Show Working
Open the app

GCSE History · Crime and punishmentAQA, Edexcel, OCR A, OCR B (Schools History Project) and Eduqas

Crime and punishment, c1700 to today: GCSE questions with answers

40 GCSE History questions on this topic. Pick your answer, then tap to see if you were right and why. Every one comes from the Show Working History bank and is checked against the source named under it.

Quiz yourself: 40 questions 6 exam questions

01 / Quiz yourselfTry it, then tap to check

Crime and punishment, c1700 to today questions to try

Choose your answer before you open it. Then read why, so it sticks.

01 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

In the 1700s, about how many crimes could be punished by death?

  1. AMore than 200
  2. BAbout 5
  3. CAbout 20
  4. DAbout 50
Show the answer

Answer: A More than 200

In the 1700s more than 200 offences carried the death penalty, many of them property crimes. This Bloody Code relied on fear of the gallows to deter crime, because there was no police force to catch criminals.

Checked against parliament.uk

02 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

At the Old Bailey from 1810 to 1837, about what share of people sentenced to death were actually executed?

  1. AAlmost all of them
  2. BAbout half
  3. CAbout one in ten
  4. DAbout three quarters
Show the answer

Answer: C About one in ten

Juries often gave partial verdicts, valuing goods low so the crime was no longer capital, and most convicts sentenced to death were pardoned, usually on condition of transportation. From 1810 to 1837 only about one in ten was hanged, so the Bloody Code was harsher on paper than in practice.

Checked against digitalpanopticon.org

03 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Why was highway robbery treated as a particularly serious crime?

  1. AIt was a crime against the Church
  2. BIt stopped people travelling freely
  3. CIt only happened in London
  4. DIt was always carried out by soldiers
Show the answer

Answer: B It stopped people travelling freely

Robbing travellers on the roads threatened trade and travel. Better policing, road transport, banking and credit made mounted robbers disappear by the late 1820s; the last series of highway robbery trials at the Old Bailey was in 1830.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

04 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

In the 1700s, smuggling meant dealing in goods on which:

  1. Athe price was set by law
  2. Bno import duty had been paid
  3. Cthe Church claimed a tenth
  4. Dthe king’s seal had been forged
Show the answer

Answer: B no import duty had been paid

High import duties on goods such as tea and brandy made smuggling profitable. Many people happily bought cheap smuggled goods, so, like poaching, it is often seen as a social crime.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

05 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

The Black Act of 1723 was passed in response to poachers who:

  1. Adressed as priests
  2. Bused black dogs
  3. Cblackened their faces as a disguise
  4. Dhunted only at Christmas
Show the answer

Answer: C blackened their faces as a disguise

The Black Act made being armed in a group with a blackened face, and several other offences, capital crimes. It is a famous example of the Bloody Code growing to protect property. It was repealed in 1823.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

06 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Which law of 1718 let judges sentence criminals to transportation to the American colonies?

  1. AThe Black Act
  2. BThe Transportation Act
  3. CThe Murder Act
  4. DThe Gaols Act
Show the answer

Answer: B The Transportation Act

The Transportation Act of 1718 made transportation a standard punishment. From then until 1775 transportation to North America was the most common sentence at the Old Bailey.

Checked against parliament.uk

07 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Why did Britain begin sending convicts to Australia?

  1. APrisons in Britain had all closed
  2. BThe Church ran the colony
  3. CAustralia had asked Britain for more workers
  4. DAmerica would no longer take them
Show the answer

Answer: D America would no longer take them

The American Revolution of 1776 ended transportation to America. Prisons filled up, so old ships moored on the Thames (the hulks) were used, and in May 1787 the First Fleet sailed to set up a penal colony in Australia.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

08 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

About how many convicts were transported to Australia altogether?

  1. AAbout 160,000
  2. BAbout 16,000
  3. CAbout 1.6 million
  4. DAbout 1,600
Show the answer

Answer: A About 160,000

Over 80 years about 160,000 convicts were sent to Australia, usually for 7 or 14 years or for life. It had become unusual long before the last convicts were sent in 1868, and prisons in Britain took its place.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

09 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEdexcel

In 1834 the Tolpuddle Martyrs were convicted of:

  1. Asmuggling French brandy
  2. Bpoaching deer in a royal forest
  3. Cswearing an unlawful oath
  4. Drobbing a mail coach
Show the answer

Answer: C swearing an unlawful oath

Six Dorset farm labourers who formed a trade union were convicted at Dorchester in 1834 of administering an unlawful oath and transported for seven years. Many saw the law being used to crush workers, and huge petitions followed.

