Show Working
Open the app

GCSE History · Crime and punishmentAQA, Edexcel, OCR A, OCR B (Schools History Project) and Eduqas

Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700: GCSE questions with answers

40 GCSE History questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working History bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 40 questions 3 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700 questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Treason, plotting against the monarch, is an example of a crime against:

  1. Aproperty
  2. Bauthority
  3. Cthe Church only
  4. Dthe person
Show the answer

Answer: B authority

Historians sort crimes into three kinds: crimes against the person (such as murder and assault), against property (such as theft), and against authority (such as treason, betraying the monarch). Using these labels helps you compare crime across periods.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

02 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Why do historians call poaching a “social crime”?

  1. AIt was judged only by Church courts
  2. BMany people did not think it was really wrong
  3. COnly nobles were ever charged with it
  4. DIt was always punished by death
Show the answer

Answer: B Many people did not think it was really wrong

A social crime is one that the law forbids but many ordinary people accept. Poaching animals for food is the classic example, so communities were often reluctant to report it.

Checked against qualifications.pearson.com

03 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

In Anglo-Saxon law, what was the wergild?

  1. AA group of ten men who kept order
  2. BA tax paid to build the king’s prisons
  3. CA fine paid to the Church for sins against God
  4. DCompensation paid to a victim or their family
Show the answer

Answer: D Compensation paid to a victim or their family

The wergild (“man price”) was money paid to the victim’s family, and Anglo-Saxon laws set a higher price for people of higher rank. Paying compensation was meant to stop a family taking revenge in a blood feud.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

04 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

King Alfred’s laws said that when a man killed someone, part of the wergild could be paid by:

  1. Ahis relatives
  2. Bthe king’s sheriff
  3. Cthe victim’s lord
  4. Dthe local bishop
Show the answer

Answer: A his relatives

Anglo-Saxon law made families share responsibility: Alfred’s laws had a killer’s relatives pay part of the wergild. This communal and family responsibility for crime is a key feature of Saxon law and order.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

05 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

In Anglo-Saxon England, a tithing was:

  1. Aa tenth of a harvest paid to the Church
  2. Ba group of men responsible for each other
  3. Ca royal judge who toured the shires
  4. Da cell beneath a castle for prisoners
Show the answer

Answer: B a group of men responsible for each other

Men were grouped into tithings of about ten. If one of them broke the law, the others had to bring him to court or pay. Neighbours policed each other because there was no police force.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

06 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

What was the hue and cry?

  1. AA trial in which God judged guilt
  2. BEveryone joining the chase after a suspect
  3. CA church bell rung before a hanging
  4. DA royal order to arrest heretics
Show the answer

Answer: B Everyone joining the chase after a suspect

When a crime was discovered, people shouted to raise the alarm and everyone who heard had to help chase the suspect. Anglo-Saxon laws already required local men to pursue thieves, and the duty to join a hue and cry still existed in the 1700s.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

07 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

Why was trial by ordeal used?

  1. AJuries refused to meet in winter
  2. BPeople believed God would show the truth
  3. CKings wanted to raise money from fines
  4. DPriests were not allowed in court
Show the answer

Answer: B People believed God would show the truth

Ordeals were used when a case could not be settled by evidence or oaths. They took place in church with a priest, and everyone prayed that God would reveal whether the accused was innocent or guilty.

Checked against rochestercathedral.org

08 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

In the ordeal by hot iron, how was the result decided?

  1. ABy a vote of the people in church
  2. BBy whether the burn was healing after three days
  3. CBy whether the accused cried out in pain while holding it
  4. DBy whether the iron stayed red hot
Show the answer

Answer: B By whether the burn was healing after three days

The accused carried a hot iron a short distance. The hand was bound and sealed, then checked on the third day: clean meant innocent, festering meant guilty. Hot water worked the same way.

Checked against rochestercathedral.org

09 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

Which of these was a form of trial by ordeal?

  1. ABeing lowered into cold water
  2. BTaking refuge inside a church
  3. CReading a verse from the Bible
  4. DPaying a fine to the victim
Show the answer

Answer: A Being lowered into cold water

There were ordeals by hot iron, hot water and cold water. Henry II’s Assize of Clarendon (1166) sent suspected robbers and murderers to the ordeal of water.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

10 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

In 1215 the Pope banned priests from blessing ordeals. What did this lead to?

