resisted fresh cholera. Weakened germs could make vaccines, and Pasteur went on to make others.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

11 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

In 1847, James Simpson found that which chemical was a good anaesthetic?

  1. AChloroform
  2. BCarbolic acid
  3. CEther
  4. DLaughing gas
Show the answer

Answer: A Chloroform

Simpson, an Edinburgh professor of midwifery, tested chemicals on himself and friends and found chloroform worked well in 1847. Patients could now be unconscious, so surgeons could take more time.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

12 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

What helped make chloroform acceptable after 1853?

  1. AParliament made it compulsory
  2. BLister sprayed it in theatres
  3. CPasteur proved it killed germs
  4. DQueen Victoria used it during childbirth
Show the answer

Answer: D Queen Victoria used it during childbirth

In 1853 Queen Victoria was given chloroform by John Snow when giving birth to her eighth child. If the Queen used it, many others felt it was safe and acceptable.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

13 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Why did more patients sometimes die after anaesthetics were first used?

  1. APatients woke up in the street
  2. BChloroform spread smallpox
  3. CSurgeons tried longer operations, and infection rose
  4. DSurgeons stopped washing wounds with carbolic
Show the answer

Answer: C Surgeons tried longer operations, and infection rose

Getting the dose right was hard and some patients died. With patients asleep, surgeons attempted deeper, longer operations, but without antiseptics more wounds became infected. Some also believed pain was natural or sent by God.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

14 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Which chemical did Joseph Lister use as an antiseptic from 1865?

  1. AChloroform
  2. BCarbolic acid
  3. CEther
  4. DSodium citrate
Show the answer

Answer: B Carbolic acid

After reading Pasteur’s germ theory, Lister reasoned that germs caused infection in wounds. From 1865 he used carbolic acid on wounds, dressings and instruments, and fewer of his patients died of infection.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

15 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Why did some surgeons resist Lister’s methods?

  1. AMany did not accept germ theory
  2. BCarbolic acid caused smallpox
  3. CHis methods were too fast
  4. DLister refused to publish
Show the answer

Answer: A Many did not accept germ theory

Many surgeons still believed in spontaneous generation and could not see germs. Carbolic acid also stung skin and slowed operations. Over time, success rates won people over.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

16 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

What is the difference between antiseptic and aseptic surgery?

  1. AAntiseptic surgery is painless; aseptic is not
  2. BThere is no difference
  3. CAseptic surgery uses carbolic spray; antiseptic surgery uses none
  4. DAseptic surgery keeps germs out; antiseptic surgery kills germs present
Show the answer

Answer: D Aseptic surgery keeps germs out; antiseptic surgery kills germs present

Antiseptic surgery kills germs, as Lister did with carbolic acid. Aseptic surgery, from the 1880s and 1890s, stops germs getting in at all: sterilised instruments, scrubbed theatres, gowns and rubber gloves.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

17 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Put these in time order, earliest first.

  1. ASimpson discovers chloroform as an anaesthetic
  2. BPasteur publishes his germ theory
  3. CJenner tests vaccination on James Phipps
  4. DLister first uses carbolic acid
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Jenner tests vaccination on James Phipps
  2. Simpson discovers chloroform as an anaesthetic
  3. Pasteur publishes his germ theory
  4. Lister first uses carbolic acid

Jenner’s test was in 1796, Simpson’s chloroform in 1847, Pasteur’s germ theory in 1861 and Lister’s first use of carbolic acid in 1865.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

18 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Edexcel and Eduqas

Where did Florence Nightingale nurse British soldiers in the Crimean War?

  1. AScutari
  2. BSidcup
  3. CÉtaples
  4. DWaterloo
Show the answer

Answer: A Scutari

Nightingale led nurses at Scutari hospital from 1854. Back in England she used money from the Nightingale Fund to open a nurse training school at St Thomas’s in 1860, and her Notes on Nursing (1859) shaped nursing for generations.

Checked against nam.ac.uk

19 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Edexcel and Eduqas

What did Nightingale’s statistics show about soldiers in the Crimea in 1855 to 1856?