Checked against api.parliament.uk

10 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEdexcel

What happened to the Tolpuddle Martyrs in 1836?

  1. AThey became Members of Parliament
  2. BThey were hanged in Dorchester
  3. CThey were sent to the hulks
  4. DThey were given a free pardon
Show the answer

Answer: D They were given a free pardon

After petitions and debates in Parliament, the Home Secretary announced in March 1836 that the King had granted all of them a free pardon. The case shows public opinion changing how the law was used.

Checked against api.parliament.uk

11 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

What did the Witchcraft Act of 1736 do?

  1. AOrdered a new hunt for witches
  2. BMoved witch trials to Church courts
  3. CMade witchcraft a capital crime
  4. DRepealed the laws against witchcraft
Show the answer

Answer: D Repealed the laws against witchcraft

Witch trials had already died out: the last known execution was in 1685 and the last trials in 1717. The 1736 Act ended witchcraft as a crime, fining or jailing only those who claimed magical powers.

Checked against parliament.uk

12 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Who set up the Bow Street Runners in 1749?

  1. ARobert Peel
  2. BCharles Warren
  3. CJohn Howard
  4. DHenry Fielding
Show the answer

Answer: D Henry Fielding

Henry Fielding, a magistrate, hired thief-takers and former constables as the Bow Street Runners in 1749. His half-brother John Fielding added a criminal intelligence network and patrols of the main roads. They are an early step towards professional policing.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

13 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

What was a thief-taker in the 1700s?

  1. AA judge who heard theft cases at the Old Bailey
  2. BA priest who visited condemned prisoners
  3. CSomeone who caught criminals for reward money
  4. DA gaoler who guarded thieves
Show the answer

Answer: C Someone who caught criminals for reward money

With no police force, the government offered rewards for convicting serious criminals, and thief-takers made a living from them. Some were corrupt: Jonathan Wild ran thieves while posing as a thief-taker and was hanged in 1725.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

14 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Robert Peel became Home Secretary in which year?

  1. A1749
  2. B1777
  3. C1822
  4. D1856
Show the answer

Answer: C 1822

As Home Secretary from 1822, Peel reformed both prisons and policing. His Gaols Act of 1823 brought chaplains’ visits, paid gaolers, women warders for women, a ban on irons, and reports to the Home Secretary.

Checked against parliament.uk

15 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

The Metropolitan Police was set up in:

  1. A1749
  2. B1801
  3. C1829
  4. D1856
Show the answer

Answer: C 1829

Peel’s Metropolitan Police Act of 1829 created a uniformed force of about 3,000 men under the Home Secretary. Officers walked set beats to prevent crime. They were nicknamed “Bobbies” or “Peelers” after Robert Peel.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

16 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

What did the Rural Constabulary (County Police) Act of 1839 do?

  1. AMade every county and borough have a paid police force
  2. BLet counties set up police forces if they wished
  3. CAbolished the Metropolitan Police
  4. DPut all police under the army
Show the answer

Answer: B Let counties set up police forces if they wished

In 1839 counties could choose to set up forces; Wiltshire was the first. Many did not, because of the cost, so the 1856 Act made policing compulsory everywhere, with inspectors reporting to the Home Secretary.

Checked against parliament.uk

17 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Put these developments in policing in order, earliest first.

  1. APolice forces become compulsory everywhere
  2. BThe Metropolitan Police is created
  3. CThe Bow Street Runners are set up
  4. DCounties may set up their own forces
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. The Bow Street Runners are set up
  2. The Metropolitan Police is created
  3. Counties may set up their own forces
  4. Police forces become compulsory everywhere

Bow Street Runners 1749; Metropolitan Police 1829; counties allowed to set up forces 1839; forces compulsory across England and Wales 1856. Policing moved from local and voluntary to professional and national.

Checked against parliament.uk

18 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

How big was the Metropolitan Police’s first detective force in 1842?