  1. AOrdeals stopped being used in England
  2. BJuries were banned from courts
  3. COrdeals became more common
  4. DSanctuary was abolished
Show the answer

Answer: A Ordeals stopped being used in England

The Fourth Lateran Council of 1215 banned clergy from blessing ordeals. Without a priest the ordeal had no religious meaning, so English courts soon stopped using it and relied more on juries instead.

Checked against sourcebooks.fordham.edu

11 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

Which new way of settling a case did the Normans bring to England?

  1. AThe hue and cry
  2. BTrial by hot iron
  3. CTrial by combat
  4. DThe tithing
Show the answer

Answer: C Trial by combat

William I’s laws let an Englishman accused by a Norman choose the ordeal of iron or “wager of battle”, a fight in which God was thought to favour the innocent. It is the first mention of trial by combat in English law.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

12 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

Under the Normans, what was the murdrum fine?

  1. AA tax on hunting in the king’s forests
  2. BA payment to a victim’s family by rank
  3. CA fine on a whole area if a Norman was killed
  4. DA fine paid by the Church for all the land it held
Show the answer

Answer: C A fine on a whole area if a Norman was killed

If a Norman was murdered and the killer was not handed over, the people of the whole hundred had to pay a large fine to the king. It protected the small number of Normans by making local people hand over killers.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

13 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

After the Norman Conquest, the Forest Laws made it a crime to:

  1. Ahunt in the king’s forests without permission
  2. Btravel at night without a light
  3. Cspeak English in a royal court
  4. Dcut down any tree anywhere in England without a licence
Show the answer

Answer: A hunt in the king’s forests without permission

Royal forests were the king’s hunting grounds, and ordinary people who hunted or took wood there broke the law. By 1217 royal forests covered about a third of England, so the Forest Laws turned common activities into crimes.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

14 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

Henry II’s Assize of Clarendon (1166) ordered that, where there were none:

  1. Apolice forces should be set up
  2. Bgaols should be built
  3. Cwitches should be tried
  4. Dmonasteries should be closed
Show the answer

Answer: B gaols should be built

The Assize of Clarendon ordered juries of local men to name suspected robbers and murderers, and ordered gaols to be built to hold them until royal judges arrived. Medieval gaols mostly held people awaiting trial rather than punishing them.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

15 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

What were the assizes?

  1. APrisons for people who owed money
  2. BCourts run by bishops for clergy accused of crimes
  3. CCourts held by judges travelling from London
  4. DMeetings of a tithing every month
Show the answer

Answer: C Courts held by judges travelling from London

From the 1100s England was divided into circuits, and royal judges visited the main county towns to hold the assizes. They tried serious crimes such as murder and highway robbery with local juries, and the system lasted until 1971.

Checked against parliament.uk

16 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Justices of the Peace (JPs) were first appointed in which century?

  1. AThe 1000s
  2. BThe 1300s
  3. CThe 1500s
  4. DThe 1700s
Show the answer

Answer: B The 1300s

JPs were first appointed by a statute of the 1300s. They were respected local landowners, unpaid and not trained lawyers, who arrested suspects, heard minor cases and sent serious ones to the assizes.

Checked against parliament.uk

17 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

What were quarter sessions?

  1. ARoyal visits to each county
  2. BCourts held by JPs four times a year
  3. CChurch services for prisoners
  4. DPrison terms of three months
Show the answer

Answer: B Courts held by JPs four times a year

A statute of 1363 told JPs to hold sessions four times a year in each county. These quarter sessions dealt with less serious crimes, while the assizes dealt with the most serious ones.

Checked against parliament.uk

18 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Who traditionally served as a parish constable?

  1. ASoldiers sent by the king
  2. BPaid officers from a national force
  3. CPriests chosen by the bishop
  4. DLocal householders, unpaid, for a year
Show the answer

Answer: D Local householders, unpaid, for a year

Householders took turns to be constable, part-time and alongside their normal work. They arrested suspects and brought them before a JP but did not investigate crimes. This amateur system lasted until the 1800s.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

19 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

In early modern towns, what did night watchmen do?

  1. ACarried out executions
  2. BCollected taxes for the king
  3. CRan the church courts
  4. DPatrolled the streets after dark
Show the answer

Answer: D Patrolled the streets after dark

Watchmen patrolled town streets at night and questioned suspicious people, reporting to the constable. Householders were expected to take turns on the watch; from the late 1600s many paid deputies instead, and later towns hired full-time watchmen.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

20 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

A fugitive who claimed sanctuary in a church was usually protected for:

  1. A40 days
  2. BSeven years
  3. COne night
  4. DThe rest of their life
Show the answer

Answer: A 40 days

A fugitive who reached a church was protected for about 40 days. Then they had to face trial or go into exile for life. Sanctuary showed the Church’s power over justice, and it was abolished in England in 1624.