  1. AMore died from disease than from wounds
  2. BNobody died in hospital
  3. CChloroform killed most patients
  4. DMore died from wounds than disease
Show the answer

Answer: A More died from disease than from wounds

Nightingale was a gifted statistician. Her diagrams showed more soldiers died of disease than of wounds, which pushed the army and hospitals to improve cleanliness, ventilation and sanitation.

Checked against nam.ac.uk

20 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

Where were Britain’s first cholera cases reported in 1831?

  1. AEyam
  2. BSunderland
  3. CDover
  4. DSoho, London
Show the answer

Answer: B Sunderland

Cholera reached Britain on a ship docking in Sunderland in October 1831. It killed quickly and struck rich and poor alike, which frightened people and the government.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

21 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

Why did people burn barrels of tar in the streets during cholera outbreaks?

  1. ATo kill rats carrying fleas
  2. BTo boil drinking water
  3. CTo mark houses with cholera
  4. DThey believed bad air spread cholera
Show the answer

Answer: D They believed bad air spread cholera

Most people still believed in miasma, so towns burned tar and removed rubbish to clean the air. Others saw cholera as God’s punishment: a national day of fasting was held in March 1832.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

22 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

In 1854, what did John Snow persuade the authorities to do in Soho?

  1. ABuild new sewers across London
  2. BShut infected houses for 40 days
  3. CRemove the handle of the Broad Street pump
  4. DKill all stray dogs and cats
Show the answer

Answer: C Remove the handle of the Broad Street pump

Snow mapped cholera deaths in Soho and found they clustered around the Broad Street pump. Workers at a nearby brewery, who drank beer, stayed well. The handle was removed on 8 September 1854; the outbreak was already easing, but Snow’s evidence pointed clearly at the water.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

23 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

Why were Snow’s findings not fully accepted at first?

  1. AHe had no map of deaths
  2. BHe was not a doctor
  3. CMost people still believed in miasma
  4. DHe worked in Paris
Show the answer

Answer: C Most people still believed in miasma

Snow showed a link between water and cholera, but he could not see the germ, and many still blamed bad air. Germ theory and Koch’s discovery of the cholera germ in 1883 later supported him.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

24 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

In 1842, Edwin Chadwick published a report linking poor health to:

  1. Abad living conditions
  2. Btoo much exercise
  3. Cthe movement of the planets
  4. Deating too much meat
Show the answer

Answer: A bad living conditions

Chadwick, secretary to the Poor Law Commissioners, published his Report on the Sanitary Condition of the Labouring Population in 1842. He showed the poor lived shorter lives and argued that clean water and drains would cut the cost of poverty.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

25 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

What was the main weakness of the Public Health Act of 1848?

  1. ATowns did not have to act on it
  2. BIt banned clean water
  3. CIt only applied to Scotland
  4. DIt closed all the hospitals
Show the answer

Answer: A Towns did not have to act on it

The 1848 Act, passed in a cholera year, set up a General Board of Health and let towns create local boards of health. It was voluntary, so many towns did nothing.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

26 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

What was the Great Stink of 1858?

  1. AA gas attack in Belgium
  2. BA cholera outbreak in Sunderland
  3. CA factory fire in Manchester
  4. DThe smell of sewage in the hot River Thames
Show the answer

Answer: D The smell of sewage in the hot River Thames

In the hot summer of 1858, sewage in the Thames smelled so bad that it affected Parliament itself. MPs quickly backed Joseph Bazalgette’s plan for new sewers.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

27 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

Who designed London’s new sewer system after the Great Stink?

  1. AJoseph Bazalgette
  2. BJohn Snow
  3. CJoseph Lister
  4. DEdwin Chadwick
Show the answer

Answer: A Joseph Bazalgette

Bazalgette, chief engineer of the Metropolitan Board of Works, built over 1,000 miles of sewers that carried waste away from the city. Main parts opened in 1865, and many are still in use.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

28 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

What made the Public Health Act of 1875 different from the 1848 Act?