  1. ATwo hundred detectives
  2. BHalf of all London’s police
  3. CTwo inspectors and six sergeants
  4. DOne officer in each county
Show the answer

Answer: C Two inspectors and six sergeants

A tiny detective force was set up in 1842. After leading detectives were put on trial in 1877, in the Turf Fraud scandal, the department was reorganised as the Criminal Investigation Department (CID), with about 250 men.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

19 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

In 1902, the Old Bailey saw its first successful prosecution using:

  1. Afingerprints
  2. Bphotographs
  3. CDNA
  4. DCCTV
Show the answer

Answer: A fingerprints

In 1902 Harry Jackson was convicted of burglary using fingerprint evidence, and in 1905 fingerprints helped convict two brothers of murder. Science began to change detective work in the early 1900s.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

20 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Public executions in Britain were abolished in:

  1. A1783
  2. B1823
  3. C1868
  4. D1908
Show the answer

Answer: C 1868

Hangings were meant to deter, but the crowds and the procession to Tyburn caused disorder. In 1783 hangings moved to outside Newgate, and in 1868 public executions were abolished; hangings then took place inside prisons.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

21 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

By the 1840s, for which crime were people actually executed?

  1. AShoplifting
  2. BMurder
  3. CForgery
  4. DSheep stealing
Show the answer

Answer: B Murder

From 1808 the death penalty was removed from crime after crime, especially in the 1820s and 1830s. By the 1840s almost everyone executed had been convicted of murder: the Bloody Code had ended.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

22 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

In 1777 John Howard published a book about:

  1. Athe Bow Street Runners
  2. Bthe state of prisons
  3. Cthe dangers of gin
  4. Dtransportation to Australia
Show the answer

Answer: B the state of prisons

Howard toured prisons in Britain and Europe, and his 1777 book The State of the Prisons shocked readers. He wanted tough but healthy prisons that would reform prisoners, and the 1779 Penitentiary Act was based on his ideas.

Checked against parliament.uk

23 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Elizabeth Fry is best known for her work with which prisoners?

  1. AWomen in Newgate prison
  2. BConvicts in Australia
  3. CDebtors in the Fleet
  4. DSoldiers in army jails
Show the answer

Answer: A Women in Newgate prison

Elizabeth Fry visited the women prisoners in Newgate and set up a society to reform female prisoners, giving them work and teaching. Her reports of the work were read in Britain and abroad, and she helped push for prison reform.

Checked against discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk

24 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Under the separate system, how were prisoners stopped from seeing each other outside their cells?

  1. AThey were blindfolded at all times
  2. BThey wore masks or sat in special seats
  3. CThey were kept in darkness all day
  4. DThey never left their cells at all
Show the answer

Answer: B They wore masks or sat in special seats

The idea was that, alone with their thoughts and the Bible, prisoners would face up to their crimes and reform. Wearing masks and sitting in separate seats in chapel kept them isolated, but some prisoners broke down mentally under the strain.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

25 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

“Hard labour, hard fare and hard board” described which prison regime?

  1. ABorstals
  2. BThe silent system
  3. CThe separate system
  4. DOpen prisons
Show the answer

Answer: B The silent system

By the 1860s the aim shifted to deterrence. Under the silent system, linked to Sir Edmund du Cane, prisoners kept total silence and did pointless hard labour such as the treadwheel, the crank or picking oakum, ate dull food and slept on boards.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

26 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

The Prisons Act of 1877 gave complete control of prisons to:

  1. Athe Church of England
  2. Bthe Home Office
  3. Cprivate companies
  4. Dlocal JPs
Show the answer

Answer: B the Home Office

Since the Gaols Act of 1823 the government had slowly taken more control of prisons. The 1877 Act transferred them fully from local authorities to the Home Office, and prisons became harsher, to deter crime.

Checked against parliament.uk

27 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Recorded offences rose between 1800 and 1840 from about 5,000 a year to about:

  1. A2 million a year
  2. B6,000 a year
  3. C20,000 a year
  4. D500 a year
Show the answer

Answer: C 20,000 a year

Recorded crime rose about fourfold in the first half of the 1800s as towns grew fast after the Industrial Revolution. Fear of crime in the cities pushed the government to reform the police and build more prisons.