Checked against durhamcathedral.co.uk

21 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

To claim benefit of clergy, an accused person had to:

  1. Apay a fine to the bishop
  2. Bcarry a hot iron in church
  3. Cread a verse from the Bible
  4. Dswear an oath on a saint’s relics
Show the answer

Answer: C read a verse from the Bible

Clergy could be tried in Church courts, which did not hang people. Because few others could read, reading a verse (usually from Psalm 51) was the test. As more people learned to read, many escaped hanging this way; it was abolished in 1827.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

22 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Why were people who used benefit of clergy branded on the thumb?

  1. ATo show they had become priests
  2. BSo they could not claim it a second time
  3. CTo mark them as heretics
  4. DSo they could be found after escaping
Show the answer

Answer: B So they could not claim it a second time

Branding the thumb meant a person could claim benefit of clergy only once. It shows how the authorities tried to limit a loophole that let many guilty people avoid the death penalty.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

23 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

In 1401 Parliament passed a law allowing which punishment for heretics?

  1. AHard labour
  2. BTransportation
  3. CBranding on the cheek
  4. DBurning
Show the answer

Answer: D Burning

The 1401 law De Heretico Comburendo (“on the burning of heretics”) was aimed at the Lollards, followers of John Wyclif who criticised Church teaching.

Checked against parliament.uk

24 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

In the 1500s, why could a belief be legal under one monarch but heresy under the next?

  1. AParliament stopped meeting for many years
  2. BEach monarch set a different official religion
  3. CThe Pope chose the laws of England
  4. DBishops were elected by the people
Show the answer

Answer: B Each monarch set a different official religion

Henry VIII broke with Rome, Edward VI made the Church more Protestant, Mary I brought back Catholicism and Elizabeth I restored a Protestant Church in 1559. With each change, the line between loyal worship and heresy or treason moved.

Checked against parliament.uk

25 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

In the 1580s and early 1590s, Elizabeth I’s laws punished Catholics who kept to their faith with:

  1. Aloss of the vote
  2. Bservice in the navy
  3. Ctransportation to Australia
  4. Dfines and prison
Show the answer

Answer: D fines and prison

After Catholic plots against Elizabeth, Parliament passed harsh laws fining and imprisoning people who kept up Catholic worship. Religion and loyalty to the monarch were closely tied, so worship could be treated as a threat to the state.

Checked against parliament.uk

26 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Which Act of 1542 made witchcraft a crime punishable by death?

  1. AThe Act of Uniformity
  2. BThe Transportation Act
  3. CThe Witchcraft Act
  4. DThe Act of Supremacy
Show the answer

Answer: C The Witchcraft Act

Witchcraft became a new crime in the 1500s. The 1542 Act made it punishable by death; it was repealed, then an Act under Elizabeth I made it a crime again. James I, who wrote a book about witchcraft, passed a harsher Act in 1604, with death for a first offence of calling up evil spirits.

Checked against parliament.uk

27 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Who were usually accused of witchcraft in England?

  1. APoor, elderly women
  2. BRich merchants
  3. CYoung soldiers
  4. DMembers of Parliament
Show the answer

Answer: A Poor, elderly women

Accusations often followed sudden misfortune, such as a child’s death, a bad harvest or dying cattle. The accused were usually poor, elderly women. Some 500 people in England are believed to have been executed for witchcraft.

Checked against parliament.uk

28 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Houses of correction (Bridewells), a 1500s idea, were used mainly to punish:

  1. Adebtors from the nobility
  2. Bmurderers awaiting execution
  3. Cvagrants and petty criminals
  4. Dtraitors and heretics
Show the answer

Answer: C vagrants and petty criminals

Vagabondage, wandering and begging without work, was treated as a new crime in Tudor times. Houses of correction set vagrants and petty offenders to hard labour, both to punish them and to teach them to work.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

29 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Why were punishments such as the pillory carried out in public?