  1. AIt only covered London
  2. BIt was compulsory
  3. CIt was voluntary
  4. DIt created the NHS
Show the answer

Answer: B It was compulsory

The 1875 Public Health Act made councils provide clean water, drains and sewers, deal with nuisances and appoint a Medical Officer of Health. Government had moved away from laissez-faire.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

29 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA and OCR B (Schools History Project)

Which 1875 Act let councils clear slums and rebuild?

  1. AThe Artisans’ and Labourers’ Dwellings Act
  2. BThe Clean Air Act
  3. CThe Sale of Food and Drugs Act
  4. DThe Vaccination Act
Show the answer

Answer: A The Artisans’ and Labourers’ Dwellings Act

Alongside the Public Health Act, 1875 brought the Artisans’ and Labourers’ Dwellings Act on housing and the Sale of Food and Drugs Act, which set standards for food. Together they show government taking responsibility for health.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

30 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

What did laissez-faire mean for public health in the early 1800s?

  1. AThe government should not interfere in people’s lives
  2. BEvery town must have a hospital
  3. CThe government must build sewers
  4. DCouncils must provide clean water and drains for everyone
Show the answer

Answer: A The government should not interfere in people’s lives

Laissez-faire is the belief that government should leave people and business alone. It slowed public health reform, as many thought paying for drains and water was not the government’s job.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

31 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

In industrial towns, what were back-to-back houses?

  1. AHouses for nurses near hospitals
  2. BHouses joined at the back and sides, with no through air
  3. CLarge detached houses with gardens at the front and back
  4. DHouses built over cesspits on stilts
Show the answer

Answer: B Houses joined at the back and sides, with no through air

Back-to-back houses were cheap homes joined at the back and sides, with poor light and air. Several families often shared one privy, and the poorest lived in damp cellars.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

32 / Medicine c1700 to c1900Every board with this unit

Put these in time order, earliest first.

  1. AThe first Public Health Act is passed
  2. BThe Public Health Act makes reform compulsory
  3. CSnow has the Broad Street pump handle removed
  4. DChadwick publishes his report on the labouring population
  5. EThe Great Stink hits London
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Chadwick publishes his report on the labouring population
  2. The first Public Health Act is passed
  3. Snow has the Broad Street pump handle removed
  4. The Great Stink hits London
  5. The Public Health Act makes reform compulsory

Chadwick’s report came in 1842 and the first Public Health Act in 1848. Snow’s pump handle was removed in 1854, the Great Stink came in 1858, and the compulsory Public Health Act in 1875.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

33 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Which new idea explained, at last, why Lister’s and Snow’s methods worked?

  1. AGerm theory
  2. BThe Four Humours
  3. CMiasma
  4. DSpontaneous generation
Show the answer

Answer: A Germ theory

Germ theory showed that microbes cause infection and disease. It explained why carbolic acid protected wounds and why dirty water spread cholera, and it led to new vaccines and, later, drugs aimed at specific germs.

Checked against healthandthepeople.ncl.ac.uk

34 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

Where had Lady Mary Wortley Montagu seen smallpox inoculation before bringing the idea to England?

  1. AIn the American colonies
  2. BIn Holland
  3. CIn Scotland
  4. DIn the Ottoman Empire (Turkey)
Show the answer

Answer: D In the Ottoman Empire (Turkey)

In Turkey, where her husband was ambassador, Montagu saw people given a mild dose of smallpox to protect them, and had her son inoculated in 1718. In 1721 she had her daughter inoculated in London, and in 1722 the Princess of Wales had two of her daughters done. It worked, but some people caught full smallpox from it.

Checked against historyofparliament.com

35 / Medicine c1700 to c1900AQA, Edexcel and Eduqas

In 1885 Pasteur’s rabies vaccine saved Joseph Meister. Who was he?

  1. AA soldier wounded in battle
  2. BA boy bitten by a rabid dog
  3. CPasteur’s own assistant
  4. DA cholera victim in London
Show the answer

Answer: B A boy bitten by a rabid dog

Jenner used a different disease, cowpox. Pasteur’s team weakened the germs of the disease itself: chicken cholera (1879), anthrax (a public test on sheep in 1881) and rabies, given to nine-year-old Joseph Meister in July 1885. Pasteur named them vaccines in Jenner’s honour.