Checked against nationalarchives.gov.uk

28 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

The first prison for young offenders opened in 1902 in a Kent village, which gave its name to:

  1. Aborstals
  2. Bworkhouses
  3. CBridewells
  4. Dhulks
Show the answer

Answer: A borstals

A government report in 1895 said young offenders should be kept apart from adults. After the first one opened at Borstal in Kent in 1902, the 1908 Act created borstals nationwide, with hard work plus education and training.

Checked against parliament.uk

29 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Which law of 1907 created a system for supervising offenders in the community instead of prison?

  1. AThe Penal Servitude Act
  2. BThe Murder Act
  3. CThe Gaols Act
  4. DThe Probation of Offenders Act
Show the answer

Answer: D The Probation of Offenders Act

The Probation of Offenders Act 1907 let courts release offenders under the supervision of a probation officer. It was an early non-custodial alternative to prison, focused on reform rather than punishment.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

30 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Which Act of 1948 abolished hard labour, penal servitude and whipping as sentences?

  1. AThe Police Act
  2. BThe Prisons Act
  3. CThe Criminal Justice Act
  4. DThe Witchcraft Act
Show the answer

Answer: C The Criminal Justice Act

The Criminal Justice Act 1948 ended hard labour and penal servitude and abolished whipping as a sentence. It shows a twentieth-century shift towards reforming offenders rather than making them suffer.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

31 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

A community service order, introduced by the Criminal Justice Act 1972, requires an offender to:

  1. Alive in an open prison
  2. Bpay money to the police
  3. Cdo unpaid work in the community
  4. Dleave the country
Show the answer

Answer: C do unpaid work in the community

The 1972 Act let courts order offenders aged 17 or over to do between 40 and 240 hours of unpaid work instead of going to prison. It aims to repay the community and keep offenders out of prison.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

32 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

In which year did Parliament abolish the death penalty for murder in Great Britain?

  1. A1868
  2. B1908
  3. C1948
  4. D1965
Show the answer

Answer: D 1965

The Murder (Abolition of Death Penalty) Act 1965 replaced hanging for murder with a life sentence, at first for a trial period of five years. In December 1969 Parliament voted to make abolition permanent.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

33 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Put these changes to punishment in order, earliest first.

  1. AWhipping and hard labour are abolished
  2. BPublic executions are abolished
  3. CThe death penalty for murder is abolished
  4. DA national system of borstals begins
Show the answer

The right order:

  1. Public executions are abolished
  2. A national system of borstals begins
  3. Whipping and hard labour are abolished
  4. The death penalty for murder is abolished

Public executions ended in 1868, borstals spread nationally after the 1908 Act, whipping and hard labour went in 1948, and hanging for murder was abolished in 1965. Punishment moved from public pain towards reform.

Checked against oldbaileyonline.org

34 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Which Act of 1990 made hacking into computers a crime?

  1. AThe Data Act
  2. BThe Police Act
  3. CThe Criminal Justice Act
  4. DThe Computer Misuse Act
Show the answer

Answer: D The Computer Misuse Act

New technology brings new crimes. The Computer Misuse Act 1990 made it an offence to get into computer material without permission, an example of the law changing to define new crimes in modern Britain.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

35 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Who developed DNA fingerprinting at the University of Leicester in 1984?

  1. AAlexander Fleming
  2. BRobert Peel
  3. CAlec Jeffreys
  4. DCharles Booth
Show the answer

Answer: C Alec Jeffreys

Alec Jeffreys discovered DNA fingerprinting in 1984. It lets police match suspects to traces left at a crime scene, one of the biggest ways science has changed policing.

Checked against le.ac.uk

36 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

The Police Reform Act 2002 introduced which new role?

  1. AParish constables
  2. BPolice community support officers
  3. CSpecial Branch officers
  4. DBow Street Runners
Show the answer

Answer: B Police community support officers

PCSOs patrol neighbourhoods, a modern sign of the move towards community policing and crime prevention. Over the 1900s police forces also merged into fewer, larger forces, especially after the Police Acts of 1946 and 1964.