  1. ABecause prisons were all full
  2. BTo shame offenders and deter others
  3. CSo the Church could pray for them
  4. DTo raise money from the crowd
Show the answer

Answer: B To shame offenders and deter others

Public punishment aimed at deterrence and retribution. Crowds watched offenders shamed in the pillory or stocks, whipped through the streets or hanged, and the authorities hoped the sight would warn others off crime.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

30 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Men found guilty of treason were sentenced to be:

  1. Aburned at the stake
  2. Bbranded on the thumb
  3. Changed, drawn and quartered
  4. Dtransported for life
Show the answer

Answer: C hanged, drawn and quartered

Treason was the worst crime because it attacked the monarch, so it had the most brutal punishment, meant to terrify others. The surviving Gunpowder plotters received this sentence in 1606.

Checked against parliament.uk

31 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Convicts were first transported as a punishment to:

  1. AAmerica and the West Indies
  2. BIndia
  3. CNew Zealand
  4. DAustralia
Show the answer

Answer: A America and the West Indies

Transportation began in the 1600s: convicts were sent to North America and the West Indies from 1614 until 1775. It removed criminals from Britain and supplied labour to the colonies, and was a new alternative to hanging.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

32 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

The growing number of crimes punishable by death in the 1600s and 1700s was later called:

  1. Athe Penal Code
  2. Bthe Forest Laws
  3. Cthe Bloody Code
  4. Dthe Black Act
Show the answer

Answer: C the Bloody Code

Many laws passed in the 1600s and 1700s made even minor property crimes punishable by death. Critics later called this body of law the Bloody Code. It aimed to deter crime by fear.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

33 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel

Who led the Gunpowder Plot of 1605?

  1. AFrancis Tresham
  2. BGuy Fawkes
  3. CLord Monteagle
  4. DRobert Catesby
Show the answer

Answer: D Robert Catesby

Robert Catesby was the plot’s leader. Guy Fawkes, a gunpowder expert, was caught guarding the barrels in a storeroom under the House of Lords. The Catholic plotters wanted to kill James I at the State Opening of Parliament.

Checked against parliament.uk

34 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel

How was the Gunpowder Plot discovered?

  1. AA plotter confessed everything to his priest
  2. BSpanish spies told the king
  3. CA lord was warned by letter to stay away
  4. DThe gunpowder exploded early
Show the answer

Answer: C A lord was warned by letter to stay away

On 26 October 1605 Lord Monteagle received an anonymous letter warning him to stay away from Parliament. He took it to Robert Cecil, the cellars were searched, and Fawkes was arrested with the gunpowder late on 4 November.

Checked against parliament.uk

35 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel

Put these events of the Gunpowder Plot in order, earliest first.

  1. APlotters are attacked at Holbeach House
  2. BGuy Fawkes is arrested under the House of Lords
  3. CLord Monteagle receives a warning letter
  4. DCaptured plotters are executed in London
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Lord Monteagle receives a warning letter
  2. Guy Fawkes is arrested under the House of Lords
  3. Plotters are attacked at Holbeach House
  4. Captured plotters are executed in London

The letter came on 26 October 1605; Fawkes was arrested on the night of 4 to 5 November; the plotters who fled were attacked at Holbeach House in Staffordshire on 8 November; the survivors were executed on 30 and 31 January 1606.

Checked against parliament.uk

36 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel

What happened to the captured Gunpowder plotters in January 1606?

  1. AThey were transported to America
  2. BThey were hanged, drawn and quartered
  3. CThey were burned as heretics
  4. DThey were pardoned by James I
Show the answer

Answer: B They were hanged, drawn and quartered

Four plotters were killed in the shoot-out at Holbeach House; the remaining eight were convicted of treason and hanged, drawn and quartered. Parliament then tightened the laws against Catholics, beginning with an Act of 1605.

Checked against parliament.uk

37 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Every board with this unit

Put these laws in order, earliest first.

  1. AElizabeth I’s Act of Supremacy
  2. BA law allows the burning of heretics
  3. CThe right of sanctuary is abolished
  4. DWitchcraft is made punishable by death
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. A law allows the burning of heretics
  2. Witchcraft is made punishable by death
  3. Elizabeth I’s Act of Supremacy
  4. The right of sanctuary is abolished

The heresy law was passed in 1401, the first Witchcraft Act in 1542, Elizabeth’s Act of Supremacy in 1559, and sanctuary was abolished in 1624. Each shows how religion shaped what counted as a crime.

Checked against parliament.uk

38 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

Put these in order, earliest first.