Checked against pasteur.fr

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

8 marks / Significance of germ theoryAQA

Explain the significance of Pasteur’s germ theory for the development of medicine.

What a full answer includes
  • At the time: in 1861 Pasteur showed that microbes in the air caused decay, disproving spontaneous generation.
  • It led Lister to use carbolic acid from 1865 to kill germs in wounds, so surgery became safer.
  • It led Koch to link particular microbes to particular diseases (anthrax 1876, tuberculosis 1882, cholera 1883).
  • It led to new vaccines: Pasteur’s chicken cholera (1879–80), anthrax (1881) and rabies (1885).
  • Over time: it was the basis of aseptic surgery, of public health based on clean water, and of later “magic bullets” and antibiotics.
  • Its impact was not immediate: many doctors were slow to accept it.

Model answer

Pasteur’s germ theory was significant at the time because it changed ideas about the cause of disease. In 1861 Pasteur showed that microbes in the air caused liquids to decay, which disproved the old idea of spontaneous generation. This gave other scientists a new explanation of infection. In Britain Joseph Lister reasoned that germs caused infection in wounds, and from 1865 he used carbolic acid on wounds, dressings and instruments, so fewer of his patients died. In Germany Robert Koch built on germ theory to identify the microbes that cause anthrax (1876), tuberculosis (1882) and cholera (1883), which proved that particular germs cause particular diseases. Pasteur himself went on to make vaccines for chicken cholera, anthrax and rabies. Germ theory was also significant over time because almost all modern medicine rests on it. It led to aseptic surgery in the 1890s, with sterilised instruments and rubber gloves. It explained why clean water and sewers prevented diseases such as cholera, which supported public health reform. In the twentieth century it was the starting point for Ehrlich’s search for “magic bullets” that target germs, and for antibiotics such as penicillin. Its impact was not immediate, as many doctors at first refused to accept that tiny organisms could kill, but in the long run it was a turning point in understanding and treating disease.

Where marks slip

Do not tell the story of Pasteur’s experiments in detail. Examiners want what germ theory led to, at the time and over the long term, and confusing Pasteur with Paré loses everything.

16 marks + 4 SPaG / Germ theory and surgeryEdexcel

‘Germ theory was the main reason for improvements in surgery in the period c1700–c1900.’

How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: chloroform; Lister’s use of carbolic acid. You must also use information of your own.

What a full answer includes
  • Surgery faced three problems: pain, infection and bleeding.
  • For: Lister read Pasteur’s germ theory and used carbolic acid from 1865, published in 1867; deaths from infection fell.
  • For: germ theory led to aseptic surgery in the 1880s and 1890s (sterilised instruments, gowns, rubber gloves).
  • Against: pain was solved first by anaesthetics with no link to germ theory: Simpson discovered chloroform in 1847.
  • Against: Queen Victoria’s use of chloroform in 1853 changed attitudes and made anaesthetics acceptable.
  • Against: John Hunter’s scientific, experimental approach in the 1700s had already improved surgical training.
  • Against: bleeding was not solved until the twentieth century, so improvement was incomplete.
  • A judgement with a clear criterion, for example which change saved most lives.