Checked against parliament.uk

37 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Women first joined the police in Britain during:

  1. Athe First World War
  2. Bthe 1820s
  3. Cthe 1960s
  4. Dthe reign of Elizabeth I
Show the answer

Answer: A the First World War

Women first joined the police as volunteers at the start of the First World War, when many policemen left to join the army. They were not fully integrated into the police until 1973.

Checked against parliament.uk

38 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

What were the hulks?

  1. AOld ships used as floating prisons
  2. BCourts held in country towns
  3. CCells under the House of Lords
  4. DPatrols on the main roads
Show the answer

Answer: A Old ships used as floating prisons

When transportation to America stopped, decommissioned ships moored on the Thames held convicts, who were put to hard labour on the docks and dredging the river. A temporary fix became a long-running part of the system.

Checked against parliament.uk

39 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

Which law of 1971 is the main law controlling harmful drugs?

  1. AThe Black Act
  2. BThe Misuse of Drugs Act
  3. CThe Prevention of Crime Act
  4. DThe Computer Misuse Act
Show the answer

Answer: B The Misuse of Drugs Act

The Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 controls dangerous or harmful drugs and also set up an advisory council on them. Drug crime is one of the changing definitions of crime in the twentieth century.

Checked against legislation.gov.uk

40 / Crime and punishment, c1700 to todayEvery board with this unit

The 1965 Act abolished hanging for murder at first for a trial period. What did Parliament do in December 1969?

  1. AAllowed hanging for theft again
  2. BBrought hanging back for murder
  3. CMade the abolition permanent
  4. DExtended the trial by one year
Show the answer

Answer: C Made the abolition permanent

The 1965 Act was due to expire unless Parliament decided otherwise. In December 1969 both Houses voted that it should not expire, so the abolition of the death penalty for murder became permanent.

Checked against api.parliament.uk

02 / Exam questionsMarked by levels

Exam questions on this topic

Write your answer first, on paper. Then open it and tick off the points you made. The marks are as on that board’s paper.

16 marks + 4 SPaG / Why policing changed, c1700 to c1900Edexcel

‘The growth of towns was the main reason for changes in policing in the period c1700–c1900.’

How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the Bow Street Runners; the Metropolitan Police Act 1829. You must also use information of your own.

What a full answer includes
  • For: towns grew fast in the Industrial Revolution and recorded crime rose about fourfold in the first half of the 1800s.
  • For: unpaid constables and night watchmen could not cope in crowded towns where people did not know each other.
  • For: London’s size explains the Bow Street Runners (1749) and the Metropolitan Police (1829) coming there first.
  • Against: individuals mattered: Henry and John Fielding set up the Runners; Robert Peel, as Home Secretary, pushed through the 1829 Act.
  • Against: government fear of protest and disorder, and weakening objections to state power, led to the 1839 and 1856 Acts (compulsory forces everywhere).
  • Against: attitudes shaped the police: fear of a French-style force meant blue uniforms and no guns.
  • Against: detectives (1842) and the CID (1878) came from the need to solve crimes, and scandal.
  • A judgement with a clear criterion.

Model answer

The growth of towns was an important reason for changes in policing. During the Industrial Revolution people moved into towns and cities in huge numbers, and London became the largest city in the world. Recorded crime rose about fourfold in the first half of the 1800s. The old system of unpaid parish constables and night watchmen had worked in villages where everyone knew each other, but it could not cope in crowded cities where strangers could disappear. This is why the first changes happened in London. In 1749 the magistrate Henry Fielding set up the Bow Street Runners, paid thief-takers who caught criminals, and in 1829 the Metropolitan Police Act created a uniformed force of about 3,000 officers for London. However, the growth of towns only created the need for change. Individuals made it happen. Henry Fielding and his half-brother John created the Runners and built up a network of information on criminals. Robert Peel, as Home Secretary, overcame opposition to get the 1829 Act through Parliament, and his officers became known as Bobbies or Peelers. Without his determination, London might have waited much longer. Government attitudes were also important. Many people feared that a police force would be used by the government against ordinary people, as in France, so the new police wore blue rather than military red and carried only truncheons. Gradually fears of disorder and protest outweighed these worries. In 1839 counties were allowed to set up forces, and when many did not because of the cost, the 1856 County and Borough Police Act made forces compulsory everywhere. The police also changed their methods: a detective department was set up in 1842 and reorganised as the Criminal Investigation Department in 1878 after a corruption scandal. Overall, I agree that the growth of towns was the main reason. Individuals such as Peel and government decisions explain when and how the police were created, but they were responding to the problem of crime in fast-growing towns. If towns had not grown, there would have been no reason to replace the old system of constables and watchmen, which had lasted for centuries.