  1. AWilliam I’s laws bring in trial by combat
  2. BHenry II’s Assize of Clarendon
  3. CKing Alfred’s laws set wergild payments
  4. DThe Pope bans clergy from ordeals
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. King Alfred’s laws set wergild payments
  2. William I’s laws bring in trial by combat
  3. Henry II’s Assize of Clarendon
  4. The Pope bans clergy from ordeals

Alfred’s laws date from around 890, William I’s from after 1066, the Assize of Clarendon from 1166 and the ban on clergy taking part in ordeals from 1215. Together they show the move from Saxon community justice to royal justice.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

39 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel and Eduqas

William I’s laws said that, instead of being hanged, some offenders should be:

  1. Aput on probation
  2. Btransported
  3. Cmutilated
  4. Dsent to a workhouse
Show the answer

Answer: C mutilated

One of William I’s laws forbade killing or hanging for an offence and ordered mutilation instead. Physical punishment was meant to deter others, as a maimed offender was a visible warning.

Checked against avalon.law.yale.edu

40 / Crime and punishment, c1000 to c1700Edexcel

Matthew Hopkins and John Stearne led witch-hunts mainly in which part of England?

  1. ALancashire
  2. BEast Anglia
  3. CThe Scottish borders
  4. DCornwall
Show the answer

Answer: B East Anglia

Calling himself the Witchfinder General, Hopkins and his partner John Stearne hunted witches in Essex, Suffolk and nearby counties from 1645 to 1647. Far more people were hanged than in any other English witch-hunt; in England witches were hanged, not burned.

Checked against cambridge.org

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

12 marks / Why justice changed after 1066Edexcel

Explain why there were changes in the way crime was dealt with in the period c1000–c1200. You may use the following in your answer: the Norman Conquest; the Forest Laws. You must also use information of your own.

What a full answer includes
  • William I needed to control a hostile conquered population, so he made justice serve the king.
  • Compensation to the victim’s family (wergild) gave way to fines paid to the king, and the murdrum fine made a whole hundred pay if a Norman was killed.
  • The Normans added trial by combat as a new way of reaching a verdict.
  • The Forest Laws made hunting and taking wood in royal forests a crime, turning ordinary activities into offences.
  • Henry II’s Assize of Clarendon (1166) restored order after a civil war: juries named suspects, royal judges travelled the country and gaols were built.
  • The Church gained its own courts, so clergy could claim benefit of clergy.

Model answer

One reason for change was the Norman Conquest. After 1066 William I ruled a hostile population of over a million English people with a small number of Normans, so he used the law to strengthen his control. Under the Anglo-Saxons a killer’s family paid wergild, compensation to the victim’s family, to stop blood feuds. The Normans moved towards fines paid to the king instead, which increased royal power and income. William also brought in the murdrum fine: if a Norman was murdered and the killer was not handed over, the whole hundred had to pay a large sum. This was meant to protect Normans by making local people police each other. The Normans also introduced trial by combat, a fight in which God was believed to favour the innocent. A second reason was the king’s wish to protect his own interests, shown by the Forest Laws. William declared large areas royal forests, where only the king and his nobles could hunt. Ordinary people who hunted deer, collected firewood or let animals graze there now committed a crime and could face harsh punishments. By 1217 royal forests covered about a third of England. Because many people felt these laws were unfair, poaching became a social crime that communities often refused to report. A third reason was the need to restore order. After years of civil war between Stephen and Matilda, Henry II issued the Assize of Clarendon in 1166. It ordered juries of local men to name suspected robbers and murderers, sent royal judges round the country to try them, and ordered gaols to be built to hold suspects until the judges arrived. This made justice more royal and more national. At the same time the Church built up its own courts, where churchmen could be tried and avoid execution, so religion shaped the system too.

Where marks slip

Do not just describe Anglo-Saxon and Norman justice side by side. Explain why things changed, such as the king’s need for control, and add an aspect of your own, such as Henry II’s reforms.

16 marks + 4 SPaG / Religion and new crimes, c1500 to c1700Edexcel

‘Religious change was the main reason why new crimes were defined in the period c1500–c1700.’

How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: heresy; vagabondage. You must also use information of your own.

What a full answer includes
  • For: each change of official religion (Henry VIII, Edward VI, Mary I, Elizabeth I) redefined heresy and treason, so worship could become a crime.
  • For: after Catholic plots, laws fined and imprisoned people who kept up Catholic worship; the Gunpowder Plot (1605) led to more laws against Catholics.
  • For: witchcraft became a crime (Acts of 1542, 1563 and 1604), linked to religious fears of the Devil; James I wrote on witchcraft.
  • Against: vagabondage was made a crime because of economic and social change: population growth, rising prices and unemployment.
  • Against: Tudor governments feared disorder from wandering poor people and punished them with whipping and houses of correction.
  • Against: witchcraft accusations also came from social tensions and misfortune, peaking in the upheaval of the Civil War (Hopkins, 1645–47).
  • Links: the closure of the monasteries, a religious change, removed charity for the poor and added to vagabondage.
  • A judgement with a clear criterion.