Model answer

In 1700 surgery was dangerous because of three problems: pain, infection and bleeding. By 1900 surgery was much safer, and germ theory played a major part in this. Germ theory was the main reason surgery became free from infection. Before the 1860s surgeons operated in their ordinary clothes and did not clean their instruments, and many patients died of infection after a successful operation. After reading Pasteur’s germ theory, the Glasgow surgeon Joseph Lister reasoned that germs from the air were causing wounds to rot. From 1865 he used carbolic acid on wounds, dressings and instruments, and later sprayed it in the air during operations. He published his results in 1867, showing that far fewer of his patients died. Germ theory then led to aseptic surgery in the 1880s and 1890s, where theatres were kept germ-free with sterilised instruments, surgical gowns and rubber gloves. Without germ theory, none of this would have happened. However, the first great improvement, the end of pain, had nothing to do with germ theory. In November 1847 James Simpson, an Edinburgh professor, discovered that chloroform made patients unconscious. Surgeons could now work more carefully and attempt longer operations. This came from experiment by an individual and from developments in chemistry. Attitudes were also important: some people believed pain was sent by God, but when Queen Victoria used chloroform in the birth of her eighth child in 1853, it became acceptable. Earlier still, John Hunter’s experimental approach in the 1700s had helped to make surgery more scientific. Some problems were not solved in this period at all. Bleeding remained a danger until blood groups were discovered in 1901, so surgery had improved only partly by 1900. Anaesthetics even made infection worse for a time, because longer operations allowed more germs into wounds. Overall, I agree to a large extent. Anaesthetics were an important improvement that came separately, through Simpson’s work and changing attitudes. But the most important measure of improvement is how many patients survived, and the biggest killer after an operation was infection. Only germ theory, through Lister’s antiseptics and aseptic surgery, solved that problem, so it was the main reason surgery became truly safer by 1900.

Where marks slip

Saying the statement is “true to an extent” without a reason keeps you out of the top level. Choose a criterion, such as lives saved, and use it to reach your judgement.

10 marks / Why government acted on public healthOCR B (Schools History Project)

Why did the government take more action to improve public health in the period c.1750–c.1900? Explain your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Cholera epidemics (1831–32, 1848–49, 1853–54, 1866) killed rich and poor and frightened the government into acting.
  • Evidence grew: Chadwick’s 1842 report showed the poor died younger and argued clean water and drains would save money.
  • John Snow’s work on the Broad Street pump (1854) linked cholera with dirty water.
  • The Great Stink of 1858 affected Parliament itself and led to Bazalgette’s sewers.
  • Germ theory (from 1861) gave a scientific reason to clean up water and waste.
  • The Reform Act of 1867 gave many working men in towns the vote, so politicians had to listen to them.
  • Laissez-faire ideas weakened, leading to the compulsory Public Health Act of 1875.

Model answer

One reason the government took more action was the shock of cholera. Cholera reached Britain in 1831 and returned in 1848, 1853 and 1866. It killed quickly and struck the rich as well as the poor, which frightened people who had ignored the slums. The first Public Health Act of 1848 was passed in a cholera year, setting up a General Board of Health, but it was voluntary and many towns did nothing. A second reason was growing evidence. In 1842 Edwin Chadwick’s report showed that poor people in towns lived much shorter lives, and he argued that clean water and drains would reduce the cost of poverty, which appealed to taxpayers. In 1854 John Snow mapped cholera deaths around the Broad Street pump in Soho and showed the disease spread through water. In the hot summer of 1858 the Great Stink from the Thames affected Parliament itself, and MPs quickly backed Bazalgette’s new sewers. Pasteur’s germ theory of 1861 later gave a scientific reason for clean water. A third reason was political change. The Reform Act of 1867 gave the vote to many working men in towns, so politicians needed to win their support by improving living conditions. Belief in laissez-faire, the idea that government should not interfere, became weaker. These pressures came together in the Public Health Act of 1875, which made councils provide clean water, drains and sewers and appoint a Medical Officer of Health.

Where marks slip

Do not write a timeline of public health laws. Explain the reasons behind them, and show how fear, evidence and politics together changed the government’s attitude.

9 marks / Opposition to Jenner’s vaccinationEduqas

Explain why there was opposition to Edward Jenner’s vaccination against smallpox.

What a full answer includes
  • Jenner (1796, published 1798) could not explain how cowpox protected people, because germs were not yet understood.
  • Some people thought it was unnatural or against God to give humans a disease from cows.
  • Doctors who earned money from inoculation (deliberately giving mild smallpox) stood to lose their income.
  • The Royal Society asked for more proof before accepting his work.
  • When vaccination became compulsory in 1853, some objected that the government should not force it on people.