Where marks slip

Many answers describe the Bow Street Runners and the Met in detail but never weigh the growth of towns against other factors. Explain the link between each change and the factor that caused it, then judge.

12 marks / Why the Bloody Code endedEdexcel

Explain why the Bloody Code came to an end in the period c1700–c1900. You may use the following in your answer: the work of Robert Peel; transportation. You must also use information of your own.

What a full answer includes
  • The Bloody Code made over 200 crimes, many against property, punishable by death.
  • Juries often refused to convict or valued goods low so the crime was no longer capital, so the code did not work as a deterrent.
  • Reformers argued that punishment should be certain and fair rather than savage, and campaigned to cut capital crimes from 1808.
  • Peel, as Home Secretary in the 1820s, removed the death penalty for over 100 crimes and created the Metropolitan Police (1829), so deterrence could rest on catching criminals.
  • Transportation, and later prisons, gave courts an alternative to hanging.
  • By the 1840s almost everyone executed had committed murder, and in 1861 capital crimes were cut to a handful.

Model answer

One reason the Bloody Code ended was that it did not work. By the late 1700s more than 200 crimes, many of them minor property crimes, carried the death penalty. The idea was to deter crime by fear, because there was no police force to catch criminals. But many people thought it unfair to hang someone for stealing goods of small value, so juries often refused to convict, or valued stolen goods below the amount that made the crime capital. Many convicts were pardoned. This meant the code was harsher on paper than in practice, and its deterrent effect was weakened. A second reason was the work of reformers and of Robert Peel. Reformers argued that punishment should be certain and fair rather than savage, and from 1808 Parliament began to remove the death penalty from crimes such as pickpocketing. As Home Secretary in the 1820s, Peel removed the death penalty for over 100 crimes. He also set up the Metropolitan Police in 1829. With professional police making it more likely that criminals would be caught, the government no longer needed to rely on the terror of the gallows. A third reason was that there were other punishments available. Transportation became a standard punishment after the Transportation Act of 1718, and from 1787 convicts were sent to Australia. It removed criminals from Britain without killing them, so judges could use it instead of hanging. As transportation declined, new prisons such as Pentonville, opened in 1842, offered another alternative. By the 1840s almost everyone executed had been convicted of murder, and in 1861 the number of capital crimes was cut to just a few, including murder and treason.

Where marks slip

Do not write about the Bloody Code itself for too long. Most marks come from explaining why it ended, using three different reasons, one of them your own.

10 marks / Why prisons were reformedOCR B (Schools History Project)

Why were prisons reformed in the period c.1750–c.1900? Explain your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • Reformers exposed bad conditions: John Howard’s The State of the Prisons (1777) and Elizabeth Fry’s work at Newgate from 1813.
  • Their Christian beliefs led them to argue that prisons should reform prisoners, not just hold them.
  • Prisons were needed more as the Bloody Code ended and transportation declined (to America by 1775, to Australia by 1868).
  • Government took more control: Peel’s Gaols Act (1823) and the 1877 Act that put all prisons under the Home Office.
  • Ideas about the purpose of prison changed: the separate system at Pentonville (1842) aimed at reform; the silent system and hard labour later aimed at deterrence.

Model answer

One reason prisons were reformed was the work of reformers who exposed conditions. In the 1700s gaols mostly held people awaiting trial or in debt, and they were dirty, crowded and run for profit by gaolers. John Howard visited prisons across Britain and Europe, and his book The State of the Prisons (1777) shocked readers. From 1813 Elizabeth Fry visited the women prisoners in Newgate, gave them work and teaching, and publicised what she had done. Both were driven by Christian belief that prisoners could be reformed, which persuaded many people that prisons should change. A second reason was that prisons were needed for more people. Transportation to America ended with the American Revolution, and as the Bloody Code was dismantled in the 1820s and 1830s, fewer people were hanged. Transportation to Australia also declined until it ended in 1868. Courts needed somewhere to send convicts, so prison became the main punishment, and the government had to build and run prisons properly. A third reason was that the government took more responsibility and changed its views on what prisons were for. Peel’s Gaols Act of 1823 introduced paid gaolers, chaplains’ visits and women warders for women prisoners. At Pentonville, opened in 1842, the separate system kept prisoners alone to reflect and reform. Later, the silent system and hard labour aimed to deter crime, and the 1877 Prisons Act put all prisons under the Home Office.