Model answer

Religious change was a major reason why new crimes appeared in this period. Henry VIII broke with Rome in the 1530s, Edward VI made the Church more Protestant, Mary I restored Catholicism and Elizabeth I set up a Protestant Church in 1559. With each change the line between loyal worship and heresy moved, so beliefs that were the law under one monarch could be heresy or treason under the next. Under Mary about 280 Protestants were burned as heretics. Because the monarch was head of the Church, refusing to accept the official religion was also seen as disloyalty. After Catholic plots against Elizabeth, Parliament passed harsh laws fining and imprisoning those who kept up Catholic worship, and after the Gunpowder Plot of 1605 further laws were passed against Catholics. Religion also lay behind the new crime of witchcraft. Witchcraft Acts were passed in 1542, 1563 and 1604. Many people believed witches worked with the Devil, and James I was so interested that he wrote a book on the subject. This belief made witchcraft a serious crime that could lead to execution. However, vagabondage was made a crime for mainly economic and social reasons. The population grew, prices rose, and changes in farming such as enclosure left many people without work, so they wandered in search of jobs or begged. Governments feared that groups of wandering poor would cause crime and rebellion. Tudor laws punished vagabonds with whipping, and houses of correction set them to hard labour. Even here religion played a part, because the closure of the monasteries between 1536 and 1541 removed a major source of charity for the poor. Witchcraft accusations also had social causes: the accused were usually poor, elderly women blamed for misfortunes such as a child’s death, and the worst outbreak, led by Matthew Hopkins in 1645 to 1647, came during the disorder of the Civil War. Overall, I agree that religious change was the main reason. Vagabondage shows that economic change created new crimes too. But most of the new crimes of the period, heresy, new forms of treason, recusancy and witchcraft, came directly from religious change, and religion also contributed to vagabondage through the dissolution of the monasteries. Religion affected the definition of more crimes than any other factor, so it was the main reason.

Where marks slip

Answers that only describe heresy and vagabondage stay low. Use your own examples too, such as witchcraft, and reach a judgement with a clear reason, such as how many new crimes each factor explains.

9 marks / Law enforcement, c1250 to c1500OCR B (Schools History Project)

Write a clear and organised summary that analyses how law enforcement worked in the period c.1250–c.1500. Support your summary with examples.

What a full answer includes
  • An organising idea: enforcement relied mainly on the local community, with the Crown and the Church playing growing parts.
  • Community: men were grouped in tithings, and everyone had to join the hue and cry to chase a suspect.
  • Community: the Statute of Winchester (1285) made towns appoint watchmen and each area have unpaid parish constables.
  • Crown: Justices of the Peace (from the 1300s) arrested suspects and heard cases; royal judges tried serious crimes at the assizes.
  • Church: Church courts tried clergy, and benefit of clergy and sanctuary let some escape the king’s courts.
  • Overall: there was no police force; enforcement depended on ordinary people, which worked in small communities but less well in growing towns.

Model answer

Law enforcement in this period depended mainly on the local community, with the Crown and the Church taking smaller but growing parts. Community responsibility was the base of the system. Men were grouped in tithings and had to bring any member who broke the law to court. When a crime was discovered, people raised the hue and cry, and everyone who heard had to help chase the suspect. The Statute of Winchester of 1285 strengthened this: towns had to have watchmen on the gates at night, and householders took turns as unpaid parish constables, who arrested suspects and brought them to court. The Crown played a bigger role over time. From the 1300s Justices of the Peace, respected local landowners appointed by the king, arrested suspects, heard less serious cases and sent serious ones on. Royal judges travelled to county towns to try serious crimes such as murder at the assizes, with local juries. The Church had its own system. Church courts tried clergy and did not hang people, so anyone who could read a verse from the Bible could claim benefit of clergy. A fugitive who reached a church could claim sanctuary for about 40 days. Overall, there was no police force, so enforcement relied on ordinary people. This worked well in small villages where everyone knew each other, but it was less effective in growing towns.

Where marks slip

Unorganised description stays in the lowest level. Pick an organising idea, such as who enforced the law, and keep every example within c.1250 to c.1500.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 41 questions in Show Working

This page shows 40 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE History topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free