Model answer

One reason for opposition was that Jenner could not explain how vaccination worked. In 1796 he gave cowpox to James Phipps and then showed that the boy did not catch smallpox, and he published his findings in 1798. But nobody yet knew about germs or the immune system, so Jenner could only show that it worked, not why. The Royal Society asked for more proof, and many doctors were unwilling to trust a method without a theory behind it. A second reason was religious and moral objections. Some people believed it was unnatural or against God’s will to put a disease from an animal into a human body. Cartoons of the time mocked vaccination by showing people growing cow-like features, which shows how strange the idea seemed. A third reason was money and freedom. Since the 1720s inoculators had earned a living by giving people a mild dose of smallpox to protect them, so vaccination threatened their income and some of them spoke out against it. Later, when the government made vaccination compulsory in 1853, opposition grew from people who believed the government had no right to force a medical treatment on them, and anti-vaccination groups were formed.

Where marks slip

Describing Jenner’s experiment is not enough. Each point should explain why a particular group opposed him and what their reason was.

16 marks + 4 SPaG / The individual and infectious diseaseAQA

Has the role of the individual been the main factor in the fight against infectious disease in Britain since c1000? Explain your answer with reference to the individual and other factors. Use a range of examples from across your study of Health and the people: c1000 to the present day.

What a full answer includes
  • For: Jenner’s cowpox experiment (1796) led to vaccination against smallpox.
  • For: Pasteur (germ theory, 1861) and Koch (identifying microbes, 1876 to 1883) changed understanding of infection.
  • For: Fleming noticed penicillin in 1928, and Florey and Chain turned it into a usable drug (1939–41).
  • Against: in the Middle Ages religion shaped responses to disease, such as prayer during the Black Death, and slowed progress.
  • Against: science and technology, such as better microscopes and dye staining, made individuals’ discoveries possible.
  • Against: war and government turned discoveries into results: US mass production of penicillin by D-Day, compulsory vaccination (1853), NHS vaccination programmes.
  • Against: chance played a part, as with Fleming’s mould.
  • A judgement on how far individuals were the main factor, linking them to other factors.

Model answer

Individuals have played a vital part in the fight against infectious disease. In 1796 Edward Jenner, a country doctor, tested the idea that cowpox protected people from smallpox by infecting James Phipps with cowpox and then exposing him to smallpox. His vaccination spread around the world and smallpox was eventually wiped out. In the nineteenth century Louis Pasteur’s germ theory of 1861 showed that microbes cause disease, and Robert Koch identified the germs behind anthrax, tuberculosis and cholera between 1876 and 1883. In 1928 Alexander Fleming noticed that mould had killed bacteria on a plate, and from 1939 Howard Florey and Ernst Chain purified penicillin and tested it. Each of these people made a breakthrough that others could build on. However, other factors were often just as important. In the Middle Ages religion shaped how people fought disease. During the Black Death of 1348 many prayed or joined the flagellants because they believed the plague was God’s punishment, and the Church’s support for Galen held back new ideas. Science and technology also made individuals’ work possible: Koch could only identify microbes because of better microscopes and his new methods of staining bacteria with dyes. War and government turned discoveries into results for ordinary people. Fleming could not produce penicillin in quantity, and even Florey and Chain’s first patient, a police officer, died in 1941 when supplies ran out. It was the Second World War that made the difference: the American government backed drug companies to mass-produce penicillin, and there was enough to treat Allied soldiers by D-Day in 1944. Government also spread vaccination: smallpox vaccination was made compulsory in 1853, and after 1948 the NHS ran mass vaccination against diseases such as diphtheria and polio. Chance played a part too, since Fleming’s discovery began with a mould landing on a plate. In conclusion, individuals have not been the main factor on their own. They made the key discoveries, so without Jenner, Pasteur or Fleming progress would have been slower. But their work only saved large numbers of lives when it was combined with science and technology, with the money and organisation of governments and, in the case of penicillin, with the pressure of war. Government action was what carried discoveries to the whole population, so the individual was important but not the main factor.

Where marks slip

Answers that tell the story of three famous people lose marks. Weigh the individual against at least two other factors, use examples from more than one period, and link the factors together.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 35 questions in Show Working

This page shows 35 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE History topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free