Where marks slip

Describing prison conditions or famous reformers is not enough. Show why each factor led to reform, and make it clear how changes in other punishments made prisons more important.

18 marks / When did punishment change most?OCR B (Schools History Project)

‘Punishments changed more in the period c.1750–c.1900 than in any other period since c.1250.’

How far do you agree with this statement? Give reasons for your answer.

What a full answer includes
  • For: the Bloody Code reached its height and then ended; by the 1840s almost everyone executed was a murderer.
  • For: public executions ended in 1868, moving hanging inside prisons.
  • For: transportation to Australia (1787 to 1868) rose and fell, and prison became the main punishment (Pentonville, 1842; national control, 1877).
  • Against: c.1500–c.1750 brought new punishments too: transportation to the colonies, houses of correction and a growing number of capital crimes.
  • Against: c.1900–present saw the abolition of the death penalty for murder (1965, permanent from 1969), borstals, probation (1907), the end of hard labour and whipping (1948) and community service (1972).
  • Against: some things continued throughout, such as fines and imprisonment.
  • A judgement with a clear criterion, such as how far the purpose of punishment changed.

Model answer

There is strong evidence that punishments changed most between c.1750 and c.1900. In the 1700s the Bloody Code made more than 200 crimes punishable by death, and hangings were public events watched by large crowds. By the 1840s almost everyone executed had been convicted of murder, and in 1868 public executions ended, so hangings took place out of sight inside prisons. Transportation also rose and fell in this period: from 1787 about 160,000 convicts were sent to Australia, but it ended in 1868. In their place, prison became the main punishment for serious crime. Pentonville opened in 1842 with its separate system, and in 1877 the government took control of all prisons. This was a change in the whole purpose of punishment, from public pain meant to terrify others to long sentences meant to reform or deter. However, other periods also saw big changes. Between c.1500 and c.1750 transportation began, first to America from 1614, and houses of correction set vagrants to hard labour, while the number of capital crimes started to rise. Since c.1900 the changes have arguably been just as great. Hanging for murder was abolished in 1965, and permanently in 1969, ending a punishment used for centuries. Young offenders were treated differently, with borstals from 1902 and probation from 1907. Hard labour and whipping were abolished in 1948, and community service orders came in 1972. These changes show a new focus on rehabilitation and on keeping some offenders out of prison altogether. There was also continuity across all periods: fines, and some form of imprisonment, were used throughout. Overall, I agree with the statement. The twentieth century made important changes, especially ending the death penalty, but it built on what had happened before 1900, when prison had already replaced execution and transportation as the main punishment. The period c.1750 to c.1900 changed not just individual punishments but the whole idea of what punishment was for, so it saw the greatest change.

Where marks slip

Writing only about c.1750 to c.1900 cannot reach the top levels. You need developed examples from at least one other period, and a reason for your judgement.

9 marks / Why the death penalty was abolishedEduqas

Explain why the death penalty for murder was abolished in the twentieth century.

What a full answer includes
  • Controversial cases raised doubts: Timothy Evans was hanged in 1950 and later pardoned; Derek Bentley was hanged in 1953 though he had not fired the shot; Ruth Ellis was hanged in 1955.
  • These cases showed the risk of executing innocent or less guilty people, which could never be put right.
  • There was little evidence that hanging deterred murder more than prison.
  • Attitudes changed: punishment came to focus more on reform than revenge.
  • Campaigners and MPs pushed for change; the 1957 Homicide Act limited hanging, and the 1965 Act ended it for murder, made permanent in 1969.

Model answer

One reason the death penalty was abolished was a series of controversial cases. In 1950 Timothy Evans was hanged for murdering his daughter, but it later emerged that John Christie, who lived in the same house, was a serial killer, and Evans was given a pardon in 1966. In January 1953 Derek Bentley was hanged for a murder in which his co-defendant fired the fatal shot, even though the jury recommended mercy. In 1955 Ruth Ellis became the last woman to be hanged in Britain. These cases worried many people, because a wrongful execution could never be put right. A second reason was changing attitudes to punishment. In the twentieth century more people believed punishment should aim to reform offenders rather than take revenge. There was also little evidence that hanging deterred murderers more than a long prison sentence, since many murders were committed in anger or by people who did not expect to be caught. A third reason was political action. Campaigners and MPs from different parties argued for abolition for years. The Homicide Act of 1957 limited the death penalty to certain kinds of murder, and the last executions took place in August 1964. In 1965 the Murder (Abolition of Death Penalty) Act replaced hanging with life imprisonment for a trial period, and Parliament made this permanent in 1969.

Where marks slip

A list of famous cases is not an explanation. Say why each case, or each change in attitudes, made abolition more likely.

16 marks + 4 SPaG / Policing from c500 to todayEduqas

Outline how methods of policing have changed from c.500 to the present day.

What a full answer includes
  • Medieval: policing was a community duty: tithings, the hue and cry, and later unpaid parish constables and watchmen (Statute of Winchester, 1285).
  • Medieval: the king’s officials, such as sheriffs, and from the 1300s Justices of the Peace, took a growing role.
  • Early modern: still unpaid constables and town watchmen; communities and victims had to catch criminals themselves.
  • Eighteenth century: thief-takers worked for rewards; the Bow Street Runners (1749) were a step towards paid police.
  • Nineteenth century: the Metropolitan Police (1829), county forces (1839, compulsory from 1856), detectives (1842) and the CID (1878).
  • Twentieth century to today: science and technology (fingerprints, radios and cars, computers, DNA from the 1980s, CCTV), women officers and community policing such as Neighbourhood Watch (1982) and PCSOs.
  • Overall: from amateur community policing to professional, scientific forces, with the biggest change in the 1800s.

Model answer

In the medieval period policing was mainly the job of the community. In Anglo-Saxon England men were grouped into tithings of about ten, and if one broke the law the others had to bring him to court. When a crime was discovered, people raised the hue and cry and everyone had to join the chase. After the Norman Conquest the king’s officials, such as sheriffs, took more responsibility. The Statute of Winchester of 1285 required towns to have watchmen at night and areas to have parish constables, who were unpaid householders taking turns. From the 1300s Justices of the Peace, local landowners, arrested suspects and dealt with minor cases. In the early modern period, from about 1500 to 1750, there was a great deal of continuity. Policing was still done by unpaid constables and town watchmen, and victims often had to track down criminals themselves. As towns grew this became less effective, and in the early 1700s thief-takers caught criminals for government rewards, though some, like Jonathan Wild, were corrupt. In the modern period policing changed completely. In 1749 Henry Fielding set up the Bow Street Runners in London, paid men who caught criminals. In 1829 Robert Peel’s Metropolitan Police Act created a uniformed, professional force for London, whose officers walked set beats to prevent crime. Counties were allowed to set up forces in 1839 and made to do so by the 1856 Act. Detective work began with a detective department in 1842, which became the Criminal Investigation Department in 1878. In the twentieth century science and technology changed police methods. Fingerprints were used from 1901, and police later used radios, cars, computers and, from the 1980s, DNA evidence, as well as CCTV. Women joined the police from the First World War. Communities were brought back into policing through Neighbourhood Watch from 1982 and, more recently, Police Community Support Officers. Overall, policing changed from an amateur duty shared by the community to a professional service using science. The greatest change came in the nineteenth century, but the idea that the community should help the police has continued throughout.

Where marks slip

Give each era a fair share and keep the focus on policing, not punishment. A narrative that never says what changed and what stayed the same misses the point of the question.

03 / In the appShow Working

All 45 questions in Show Working

This page shows 40 of them. In the app, choose your exam board and units and you only see what your exam asks for. Tap through questions, or open Read the answers to see the whole topic at once, covered until you tap.

More GCSE History topics

Our own questions, written for every board. Show Working is independent and not affiliated with any exam board.

Show WorkingFree on the App StoreFree in your browser, no download

Open it free